Mumbai building collapse kills 10

[Showdown]

21 June 2013 Last updated at 08:35 GMT

Mumbai building collapse kills ten

<iframe src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/s1K_g_Bjxd4?rel=0" allowfullscreen="" frameborder="0" height="315" width="420"></iframe>

The cause of the collapse in not known yet

At least ten people have been killed in the collapse of a building on the outskirts of the Indian city of Mumbai.

More people are trapped inside the three-storey building in Thane district, 35km (20 miles) from Mumbai. Rescue operations are continuing.

The cause of the collapse in not known, but correspondents say such incidents are common in India and often blamed on poor construction practices.

In April, 74 people were killed in another building collapsed in Thane.

And earlier this month, four people were killed when a five-storey building collapsed in Mumbai.

India's deadly collapses

4 April 2013: 74 die in Thane, near Mumbai
19 Dec 2012: 13 die in Wagholi, Maharashtra
24 Sept 2012: 6 die in Pune, Maharashtra
15 April 2012: 23 workers killed in blanket factory collapse in Jalandhar
16 Nov 2010: 69 killed and more than 80 injured in Delhi
18 Aug 2010: School building collapse kills 18 children in Uttarakhand
26 Jan 2010: 23 killed in Bellary, Karnataka
23 Sept 2009: Chimney of a power plant in Chhattisgarh caves in, 40 killed
13 Aug 2008: 20 die in Mumbai
18 July 2007: 29 killed in Mumbai

The latest incident happened early on Friday when the residential building caved in, officials said.

The building was home to nine families and most people were asleep at the time of the collapse, Sandeep Malvi, spokesman for the Thane municipal corporation, told the BBC.

It was not known what caused the collapse, but Mr Malvi said it was an "old building" constructed in 1979 and that rains in the area over the past few days could have caused the incident.

Fourteen people who were injured in the collapse have been admitted to hospital.

"There are more trapped inside and rescue operations are in full swing," Mr Malvi said.

There is huge demand for housing, and corruption often leads to cost-cutting and a lack of safety inspections, correspondents say.

After April's building collapse in Thane, police arrested nine people suspected of colluding to illegally construct the high-rise building.

Those arrested included two builders, police officers and municipality officials.

In a similar collapse in 2010, 69 people were killed in Delhi.

 

[Showdown]

Mumbai building collapse kills 10

AFP Updated June 21, 2013, 6:56 pm

MUMBAI (AFP) - An apartment block collapsed in Mumbai's outskirts Friday, killing at least 10 people and trapping more in the debris, the latest incident to fuel concerns about the quality of construction in the booming Indian city.

Rescue workers were using hand-held wire cutters and excavators to search for survivors through the rubble after the building on Mumbai's outskirts collapsed while many of its residents were sleeping, officials said.

"There have been 10 deaths, five adults and five children. Nine are injured, with minor injuries," said K.P.Raghuvanshi, police commissioner of Thane district, where the incident occurred.

Among those killed were a two-month-old girl and a seven-year-old boy, said Sandeep Malvi, spokesman for the municipal corporation of Thane.

Police said an investigation was under way into the cause of the incident, the third building collapse in recent months in the Mumbai area, including one in April that killed 74 people.

The collapses have highlighted widespread shoddy construction standards in India, where a huge demand for housing and pervasive corruption often result in cost-cutting and a lack of safety inspections.

"The pace of urbanisation in India's large cities is unmanageable," said Anurag Mathur, a senior executive at property consultancy Jones Lang LaSalle India.

"Sometimes the codes of construction, building safety and upgrades are either not followed or not carried out regularly," he told AFP.

Police said 20 people had been rescued from under the debris on Friday, while local reports said the three-storey building, built in 1979, was home to nine families.

The spokesman, Malvi, said monsoon rains may have triggered the collapse but "we can't say that's the only reason".

The incident happened about 35 kilometres (20 miles) from the centre of the financial capital, close to the scene of the apartment block that collapsed in April, which was one of the worst such incidents in decades.

Two builders and seven others were arrested in connection with the collapse of the partly finished building, which officials said was unauthorised.

Many of the victims were poor daily wage earners and their families, who were living with them at the site.

Just last week, part of a five-storey apartment block in central Mumbai caved in and killed 10 people. The accident was blamed on alleged illegal alterations to the structure, exacerbated by heavy monsoon rains.

The high cost of property in Mumbai and surrounding areas pushes many low-paid families, especially newly arrived migrants from other parts of India, into often illegal and poorly constructed homes.

India's urban housing shortage was estimated at nearly 19 million households in 2012, and in Mumbai the situation is so dire that more than half of the city's residents live in slums.

In another of the worst recent Indian cases, 69 people were killed and more than 80 injured by a building collapse in the Indian capital New Delhi.