• IP addresses are NOT logged in this forum so there's no point asking. Please note that this forum is full of homophobes, racists, lunatics, schizophrenics & absolute nut jobs with a smattering of geniuses, Chinese chauvinists, Moderate Muslims and last but not least a couple of "know-it-alls" constantly sprouting their dubious wisdom. If you believe that content generated by unsavory characters might cause you offense PLEASE LEAVE NOW! Sammyboy Admin and Staff are not responsible for your hurt feelings should you choose to read any of the content here.

    The OTHER forum is HERE so please stop asking.

Subletting banned to keep hawker food prices affordable

RonRon

Alfrescian
Loyal
Joined
Aug 14, 2009
Messages
3,634
Points
0
The Government announces new polices to moderate food prices at hawker centres, including the banning of stall subletting and assigning.

Singapore, March 6, 2012

To keep hawker food prices affordable to Singaporeans, subletting and assigning of stalls in hawker centres will be banned from April 1.

The Government announced in a media statement today that changes to existing hawker tenancy policies will apply to both current and new hawker centres.

New policies like the building of new hawker centres and provision of more stalls will also help moderate food prices.

The new measures were also revealed in Parliament today by Senior Minister of State for the Environment and Water Resources Grace Fu.

Following the Government’s announcement last October that 10 new hawker centres would be built in the next decade, seven hawker centre sites have been identified in the following towns: Bukit Panjang, Yishun, Pasir Ris, Jurong West, Woodlands, Punggol and Tampines.

In building the new hawker centres, the Government will also draw on recommendations of the Hawker Centre Public Consultation Panel, formed in November 2011 to deliberate on new ideas to improve the "vibrancy, design and management" of the the new centres, said the statement.

Besides increasing the number of stalls, the Government will seek to moderate food prices by changing existing hawker tenancy policies.

It said: "Currently, non-subsidised stallholders are allowed to sublet and assign their stalls. As part of the measures to reduce the cost pressures on stallholders and to keep food prices affordable, the Government will no longer allow full day subletting, as there have been concerns that such practices increase rentals and cost pressures on food prices."

Stallholders are required to operate the stall personally for at least four hours a day, but will be allowed to have a co-operator to run the stall for the other half of the day. This is something the panel had also recommended.

Addressing concerns that the existing Stall Assignment Scheme "allows speculators to profit and drive up food prices", non-subsidised stallholders will also not be allowed to assign their stalls to someone else, said the statement.

"There are hawkers who take over stalls by way of assignment after paying assignment fees. To recoup their investment, they may then pass down the costs to consumers in the form of higher food prices.

"To address this, non-subsidised stallholders who are no longer interested in operating their stalls are to return the stalls to NEA, who will in turn rent the stalls out," the statement said.

These new restrictions will take effect from April 1.

For the current stallholders in existing centres, the no full-day subletting and no stall assignment conditions will apply to tenancy renewals three years from now to allow stallholders reasonable time to make business adjustment. There will be no change in policy for subsidised stallholders.

Stall allocation policy

Currently, stalls are allocated to the highest bidders whose bids are above the minimum rent under the Tender Scheme. But to allow more vacant stalls to be taken up, a reserve rent will not be set when the Government tenders them out.

This means that vacant stalls will be allocated to the highest bidder even at a low price, as long as there are competitive bids. This will ensure that all stalls in hawker centres are fully utilised.

Plans for new hawker centres

The Hawker Centre Consultation Panel has provided a number of ideas on management, infrastructure and design for the new hawker centres.

Taking them into account, together with suggestions from the public, the Government will study these proposals further under the following areas:

1) Future management models
As part of the review process, the Government is also exploring alternative hawker centre management models and assessing the suitability of different management models for the new hawker centres.

While the Government has been managing hawker centres thus far, it acknowledges that there is domain expertise in the private sector such as F & B management which can be tapped.

The building of new hawker centres provides an opportunity to start pilot management models that may improve on the current approach.

The Government is open to partnering with different stakeholders on the design, building, and operation of new hawker centres, as long as their aims are aligned with the Government’s social objectives of achieving food price affordability and meeting community needs.

The Panel’s proposal for a social enterprise or cooperative to manage a new hawker centre as a pilot project is something that the Government is exploring.

2) Better design features
Beyond food price affordability, hawker centre customers should continue to enjoy a clean, hygienic and comfortable dining environment. Design features of the new hawker centres will take cost concerns into consideration to ensure that overall costs are kept low.

Drawing on the Panel’s recommendations, new design ideas will be implemented in the new hawker centres to improve air circulation, such as designing buildings to enhance natural ventilation.

Environment-friendly features to improve energy efficiency, resource and water conservation will also be incorporated wherever possible.

Examples of these features include energy-saving lights, which will help to lower costs in the longer term, and ways to encourage recycling by patrons and stallholders.

To improve the overall cleanliness of hawker centres, designated return points for trays and crockery will also be a key feature in the new hawker centres.

3) Hawker centres for social inclusiveness
The Government will continue to engage and consult closely with constituency advisors and grassroots organisations for their inputs and ideas on the new centres to be built.

Ideas for their design and development should also come from the people they will serve, as hawker centres are more than just places for affordable food.

"They are also important common spaces that cultivate a sense of community and key features of a city that is inclusive and makes room for everyone," concluded the Government statement.
 
Prices would never had been this crazy if the stalls were not sold in the first place! And the next thing was the bringing in of so many FTs which drive demand up! Bottomline lies with the greed of the government!
 
Finally the PAP is waking up. The relentless drive on rentals across Singapore led by Temasek is hitting the ballot box.
 
/


i really hope those FAT CATS and their Nominees will


be hit Big Time this round and the coming rounds ...


Fat Cats :

1) Kopi Tiam Group

2) S21 Group

3) Food Junction Group

4) Banquet Group

5) and remember their "fronts" / nominees


these are the jokers who oppress all the small stalls holders


and drive up the FOOD PRICES ------- Ptui !!!
 
All the fuxxking towkays in Newton Hawker Centre are not working. They simply sublet, especially those stalls selling seafood.
 
/



Fat Cats :

1) Kopi Tiam Group

2) S21 Group

3) Food Junction Group

4) Banquet Group

5) and remember their "fronts" / nominees

I'm not sure if the fat cats you mentioned are considered hawkers, especially if their place of business is within shopping centres.
 
Not only ban sublet, should bring back subsidised stalls. Now fewer and fewer subsidised stalls. That would really drive costs down for the hawkers and therefore make hawker fare cheaper all things equal.
 
must bring back street push cart of old that go tok tok tok tok ...... selling wantaan mee
 
must bring back street push cart of old that go tok tok tok tok ...... selling wantaan mee

They attempted that once with mobile canteens, but as usual, the PAP government royally fucked it up with pedantic micromanagement and overall cluelessness.
 
Once upon a time many years ago, my friend who knew how to fry Hokkien haymee took up a cartstall at Boon Tat St. beside Lau Pa Sat. For those who remember, Boon Tat St. was then closed to traffic from 6:30 p.m. to 6:30 a.m. for the street cartstalls. The rental was S$3,000...he closed stall after a year...

The same happened at the Orchard-Stamford Canal carpark several years later. The stallholders had to sell S$6 to 10 per plate of simple mee just to break even.
 
Last edited:
Finally the PAP is waking up. The relentless drive on rentals across Singapore led by Temasek is hitting the ballot box.

There is a Hokkien saying that literally translate as " Devil they are, Angel they are". If we don't have a opposition party that won a SMC & a GRC, you think, we can see some of the changes we see today??
 
They attempted that once with mobile canteens, but as usual, the PAP government royally fucked it up with pedantic micromanagement and overall cluelessness.

There were so much restrictions & red tape, the mobile canteens, went mobile!:p
 
Finally the PAP is waking up. The relentless drive on rentals across Singapore led by Temasek is hitting the ballot box.

heheh ...
bro, imagine the incumbent with less than two thirds majority... Singapore would be a wonderful place again? :p:p:p
 
even simple things like 叮叮糖 is a thing of the past :(:(:(

Those people who made these 'tin tin tang' have passed on, if they were alive today, they would not survive in the small business they are in not only for the cost but the regulations, from NEA, HSA & whatever, they have to get licencing, go upgrading courses etc., that will stifle them.

The last 'ting ting tang' old man with his portable stall was 15 years a go, he walked 15 to 20 km to sell his ware, he lived in the Macperson area, and his confectionery were hand made. For years he used a chisel to knock the candies from the block in his metal tray & wrapped them in old newspaper, or phone book pages. Later years, he used small plastic bags, still the same old metal chisel.

I am sure he must have passed on, the 'ting ting tang' sold in the shopping centres today are not only expensive but taste lousy, though one may attest they conform to HACCP or whatever standard.

The old days of simple things like this is gone, remember the Maple syrup on stick? or what we call, 'mak ar tong'??
 
Last edited:
Exposing hawker food prices MYTH!

Why blame subletting when it is only a small fraction of the issue concerning food prices?:rolleyes:


  1. famiLEE LEEgime's RENTAL = SKY HIGH!
  2. GST = SKY HIGH & hidden!
  3. Utility = SKY HIGH!
  4. Gas fuel cost = SKY HIGH!
  5. Sale Price of retail space = SKY HIGH!
  6. Greedy LEEgime Auction system Jacks even more SKY HIGH!

:oIo:Pot calling the kettle black? Bandit blaming the thief:*::eek:?

Are PAP Cronies not the BIG TIME SUB-LETTER? Seng Siong? KopiTiam? FoodJunction? Koufu? Banquet? Food Republic? Fook & Spoon? CUNT kopi? These are not Profiteering Hawker Food? Ripping off our Lunch $$$?:mad:

Wake UP Peasants! Wake Up LEEgime!
 
Has anymone taken time to examine their utilties bill? for the myraid number of taxes we are paying, on top of the GST? I am sure 99% of SINgaporeanS don't even bother. One particular glaring tax is the water born fee, which is taxed at a rate, in which any household can never achieved, it is calculated sure make money tax. Go add up the indirect tax you are paying in your utilities bill, and you will be shock! go try!!
 
The old days of simple things like this is gone, remember the Maple syrup on stick? or what we call, 'mak ar tong'??

there was this old ah mn who used to sell 麦芽糖 at Holland V some years back, recently checked, didn't see her anymore.

used to buy it from her whilst me was visiting that area during lunch time, paid her two bucks and asking her to keep the change, she'd insist in putting a dollar back in me palm :o:o:o
 
there was this old ah mn who used to sell 麦芽糖 at Holland V some years back, recently checked, didn't see her anymore.

used to buy it from her whilst me was visiting that area during lunch time, paid her two bucks and asking her to keep the change, she'd insist in putting a dollar back in me palm :o:o:o

I don't hang around HV that often, but have fond memories of that area for sentimental reasons, so, once in while I would just go and walk around, most recent, when the circle line station was opened.

I have a picture of that old lady selling that sweet somewhere in my photos archives, when some years back, went there & took some photos before the place changed.
 
ron ron let me help to rephrase your thread title

PAP dog title : Subletting banned to keep hawker food prices affordable XXXX

Should be : PAP has allowed subletting to go on for ages thus causing unaffordable food prices :mad:
 
Back
Top