• IP addresses are NOT logged in this forum so there's no point asking. Please note that this forum is full of homophobes, racists, lunatics, schizophrenics & absolute nut jobs with a smattering of geniuses, Chinese chauvinists, Moderate Muslims and last but not least a couple of "know-it-alls" constantly sprouting their dubious wisdom. If you believe that content generated by unsavory characters might cause you offense PLEASE LEAVE NOW! Sammyboy Admin and Staff are not responsible for your hurt feelings should you choose to read any of the content here.

    The OTHER forum is HERE so please stop asking.

Chitchat White Trash Aussies Reject NS Defaulter For Citizenship


Alfrescian (InfP)
Generous Asset
SINGAPORE - A national service defaulter seeking Australian citizenship was advised by a tribunal in that country to first return to Singapore and face pending offences.

Rejecting his appeal, the Melbourne-based tribunal refused his plea to waive a clearance certificate from the Singapore police required to support his citizenship application.

"I consider the Australian people would reasonably expect that those applying for citizenship would respect laws of general application," wrote senior member A. Nikolic of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal of Australia.

"The existence of verifiable information that an applicant has not obeyed the laws of their existing country of citizenship understandably raises character concerns," he added, in decision grounds issued last week (Nov 22).

Australian permanent resident Ashley Rozario, 25, who was born here, remained in Singapore to complete his polytechnic studies when his parents migrated to Australia in January 2011. He joined them in November 2012, and has been there ever since.

His Singapore passport expired in 2014 but was not renewed as he had not reported for compulsory national service the year before.

However, this decision had an impact when his application for Australian citizenship made in 2015 was rejected by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection in January (2017).

It led to his appeal at a tribunal hearing last month.

The tribunal noted Mr Rozario had satisfied all legislative requirements for citizenship except for the issue of whether he is of good character within the meaning of the relevant Act.

For this, he needed to produce a certificate of clearance from the Singapore police stating he had no criminal convictions, but the police declined to provide him with one as he had "outstanding issues" in relation to his national service liability.

Mr Rozario sought a waiver of the certificate requirement as there were no prospects of getting the certificate or renewed passport.

In 2013, he received an e-mail from the Central Manpower Base that he had committed two offences of having failed to enlist for full-time NS and for remaining outside Singapore without a valid exit permit. He was told that if convicted, he could be fined up to $10,000 or jailed up to three years or both, and was advised to return as soon as possible.

Mr Rozario said he was committed to living in Australia as his whole family was there and he did not have a valid passport to travel abroad.

Currently a postgraduate student, his citizenship bid was strongly supported by several referees, including Dr Melanie Pritchard, the convenor of his Bachelor of Biotechnology honours course last year.

She described him as of sound character and an upstanding citizen of Monash University, adding she was aware he had not done compulsory military service in Singapore.

However, after weighing all the evidence and considering the applicable law, the tribunal rejected his appeal as he had not exhausted all reasonable options to resolve his outstanding issues in Singapore.

"It may be open for him to appeal against the decision of the Singapore authorities to reject his application for a clearance certificate, or to return to Singapore and address the pending offences," wrote Mr Nikolic.

"Obedience to and observance of the law are values that are fundamental to the assessment of character."



Very easy solution to this problem...ask Ashley Rozario to change his sex to female.

Problem solved.


If he has chinese-blood, he can renounce his citizenship and go to Taiwan or China, they gladly accept returning Chinese as citizens.


Alfrescian (Inf)
No such problems for foreigners who can easily get citizenship and PR's here and need not serve NS.
Policy about not enjoying the so called " perks of citizenship" before you can renounce do not apply to 1st generation PR's who so call enjoy all these "perks" and yet need not serve NS and are even given reserved places in schools/universities.
Why local born citizen must serve but foreign born citizens need not serve?


Probably the most detached Eurasian family ever. The Gragoes have been migrating to Oz well before the NS conscription came into force in the 60s. They know how to handle this from A to Z. The family typically goes and the Son will remain to do NS and then joins them. They do this because they come back often to visit families and friends and some have kept their homes in Singapore.

Police Clearence Certificate is the basis of entry into PR in all countries. Most countries require it even for employment visa.

I have known of cases where someone convicted in Singapore courts has been offered PR and then citizenship but these were declared prior to move and they had served their time.

Anyway he can remain a PR for yonks but he cannot travel anywhere. Not a smart cookie.