- Joined
- Jul 19, 2008
- Messages
- 30,580
- Points
- 0
Before PAP started the Speak mandarin campaign, yes, Chinese spoke dialects with each other or at home. But with Malays, the Chinese used to speak pasar Malay to them. Malay is easy to master. Even grannies spoke Malay in thjose days. Malays do speak dialects too but a smattering. But to change that all and turn to Mandarin, even the CHinese are finding it hard, or were you blind and deaf? The old folks had it worst.
I am saying the SMC smacks of Chinese chauvinism due to the way it was being driven from on high. Blurfucks like you dont know that SMC raison-detre lay in the PAP trying to appease the unhappy Chinese-educated Chinese voters, who have been unhappy since the closure of Nantah and Chinese schools. SAP was the same tool. Please read and repeat this many times to get it that they were PAP race-based politics as you seem to be cranially decrepit before you vomit anymore govt cum.
Speaking dialects was not driven by a govt; it was the spontaneous people's choice at street level from the early days of trading between Chinese immigrants and local resdient Malays. This has evolved over long years under the British. You must be too young to understand this social dynamic.
Malays learning Mandarin? Sure, a few bad words here and there maybe, if they are not already put off by the in-your-face aggressiveness of the SMC. If Chinese have difficulty learning the language, you expect another race to learn it? What a dolt you are! You said some, yes some; but is that enough for social integration across the whole pop? Are you daft?
In those days, when govt leave the races alone to mingle with each other, Chinese and Indians treated Malays in more friendlier and abang/adek ways, with more courteousness, and there was always a good deal of community bonding as both sides. Not people like you, who never waits to lord it over to them. Chinese are great and capable in many ways sure, but they will be greater if they learn to be humble and treat their less equal brothers with maganimous gestures, not adopt an an eye for an eye attitude.
It's people liek you who have got a lot to learn about the way of PAP race politics, social graces, humility etc more than the Malays shld be learning mandarin!
You're obviously a retard and you even contridict yourself in this post. The chinese educated chinese that speak dialect don't find it hard to learn mandarin you dumb azz. It's the ENGLISH educated chinese that are a minority and even smaller minority in those days that find it difficult to master chinese not just mandarin. In those days a chinese educated chinese from a certain dialect like hokkien could understand and speak a number of dialects. Why? Cos they are dialects! The various dialects are not seperate languages and are very closely related including mandarin you idiot. :oIo: Don't make up shit like the old folks don't speak mandarin. They have problems speaking in english not mandarin understand. :oIo:
What's wrong with appeasing the chinese educated chinese that were and probably still the majority of this country? Maybe they should appease the minorities instead.

In short what's wrong with chinese learning a chinese language? You rather the chinese not learn their mother tongue but a totally different language like malay? Fuck you understand. Mandarin and teochew and so on are all closely related okay you dumb piece of lying shit.
I suggested the malays learn mandarin cos firstly they are a minority here and secondly they are a minority the world over. There are more chinese and china and taiwan, hk are all better off than malaysia. Anyway who's forcing the malays to learn mandarin? The last i checked they still learn malay so what are you bitching about?
Oh please stop making up lies The chinese have been maganimous enough. Malay is the national language of this country, the army commands and so on are all in malay. Very maganimous i must say. The chinese have always been bending backwards to appease the malays all the time. What more do you want? You just want to demand more and more and find all sorts of stupid riddiculous reasonings like chinese are not learning their mother tongue when dialects are so closely related.
I also noticed that there are "malays" here with indonesian ancestry like javanese for eg. Now let me inform a pea brain like you that javanese ppl aren't malays and their language javanese isn't malay. Yet guess what language do javanese singaporeans learn? Malay. Can the javanese use the same logic that malay isn't their MT just like what brow beating retards like you have always been ranting about learning mandarin rather than the dialects? Care to explain to me why are these double standards perpetuated? The same applies to malayee indians that learn tamil but they're not tamils so why should they learn tamil but yet you don't feel indignant for them?
Lastly don't even talk about what social dynamics and crap under the british. During those days they didn't even consider themselves a seperate nation. It all changed after sg's independence.
Answer me this: It's ok for the chinese to not learn their MT but learn a language totally different from chinese but when you ask the malays to do likewise that's an unspeakable crime correct? Ppl like you are full of contridictions.
Last edited: