PAP Indranee Rajah sexpose and whack resident who ask for handout..KNNB CHAO CHEE BYE

brocoli

Alfrescian
Loyal
Joined
Aug 30, 2011
Messages
1,657
Points
0
CHAO MP drive Lexus so cant empathise with needy people......

Indranee said:
Dear Kah Weng

I refer to your post below, in which you mentioned that you did not receive help, that your case was pushed from one department to another and that you had sought help from the GRC MPs but it was still no use.

There are some things which need clarification here. There are also a few things which you have not mentioned, and I thought it would be helpful to highlight them so that there is a more complete picture.

I can't comment on your experience with other agencies or MPs as I have no knowledge of this, but I can comment on your interface with me and my division.

The first communication you had with me was when I visited your block at Bukit Merah View after the GE. You were not at home, but you were aware that I was visiting because you had left a note stuck on your gate addressed to me which said that you needed financial assistance and asked me to help. Although I did not have the opportunity to see you in person, I felt you should be helped, and I left a note in reply to say that I would get the grassroots leaders and the constituency office to follow up.

They did do so. In the week following my walkabout, one of the grassroots leaders went to your unit to visit you. You were not at home. To make things easier for you, he left a Comcare application form for you to fill in, and he smsed you at the contact number you had left on the note. You then dropped off the form at the CC. You application was processed on an expedited basis, and you were given the maximum allowable financial assistance under Comcare of $600, paid over 3 months. This was disbursed by the CCC. (The maximum under Comcare is $200 per month for 3 months in one calendar year.)

I understand that your father was also until recently given a monthly allowance under a separate fund.

Not long after you received that financial assistance, you posted on my FB saying that you needed financial assistance again. I explained that you had already received the maximum allowable amount under Comcare. However, I also said that if you required further assistance over and above what had already been given, then I needed to understand your situation better to see how to help you. I invited you to come down to see me at MPS.

However, as far as I am aware, you have not come to my MPS, although I do 2 MPS a week - one on Monday and one on Friday. Thus far therefore, I have not had the opportunity to meet you and get details from you.

If is important for me to be given details about your situation to understand why you are in financial difficulty. For example, I see from your picture that you are relatively young. I need to know whether you are working. If you are working and earning, then I need to know why it is that despite the fact that you are working, you have financial difficulty, and from there, I can try to work out how to better assist you.

On the other hand, if you are not working, then I also need to understand why. If it is because of illness or disability, then I can appeal for a form of longer term assistance under a different programme. However, if it is simply because you don't have a job, then the better way to assist you would be through job assistance rather than financial assistance. With a job you will have salary, which hopefully do away with the need for financial assistance.

We are coming to the end of the year. January will be a new calendar year. You will in January be eligible to apply for Comcare again. If you wish to do so, you can get the application form at the CC. The same maximum cap will apply.

If you require assistance over and above that, then you do need to come and see me at MPS for the reasons I have explained above, and I again invite you to do so.


http://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=342648765752099&id=209473372402973

see her lexus SC430. satki or notch ??? how to empathise huh ???

86Lpv.jpg


oNVeH.jpg


Xsety.jpg


L9MgF.jpg


5AniF.jpg


iH8nf.jpg
 
Re: PAP Indranee Rajah sexpose and whack resident who ask for handout..KNNB CHAO CHEE

In this case that pathetic Sinkie resident shoud just chop, go to Matland, adopt a bumiputra name, and be fed by the govt. Its such shame poor stock like this exists in Sinkieland
 
Last edited:
Re: PAP Indranee Rajah sexpose and whack resident who ask for handout..KNNB CHAO CHEE

Agree completely. Jobless, still can make appointment but go jalan jalan.
In this case that pathetic Sinkie resident shoud just chop, go to Matland, adopt a bumiputra name, and be fed by the govt. Its such shame poor stock like this exists in Sinkieland
 
Re: PAP Indranee Rajah sexpose and whack resident who ask for handout..KNNB CHAO CHEE

I say let all these losers starve to death and put an end to their misery.

Giving them handouts only prolongs matters.
 
Re: PAP Indranee Rajah sexpose and whack resident who ask for handout..KNNB CHAO CHEE

Agree completely. Jobless, still can make appointment but go jalan jalan.


What i can gather from Indranee's missive (her side only of the story, no doubt), is that this poor chap had not made any attempt to avail himself and approach in person for help. I don't know whether he went jalan jalan or he really had some life-and-death situation, but over the few months the pattern of behaviour is clear. If he had serious difficulty showing his face he could have called to explain why, and ask for alternative plan. It is clear he did not -- and repeatedly.

Such a person should not be helped. Indranee in this case is not to be blamed.
 
Re: PAP Indranee Rajah sexpose and whack resident who ask for handout..KNNB CHAO CHEE

iNDRANEE hv been taken for a ride. Faceless n given $600. ??
Should not hv entertained him. No show, no entertain.
Bad judgement/decision by Indranee.
 
Re: PAP Indranee Rajah sexpose and whack resident who ask for handout..KNNB CHAO CHEE

One stay healthy and has substantial saving or retirement for old age... when nobody want to employ you.

We must live with pride and not depend on these temporary handout.

$200 a month just enough to pay PUB, town council and Singtel fixed line bills. This chap still need to apply for coupons for food.
 
Re: PAP Indranee Rajah sexpose and whack resident who ask for handout..KNNB CHAO CHEE

Bro,

Not fair to say so lah. From the exchange, to me the guy also doesnt deserve to be helped. He who does not help himself should not be helped.

If welfare giving depends on compassionate Lexus drivers, then there will be no rules except subjective emotional feelings.

CHAO MP drive Lexus so cant empathise with needy people......
 
Re: PAP Indranee Rajah sexpose and whack resident who ask for handout..KNNB CHAO CHEE

Bro,

Not fair to say so lah. From the exchange, to me the guy also doesnt deserve to be helped. He who does not help himself should not be helped.

If welfare giving depends on compassionate Lexus drivers, then there will be no rules except subjective emotional feelings.

Was the sentence passed on the TV actress srictly to the rules or with compassion?
 
Re: PAP Indranee Rajah sexpose and whack resident who ask for handout..KNNB CHAO CHEE

Even though the PAP is generally regarded as being heartless to the poor, I think a fine balance must be drawn.

You CANNOT afford to indiscriminately give out cash benefits especially to those who are able-bodied and young. This will breed a culture of laziness. Why would people want to work if they can get free handouts? This is exactly what's wrong with Europe and it is also why Europe is so messed up right now. Welfarism does not work. It has been proven time and time again. Worst of all, once they are on welfare, you can't wean them off it.
 
Re: PAP Indranee Rajah sexpose and whack resident who ask for handout..KNNB CHAO CHEE

Even though the PAP is generally regarded as being heartless to the poor, I think a fine balance must be drawn.

You CANNOT afford to indiscriminately give out cash benefits especially to those who are able-bodied and young. This will breed a culture of laziness. Why would people want to work if they can get free handouts? This is exactly what's wrong with Europe and it is also why Europe is so messed up right now. Welfarism does not work. It has been proven time and time again. Worst of all, once they are on welfare, you can't wean them off it.

What are these handouts compared to those handouts by PAP to their cronies. These people just go on auto-pilots protecting their handouts.
Europe is not messed up because of welfarism. Europe is messed up now and that's why they could no longer afford welfare.
 
Re: PAP Indranee Rajah sexpose and whack resident who ask for handout..KNNB CHAO CHEE

What are these handouts compared to those handouts by PAP to their cronies. These people just go on auto-pilots protecting their handouts.
Europe is not messed up because of welfarism. Europe is messed up now and that's why they could no longer afford welfare.


ebvery 1 believe her 1sided story??

kannina hia
 
Re: PAP Indranee Rajah sexpose and whack resident who ask for handout..KNNB CHAO CHEE

If her side of the story is true, that guy deserve to Be left hanging. There are the lower income group whose thinking are funny sometimes. Is it because of their attitude that made them what they are today or the harsh environment that made them what they are today?

If it is attitude problem, then nothing can be done even with a 10 mil toto prize. The fool and his gold are soon parted. If it is due to harsh environment, I think we should do our part to assist. The govt Should shoulder this responsibility as they are paid very very well to do this.
 
Re: PAP Indranee Rajah sexpose and whack resident who ask for handout..KNNB CHAO CHEE

What are these handouts compared to those handouts by PAP to their cronies. These people just go on auto-pilots protecting their handouts.
Europe is not messed up because of welfarism. Europe is messed up now and that's why they could no longer afford welfare.

I agree that the PAP's cronyism and nepotism is not to be tolerated and it is disgusting and unacceptable.

However, the fact remains that welfare is something that is open to abuse and WILL be abused if you look at historical examples.

For those who are disabled, sick or elderly, I have no problem with giving them $700-800 a month from public funds.

However, for those who are YOUNG and ABLE BODIED, I have a huge problem with even giving them $1. If everyone else can find a job, why can't they? There are plenty of jobs available, it's just that these people want to pick and choose. They would rather sit at home and do nothing than to work for $800-$1000 monthly salary, claiming that it's not enough to get them by.

But then, they can get by earning $0 a month? Isn't that mysterious?
 
Back
Top