Just answer me the following questions. Why did your PM apologise just before the GE2011? What the hell did he apologise for?
This is an excellent question -- something I was hoping someone would ask.
Let us first of all recap exactly what PM Lee said at the lunch time rally a couple of days before polling. These excerpts are extracted from
The Online Citizen; I believe this is a verbatim transcript.
.
.
PM LEE HSIEN LOONG: "Five years ago, the opportunities to have IRs in Singapore came up. We seized it, we started going, and got them going before the financial crisis. If we hadn’t done that, and missed the chance, missed the boat, you won’t have Marina Bay like this today.
Last year, we got another gust of wind. Growth was strong, markets were good, we were ready. We went for it, we got fourteen and a half percent growth. Had we not done that and taken in a few more foreign workers and accepted the crowding in the trains and in the public places, you would not have had the budget surpluses, we would not have had the Grow And Share Package this year.
So we can’t go exactly on a straight line from point A to point B and have everything just perfect every spot. There will be detours, sidetracks, side effects, from our decisions. So, IRs are good, but because of the IR, more Singaporeans are at risk of problem gambling, more families are at risk. High growth is good, but because of growth, we have to take in somewhat more foreign workers, we have to be prepared to accept a little bit more congestion for the time being.
These are real problems -- we will tackle them, but I hope you will understand that when these problems vex you or disturb you or upset your lives, please bear with us, we are trying our best on your behalf. And if we didn’t quite get it right, I’m sorry, but we will try and do better the next time."
.
[SNIP]
.
"But good as we are, we and the PAP in particular must never become self-satisfied. The PAP – you may wear white, but that does not give you an automatic right to become the government. You put on the whites — but win the respect of voters – every time, every election. And never forget that we are here to serve the voters, to serve Singaporeans, and not to lord it over people.
No government is perfect. We can have our best intentions, make our best efforts, but from time to time, mistakes will happen. We will make mistakes. We made a mistake when we let Mas Selamat run away. We made a mistake when Orchard Road got flooded. And there are other mistakes which we have made from time to time, and I’m sure occasionally will happen again – I hope not too often. But when it happens, then we should acknowledge it, we should apologize, take responsibility, put things right, if we have to discipline somebody we will do that, and we must learn from the lessons, and never make the same mistake again."
.
Let us examine PM Lee's apology closely. He was not saying that the government had enacted the wrong policies or steered Singapore in the wrong direction. What PM Lee was saying is that the policies are right, but there have been lapses in their implementation from time to time. You must get the distinction clear. The fault resides in the nitty gritty details of implementation, not the core substance or reasons for the policies.
The PAP did the right thing by seizing on economic growth while the going was good. They did the right thing by getting the casinos in. They did the right thing by importing foreigners, which as I have previously mentioned, complement our workforce, enhance our competitiveness, and create even more jobs for Singapore citizens. (
Sidenote: without foreigners, our unemployment rate would be much higher, especially for the lower and middle income)
However, not every government is perfect, and the PAP certainly is not. Because we grew rapidly, there has been some congestion, and prices have been increasing. PM Lee has acknowledged this. That is what he apologized for -- the temporary and unavoidable setbacks as a result of pursuing
policies that are in the long term interest of the nation.
PM Lee has emphasized that the PAP is here to serve the voters and will never be complacent or self-satisfied. You must admire the tenacity and spirit of the PAP. They are not afraid to implement unpopular policies for the good of Singapore. In other words, they do not pander to the short term and often contradictory wishes of the electorate. They have the courage and the determination to do what is right for Singapore, to enact policies that will benefit all Singaporeans in the long run, even if they cause a small amount of short term discomfort.
For all this and more, we should be very grateful to the PAP and to the wisdom of PM Lee. This is an enlightened and forward looking government that has steel in its heart, the raw determination to better the lives of everyone. As a nation, we have avoided the disastrous pitfalls of short term thinking, political gridlock, and rampant welfarism that has plagued western countries. As a result of the focus on long term prosperity and stability, Singapore has more good decades ahead.