Transport Woes...

MRT services interrupted on Circle Line due to train fault during morning peak hour​

Crowds seen at Serangoon MRT station on May 20.

Crowds seen at Serangoon MRT station (left) and Caldecott MRT station during a train delay on May 20.PHOTOS: ST READERS

Fatimah Mujibah
May 20, 2025


SINGAPORE - Train services have fully resumed after a train fault between Paya Lebar and Buona Vista on the Circle Line (CCL) caused a delay during the morning peak hour on May 20.

In a post on X at about 8.30am, SMRT advised passengers to add 30 minutes of travel time to their morning commute.

About 10 minutes later, SMRT said in an update that the train fault has been fixed and train services are progressively resuming. Soon after, SMRT said that train services have fully resumed.

Free regular bus services are no longer available.

The Straits Times has contacted SMRT for more information.
 

Track fault on 7-station stretch of East-West Line delays commuters during evening peak hour​

MRT trains are seen on the tracks near Jurong East MRT Station and buses at the bus interchange taken on August 1, 2020.

SMRT advised commuters to factor in 15 minutes more when travelling between Jurong East and Gul Circle stations.PHOTO: ST FILE

Gabrielle Andres
Dec 17, 2024

SINGAPORE – Train commuters in western Singapore were delayed in their journeys during the evening peak hour on Dec 17, when a track fault affected a seven-station stretch on the East-West Line.

In a Facebook post at 7.37pm, operator SMRT advised commuters to factor in 15 minutes more when travelling between Jurong East and Gul Circle stations.

Free regular bus services were available between the two stations, SMRT also said on X.

The delay was subsequently shortened to 10 minutes, before SMRT announced at 8.05pm that normal train services between the two stations had resumed and the free bus services were stopped.

In a Facebook post at 8.45pm, SMRT said a point machine failure occurred near Joo Koon station at about 6.45pm.

A point machine controls train movements at rail junctions when they move from one track to another.

“For the safety of our commuters, trains were moving slower along the affected stretch, resulting in an additional 15 minutes of travel time,” SMRT said.

“Train services remained available in both directions between Jurong East and Gul Circle stations.

“Our staff worked promptly to resolve the fault, and normal train services progressively resumed from 7.50pm. We apologise for the inconvenience caused to your evening commute.”

Ms Ng Pei Fang, a 41-year-old engineer, told The Straits Times she was on a train heading to Buona Vista when she realised it had stopped longer than usual at Redhill station.

She said that an announcement informed passengers that the train ahead had activated the emergency button, but noted that the delay was not very long.

The train then proceeded to Queenstown station. Ms Ng said the train had stopped there for about four or five minutes before it was announced that there had been a train fault and her train was being taken off service.

Passengers were then asked to alight, and some hurriedly made their way towards the exits to the nearest bus stop.

“Some passengers started looking for rides on their phones, or looking for a taxi,” Ms Ng said, adding that she had her husband pick her up at a nearby taxi stand.

She also said she did not see any connecting services or signboards informing commuters about the delay when she left Queenstown station at 7.15pm.

While she acknowledged that SMRT may need time to arrange for alternative transport, she added: “I think it can be reflected faster on social media or via the app for people to take alternative transport.”

The delay on Dec 17 follows two recent disruptions on the Circle Line, which is also operated by SMRT.

A signalling fault affected train service on the 10-station stretch between Farrer Road and Harbourfront stations on Dec 16, while a stalled train at Tai Seng station on Dec 14 led to no train service between Serangoon and Promenade stations – also a 10-stop stretch.

The East-West Line was disrupted for six days from Sept 25 to Sept 30, affecting more than 2.6 million passengers. It is one of the worst breakdowns to affect Singapore’s MRT system in its 37-year history.

Following that, SMRT said in November that it had formed a working group to review the safety and reliability of its rail network.
 

MRT services on TEL back to normal after signal fault resolved​

Trains are moving slower from Woodlands North station and Bayshore station in both directions, on Dec 19.

SMRT said a signalling system fault occurred on the TEL at around 9.10am. ST PHOTO: KELVIN CHNG

Sherlyn Sim
Dec 19, 2024

SINGAPORE - SMRT engineers have resolved a train fault on the Thomson-East Coast Line (TEL), which caused a delay during the morning peak hour on Dec 19.

SMRT first alerted the public about the delay in a post on social media platform X at 9.38am, urging commuters to expect an additional travel time of 10 minutes between Woodlands North and Bayshore stations.

An ST journalist who was on a TEL train towards Woodlands North station said that at around 9.25am, the train stopped at Shenton Way station and remained there for about 15 minutes.

The error message on the display screen said the train was delayed due to an incident. The message was later changed to the train being delayed due to a train fault.

In an update on Facebook at 10.33am, SMRT said a signalling system fault occurred on the TEL at around 9.10am.

“For the safety of our commuters, trains operated at reduced speed,” SMRT said.

“Our engineers have resolved the signalling system fault, and trains are now running at normal speeds,” it added.

“We sincerely apologise for the inconvenience caused to your morning commute.”

In October, a train fault caused a delay on the TEL during the evening peak hour on Oct 1, with trains moving slower from Woodlands North station towards Lentor station.

 
The trains are too crowded.

Commuters in north-east S’pore to get more incentives from Jan 2 to avoid morning peak​

The Travel Smart Journeys incentive scheme will cover four more express bus services, bringing the total to 11.

The Travel Smart Journeys incentive scheme will cover four more express bus services, bringing the total to 11.ST PHOTO: KEVIN LIM

Kok Yufeng
Dec 26, 2024

SINGAPORE – A scheme to encourage public transport users in north-eastern Singapore to change their travel patterns to ease peak-hour train congestion will be expanded from Jan 2.

Those who take selected express bus services instead of the train will get more rebates on their fares on weekday mornings. For the first time, the rebates, which are up to 80 per cent of the fare, will also be extended to train journeys.

These apply when eligible rail passengers from the north-east shift their morning commutes to avoid the most crowded period between 7.15am and 8.45am.

Four more express bus services will be added to the list, bringing the total to 11.

These additional express routes are City Direct Services (CDS) 675, 676, 677 and 678, which will all begin operations on Jan 2.

The programme will also cover CDS 660M, a variant of the existing CDS 660 express route.

The Land Transport Authority (LTA) said on Dec 20 that the initiative is aimed at encouraging passengers to avoid busier segments of the MRT network during the morning rush.

It is an enhancement of the Travel Smart Journeys (TSJ) programme, which awards points to eligible participants. These points can be redeemed for credit.

To help ease the load on the congested North East Line (NEL), the programme was launched in 2020 as a trial and expanded in 2023. It was temporarily suspended on Nov 25 to facilitate systems upgrades.

Before the suspension, there were about 21,400 eligible TSJ participants, with about 1,240 commuters benefiting from rebates totalling $66,000 between March 2023 and November 2024.

In response to queries from The Straits Times, LTA said the cost of the enhanced TSJ scheme, which is government-funded, depends on the take-up. The scheme will not contribute to future fare increases, the authority added.

The biggest change will be the addition of train journeys to the programme: Passengers who start their commutes from Punggol Coast, Punggol, Sengkang, Buangkok or Hougang MRT stations, or any station on the Punggol and Sengkang LRT lines, are eligible for discounts too.

While the focus is now on the north-eastern region, Transport Minister Chee Hong Tat had left the door open for the programme to be expanded to other rail lines in future.

He said during a media interview in early December that the goal is to distribute peak demand on buses and the MRT to help manage crowding and the capacity needed.

In the first half of 2024, the NEL had an average daily ridership of 588,000 passenger trips, 2.2 per cent shy of the 601,000 daily trips made on the line in 2019.

187b443662cd3758093ca4be89d47777ffc9fbf8f89392a9941f883c23bbcf33


Eligibility for Travel Smart Journeys​

To be eligible for the TSJ incentives, passengers must have tapped in at any NEL station between Punggol Coast and Hougang, or any station along the Punggol and Sengkang LRT lines, between 7.15am and 8.45am on at least six working weekdays in the past 30 calendar days.

This is to prove that they regularly travel on these rail lines during the morning peak period.

Asked for the rationale behind this, LTA said TSJ is a targeted scheme, and is not meant to incentivise those already travelling outside the morning peak, or encourage those who travel later in the day to bring their journeys forward.

LTA said using a points system, rather than upfront discounts, is in line with the objective of encouraging consistent, long-term shifts in travel patterns.

This also gives the authority greater flexibility to introduce tailored incentives for other parts of the public transport network in the future.

Active participants of the previous iteration of the TSJ programme will automatically be enrolled in the upgraded scheme from Jan 2.

Inactive users – those who have not earned any TSJ points in the last six months – will receive an e-mail invitation to re-register, but they will need to be eligible to earn points.

Commuters taking the train during off-peak hours at Punggol MRT station on Dec 20, 2024. ST PHOTO KEVIN LIM yftransport20

LTA said that the initiative is aimed at encouraging passengers to avoid busier segments of the MRT network during the morning rush.ST PHOTO: KEVIN LIM
For those not on the scheme yet, they can register for it using the SimplyGo app and add a travel card to their SimplyGo account.

They will then need to nominate a travel card that will be used to check their eligibility, which will be determined within 72 hours, LTA said.

Once enrolled, participants will be able to see how many points they have earned through a revamped dashboard within the SimplyGo app. The accumulated points can then be redeemed in blocks of 500, with the credit going towards the travel card of the passenger’s choosing.

How to calculate discounts under enhanced scheme​

Under the scheme’s earlier format, participants who used eligible express bus services on weekday mornings were awarded points worth $1.50 per trip.

From Jan 2, this will increase to 80 per cent of the journey fare.

In the case of an adult passenger who takes CDS 666 instead of the train from Damai LRT station to Promenade MRT station, he will get an effective fare discount of $2.37 under the upgraded scheme.

For eligible commuters who continue to take the train, they will either get a 40 per cent or 80 per cent rebate on their fares, depending on when they travel.

This is on top of an existing discount of up to 50 cents that is given to those who tap in at MRT stations islandwide before 7.45am on weekdays.

For instance, an adult train passenger who taps in at Sengkang station on a weekday morning and exits at Raffles Place station would normally pay a fare of $1.93.

More on this Topic
S'pore's biggest train and bus depot on course to open in 2026ST Explains: Why are public transport fares going up again?
With the new incentive, if he makes the same MRT journey before 7.15am, he will get an upfront discount of 50 cents plus 114 TSJ points, which are equivalent to $1.14 or 80 per cent of the fare after the 50-cent discount.

If the same passenger taps in after 7.15am but before 7.45am, he will still get an upfront discount of 50 cents, but no points.

If he makes the journey between 9am and 9.30am, there is no upfront fare discount, but he will receive 154 points (80 per cent of $1.93), effectively bringing the fare down to 39 cents.

For the periods between 8.45am and 9am, and between 9.30am and 9.45am, the points received will be 40 per cent of the fare, which, in this example, is 77 points. Those who travel after 9.45am will pay the regular full fare.

LTA said: “By offering a smaller discount before and after the main incentive period between 9am and 9.30am, commuters do not have to rush or deliberately delay their journeys, which may cause crowding and reduce the effectiveness of the programme.”
 

Forum: A fairer COE system must distinguish profit from need​

Jun 19, 2025

I refer to the article “Acting Transport Minister Jeffrey Siow on COE system, private-hire cars and other transport issues”, (June 17). The minister suggested it’s more efficient to allocate certificates of entitlement (COE) to private-hire cars since they serve more people.

While this may sound sensible, it overlooks the constraints faced by individual buyers such as the total debt servicing ratio and monthly budgets. Private-hire companies can afford higher COE prices and pass on the cost to drivers through rental fees.

The rise of private-hire cars has also added to overall demand. When COEs are treated as business assets, the system risks being distorted, disadvantaging regular families who rely on a car for daily commuting and caregiving – not for profit.


If the Government sees private-hire cars as delivering a public good, then it should consider creating a separate COE category for them. Allowing them to compete in the same pool as individual buyers prices out the average household.

A fair COE system should ensure users bear the true cost of ownership, encourage responsible usage and prevent commercial entities from distorting bids.

Chen Tian Qi
 

Thomson-East Coast Line train services delayed due to train fault for 3rd time in 7 days​

The delay, spanning 19 stations, affected those travelling in both directions.

Passengers alighting at the TEL’s Outram Park station on Dec 19. A disruption to train services on the line on Jan 2 affected 19 stations.ST PHOTO: KELVIN CHNG

Rhea Yasmine
Jan 03, 2025

SINGAPORE – Train services on the Thomson-East Coast Line (TEL) were delayed on the evening of Jan 2 due to a train fault. It was the third time in seven days commuters on the TEL had their journeys disrupted for the same reason.

In a Facebook post at 7.38pm, operator SMRT advised commuters to factor in an extra 10 minutes for their journey between Caldecott and Gardens by the Bay – a span of 12 stations – due to a train fault. Train services remained available in both directions.

The delay expanded to 19 stations – from Caldecott to Bayshore – SMRT said in an update almost 10 minutes later. It affected train services in both directions.

A post by SMRT at 8pm said the issue was resolved.

On the night of Dec 29, a train fault on the TEL caused a 15-minute delay for those travelling from Bayshore to Woodlands North, with trains moving slower during the disruption.

On Dec 27, a signalling system fault led to intermittent stoppages on the TEL, causing a delay of up to 15 minutes.

SMRT said then that trains continued to run in both directions between the Woodlands North and Bayshore stations during the disruption, which started at 6.30am. The operator said at 9.06am that day that normal service had resumed.
 

SMRT says 3 recent train disruptions on TEL unrelated​

Passengers alighting at Outram Park MRT on Dec 19, 2024. A signalling fault on Dec 27 had caused communication between the signalling system and trains to be disrupted.

Passengers alighting at Outram Park MRT on Dec 19, 2024. A signalling fault on Dec 27 had caused communication between the signalling system and trains to be disrupted.ST PHOTO: KELVIN CHNG

Fatimah Mujibah
Jan 04


SINGAPORE – Three recent MRT service disruptions that took place over a span of a week on the Thomson-East Coast Line (TEL) were unrelated, said operator SMRT in a Facebook post on Jan 3.

A signalling fault on Dec 27 had caused communication between the signalling system and trains to be disrupted, leading to multiple trains stopping intermittently. The trains then had to be manually driven at 18kmh after system resets, said SMRT.

The fault, which started at 6.30am, had caused a delay of up to 15 minutes. Normal service resumed at 9.06am the same day.


The second incident on Dec 29 involved a train with intermittent brake faults while departing a station.

To keep in line with safety protocols, the train was manually operated at 18kmh. The fault later cleared on its own, allowing regular train services to resume shortly after a 15-minute delay.

Preliminary findings suggest a possible component fault within the train, said SMRT.

The latest incident on the evening of Jan 2 was caused by a train activating the emergency brake system while approaching Orchard MRT station, leading to manual operation being required.

SMRT had then advised commuters to factor in an extra 10 minutes for their journey between Caldecott and Gardens by the Bay – a span of 12 stations – due to a train fault. Normal service resumed at 8pm.

Investigations into the cause of this incident are ongoing.

 
Jan 7, 2025, 01:53pm

Man scolds MRT staff for not telling him escalator under repair: 'Stupid or just can't be bothered?'​

smrtmain.jpg

14,034
52

Cherlynn Ng
Submitted by Stomper
Emmanuel
A man was caught on camera verbally abusing staff at Redhill MRT station.

He was upset that they did not tell him about an escalator not working, which apparently caused him to walk to and fro in vain.

Stomper Emmanuel shared a video of the incident that occurred on Dec 26, 2024, at around 3.35pm.


He recounted: "I witnessed the man verbally abusing and shouting vulgarities at the employee.

"He was fussing over the escalator being broken down and having to walk long distance. But I don't see this is how is the worker's fault."

In the video, the man can be seen raging at a female employee, with a male colleague standing behind her, at the passenger service counter.



The man is heard using the F-word and saying, "Give warning to people, you know? Tell people you are repairing the escalator. I don't have to walk back here, then walk back to the staircase. You understand what I'm saying?"

When the employee tried to explain, the man responded: "You only put (the) way out. You didn't say the escalator is under repair.

"If you are from the other end, the other end, the other, you know the other end? Go and have a look later. I didn't see, ok? I was walking, then walk until the escalator, escalator (under) repair, I got to walk back to the staircase."

The video ends with the man saying, "I said this is not the first time, ok? It's either stupid or you guys just can't be bothered, ok?"

Emmanuel told Stomp: "I am quite angry that he shouted and insulted the workers as they were already trying their best to help him. People should honestly learn to be more gracious and appreciative."

Stomp has contacted SMRT for more info.
 
Back
Top