Rape and the city
The Horrific Rape Of A 23-year-old Girl In A Delhi Bus Last Week Is Only The Latest In A Long List Of Incidents Of Sexual Assault In The City. Is Delhi The Rape Capital Of India? Sonia Sarkar Finds Out | Published 23.12.12, 12:00 AM
PUBLIC OUTCRY: A candlelight protest at India Gate in New Delhi condemning the recent gang rape
Neha Taneja does not want to step out of her house. For almost a week, the 21-year-old Delhi student has stayed home, not willing to go to a pub or a movie. “I fear that if I go out, it will be my turn to get raped,” she says.
Taneja’s concerns are real. Last Sunday’s incident of a brutal rape and assault have instilled a sense of fear in the minds of Delhi women. Six men raped a 23-year-old woman in a moving bus, beat her and her male friend with iron rods, and then threw them off the bus.
Spread over 1,482 square kilometres, Delhi — famous for its historical monuments, broad roads and butter chicken — is now being seen as a city that has no place for women. Not surprisingly, the media have started calling it the rape capital of India.
Statistics corroborate the fact that Delhi is unsafe for women. This year so far, 661 rape cases were reported in the city, according to National Crime Records Bureau figures. Last year, there were 572 reported rape cases — far higher than such incidents in Mumbai (221), Bangalore (97), Chennai (76) and Calcutta (46). According to government data, rapes per lakh population are higher in Delhi than in any of the metros. Jabalpur in Madhya Pradesh has the highest rate (7.3) in the country, but experts say because the city is a small town with a smaller population than Delhi’s, the number of rapes in Delhi far exceeds those in the MP town.
“There has been a 20 per cent rise in the number of complaints related to sexual assault that we have received over the past two years,” says Nilanju Dutta, manager, violence intervention team, Jagori, a Delhi-based women’s organisation.
What makes Delhi so unsafe?
A combination of factors, say experts — the ever-expanding city has low police vigil and an ever growing migrant population. “The city is being stretched from every corner. It is not possible to set up police stations near every new colony,” says a senior Delhi police official.
The porous borders that the city shares with states such as Haryana and Uttar Pradesh also make it unsafe. “Many crimes are committed by migrant drivers coming from neighbouring states who get drunk and harass women,” says the police official.
But the blame cannot be blindly put on migrant workers because the city’s rich have a criminal record too. “A group of neo-rich has come up in the city. They have money but little education. Often, being intimidated by the English-speaking crowd, they pick up fights in pubs and nightclubs and vent their frustration by sexually assaulting women,” says the officer. And there are enough cases of rapes being committed by the powerful and affluent.
The city — with its vast fleet of vehicles (7.2 million, exceeding the combined vehicle population of Chennai, Calcutta, Lucknow and Mumbai) — is difficult to manage. Rapes are often conducted in moving vehicles. “But it is not possible to keep a check on every vehicle,” argues Dharmendra Kumar, special commissioner of police (law and order).
Home to over 1.67 crore people, the city has also come up over the years as the workplace of diverse communities. In that sense, it’s unlike other cities which invoke a sense of regional pride. “There are many cities living together in Delhi without integrating with one another,” says social commentator Santosh Desai. “There is no sense of belonging. It is a users’ city where people come only for work opportunities with a strong sense of detachment,” feels Desai.
This detachment is often reflected on the streets, says criminal psychiatrist Rajat Mitra. “Women fight a lonely battle against harassment because Delhiites are mostly mute spectators,” he says.
The city has long stretches of lonely roads where the security cover is not adequate. One policeman is in charge of the security of 400 citizens and one public call response (PCR) van handles law and order over a 10-kilometre stretch.
“Further, the body language of policemen doesn’t generate confidence in women. The police also often refuse to lodge complaints of sexual assault,” says National Commission for Women chairperson Mamata Sharma.
There are others who believe the issue goes beyond the police. “The problem lies with the patriarchal mindset of the people. They need to change their attitude towards women,” says former additional commissioner of Delhi police Gautam Kaul. “Some men think that women are their property. They think they are entitled to sex and thereby control female sexuality at their will,” adds Supreme Court advocate Aarthi Rajan.
But the cops also say that these incidents get media coverage because they are occurring in the country’s capital. “Incidents like these happen in every city,” says the senior police official.
Kumar adds that Delhi’s track record is better than that of other cities. “The incidence of rape per lakh population is 52.8 in London and 10.6 in New York whereas it is 4.07 in Delhi.” Others, however, point out that rape has a wider definition in the West, where cases are also reported more often and taken more seriously.
Delhi is a city where people from across the country converge. But with increasing lack of security, not many would repeat the words made memorable by the 19th century poet Zauq: “Who could bear to leave behind the alleys of Delhi.” Who, a 21st century poet would write, would want to walk down dark alleys?
To kill or not to kill
In favour of death penalty for rape
• It will act as a deterrent
Every rapist should know that he could hang one day for his crime: Maya Singh, BJP Member of Parliament
• It is a form of retributive justice
The death penalty is the best form of revenge for a victim of rape: Kiran Bedi, former IPS officer
• It will save state resources
The state need not spend money on rape convicts until their death: Singh
Other arguments
• Convicts, once they complete their sentence or on parole, could rape other women
Against death penalty for rape
• It would lead to fewer convictions
It takes almost nine years on an average to get a conviction in a rape case. Death penalty will be a never ending process: Ranjana Kumari, sociologist and activist
• It blurs the punishment differential between rape and murder
Rapists maybe tempted to murder their victims to destroy evidence: Kumari
• Justice should be served, not revenge
At a time when the world is moving towards abolishing the death penalty, we should concentrate on getting justice faster: Singh
Other arguments
• The state cannot act like a criminal
• Innocents could also be convicted and hanged
• The death penalty is actually not a deterrent
Between 1970 and 1999, more than 2,600 death row prisoners were executed in Nigeria , but the crime rate did not decrease. In Canada murder rates fell by 44 per cent in 27 years after the abolition of the death penalty: Amnesty International
V. Kumara Swamy
