- Joined
- Nov 3, 2008
- Messages
- 1,583
- Points
- 48
Only Ah Neh & Chow Ang Moh were caught before doing this now Taiwanese!
https://tw.news.yahoo.com/調查報導-醫界再爆黑幕-次性手術器械遭重複使用-091524494.html
調查報導/醫界再爆黑幕 一次性手術器械遭重複使用

聯合新聞網
12.1k 人追蹤
記者李樹人、陳雨鑫、鄧桂芬、簡浩正、魏忻忻/調查報導
2019年5月9日 下午5:15
檢視相片
可重覆使用的手術器械。
為了切除外痔的50幾歲李姓婦人,術前趴在手術檯上,醫護人員當場拆掉「雙極電外科器械」塑膠封套,意味著這是全新的,為此,她自費兩、三萬元支付此醫材費用,但果真如此嗎?
檢視相片
一次性手術器械包裝上有註明只能供一位病人使用。
手術室裡不能說的祕密
檢視相片
原應該一次性使用的手術器械,部分醫院重複使用。
「你開刀耗材是幾手貨?」
手術室裡不能說的祕密--「你開刀耗材是幾手貨?」,繼揭發達文西手術A健保數億元黑幕之後,聯合報系再次挖掘到國內自費醫療的大黑洞,眾多醫院竟不顧法令,私下重複使用一次性手術耗材,擬定消毒SOP。
儘管醫師、醫院均認為,「這為了病人著想」,但眾多手術患者卻在不知情狀況下,用了第二手、第三手,甚至第四手的醫材,除了承受感染風險,長久以來,病人信任醫師的醫病關係也遭受重大挑戰。
俗稱「雙極電外科器械」屬於一次性使用手術耗材,在食藥署藥證中,清楚寫著「單次使用器械」,但許多醫療院所卻在消毒殺菌後重複使用,記者深入追查,在健保署「醫材比價網」中可看出端倪。
一套「雙極電外科器械」費用近3萬元,但在77家提供該項自費醫材的醫療院所中,卻有32家售價低於2.5萬元,其中八家醫院低於8,000元,台大醫院僅需6875元,位居低價排行榜的第九名。
最便宜的是委託彰化秀傳醫療體系所經營的台南市立醫院,患者僅需自費3,000元,而價格最高的是桃園敏盛綜合醫院,自費價格高達4.75萬元,價格幾乎為台南市立醫院的16倍。
同樣醫材自費價差距大
醫院重複用可能高達10次
先不探究同樣醫材在不同醫院自費售價差距如此懸殊,低於出廠售價的醫院幾可認定重複使用此一次性手術耗材,只是各醫院重複使用的次數不一,有些五次,有些則可能高達十次。
大醫院:幫病患省錢
重複使用竟有消毒SOP
記者親訪台大醫院大腸直腸科主任梁金銅,他不諱言地表示,台大確實重複使用「雙極電外科器械」,出發點是為了幫患者省錢,此醫材單價約3萬,依照院內手術管理委員會所討論出來消毒SOP規範,徹底消毒後,使用次數最高五次。
梁金銅說,就他所了解,在相關能量器械的重複使用上,台大醫院在使用一次性手術耗材時,重複使用機率僅約一成,但有些醫院甚至超過三成以上。
由秀傳醫療體系委託經營的台南市立醫院創下全台「雙極電外科器械」最低價紀錄,病人僅需自費3000元,秀傳醫療體系副總裁牟聯瑞說,基於病人省錢的出發點,平均使用八至十次,價格才能壓到如此之低,讓每個病友都用得起。
牟聯瑞說,「重複使用一次性耗材,這是無可奈何的事」,站在醫院及醫師的立場,當然希望讓病人使用全新的手術耗材,但並非每個病家都能夠負擔得起,因此,才會消毒後重複使用。
大部分病患不知用二手貨
一次性手術醫材大多再使用
在北部某區域醫院手術室任職多年的陳姓護理師透露,除了骨丁、骨板、骨水泥等無法回收的醫材,以及凝血劑、止血用品等醫材,不會重複使用之外,其餘原本僅限一次使用的手術醫材,大都在消毒後多次使用。
大部分患者不知道自己使用「二手醫材」,陳姓護理師說,患者術前接受麻醉,披上手術被單,推至手術台,術後醒來怎會知道自己用過了哪些器械,而這也是部分醫院重複使用一次性手術耗材的主因。
對於部分醫院執行外科手術重複使用一次性器械,台灣內視鏡外科理事長、高雄榮總一般外科主任陳以書表示,站在學會立場,希望醫院遵守規範,單一使用一次性耗材。
陳以書坦言,好幾年前,就爆發過類似弊端,就有醫院訂出令人啼笑皆非的收費標準,第一個使用器材的患者收取50%的費用,第二名則收30%,以此類推,最後一名使用者因為感染風險最高,當然收費就最便宜。
面對醫界這項陋習,陳以書無奈地說,如果易地而處,換他是病人,當然希望醫師坦然告知細節,而不是在不知情的情況下,被迫使用二手醫材,「這樣才公平吧。」。
衛福部:只能單一使用
可開罰50萬 嚴重者停業
健保署年初審閱「醫材比價網」資料,就發現部分醫院價格低得離譜,曾派人致電這些醫院,瞭解低價原因,原因就是重複使用。不過,這並非健保署業務,並未進一步督導究責,而只是打電話「瞭解瞭解」。
對於這項醫界不能說的秘密,衛福部醫事司司長石崇良說,如果醫材耗材仿單上寫著「single use」,就只能做單一使用,不得重消再用,若醫師未依照仿單操作,等同違反醫師法可開罰10萬元以上、50萬元以下罰鍰,嚴重者可要求停業。
延伸閱讀》
醫界不能說的祕密?重複使用手術耗材 衛部把關嚴重失職
醫界器械風暴脫身 北榮、中醫「感控模範生」
陷醫界器械風暴 台大、秀傳:為病患省錢「逼不得已」使用重複器械?
更多udn報導
Investigation report/medical circles re-sharpening Disposable surgical instruments are being reused
[Joint News Network]
United News Network
12.1k person tracking
Reporter Li Shuren, Chen Yuxin, Deng Guifen, Jian Haozheng, Wei Wei/Investigation Report
May 9, 2019 5:15 PM
Reusable surgical instruments.
View photos
Reusable surgical instruments.
In order to remove the 50-year-old woman named Li, she was on the operating table before surgery. The medical staff removed the plastic cover of the "bipolar electrosurgical instrument" on the spot, which means that this is brand new. For this reason, she paid two or three thousand at her own expense. Yuan pays for this medical material, but is this really true?
Disposable surgical instruments are marked on the package for use by only one patient.
View photos
Disposable surgical instruments are marked on the package for use by only one patient.
Secrets that cannot be said in the operating room
Surgical instruments that should have been used once and used in some hospitals.
View photos
Surgical instruments that should have been used once and used in some hospitals.
"How much is your supply of supplies?"
The secret that can't be said in the operating room--"What is your hand-selling consumables?" After the cover of the developed Wenxi surgery A health insurance billions of dollars, the joint newspapers once again tapped into the big black hole of domestic self-funded medical care, many hospitals ignored Decree, private use of disposable surgical supplies, draft disinfection SOP.
Although doctors and hospitals all believe that "this is for the sake of patients", many surgical patients have used second-hand, third-hand, and even fourth-hand medical materials without knowing the situation. In addition to the risk of infection, they have long been The patient's trust in the doctor's medical relationship has also been a major challenge.
Commonly known as "bipolar electrosurgical instrument" is a disposable surgical consumable. In the drug administration certificate, the "single use device" is clearly written. However, many medical institutions have repeatedly used it after disinfection and sterilization. In the "Medical Materials Comparison Network" of the Health Insurance Department, we can see the clues.
A set of "bipolar electrosurgical instruments" costs nearly 30,000 yuan, but among the 77 medical institutions that provide the self-funded medical materials, 32 have sold for less than 25,000 yuan, of which eight hospitals are under 8,000. Yuan, the National Taiwan University Hospital only needs 6875 yuan, ranking ninth in the low-cost list.
The cheapest is Tainan City Hospital, which is commissioned by Changhua Xiuchuan Medical System. The patient only needs to pay 3,000 yuan at his own expense, and the highest price is Taoyuan Minsheng General Hospital. The self-funded price is as high as 47,500 yuan, and the price is almost 16 for Tainan Municipal Hospital. Times.
The same medical materials have a large gap in self-cost
Repeated use of hospitals up to 10 times
We will not explore the disparity in the price of the same medical materials in different hospitals. The hospitals below the factory price can be considered to reuse the disposable surgical consumables. However, the number of repeated use in hospitals varies, some five times, and some It can be up to ten times.
Big hospital: help patients save money
Repeated use has a disinfection SOP
The reporter visited Liang Jintong, director of the large intestine and rectal department of the National Taiwan University Hospital. He said without hesitation that the National Taiwan University has repeatedly used the "bipolar electrosurgical instrument". The starting point is to help the patient save money. The unit price of this medical material is about 30,000, according to the operation management in the hospital. The committee discussed the disinfection of the SOP specification and disinfected it up to five times.
Liang Jintong said that as far as he knows, in the repeated use of related energy devices, the use of disposable surgical consumables in National Taiwan University Hospital is only about 10%, but some hospitals even exceed 30%.
Tainan City Hospital, commissioned by Xiuchuan Medical System, set a record for the lowest price of "bipolar electrosurgical instruments" in Taiwan. Patients only need to pay 3,000 yuan at their own expense. Yan Lianrui, vice president of Xiuchuan Medical System, said that based on the patient's money-saving starting point, the average use Eight to ten times, the price can be so low that every patient can afford it.
Yan Lianrui said, "Reuse of disposable consumables is a helpless thing." From the standpoint of hospitals and physicians, of course, I hope that patients can use new surgical supplies, but not every patient can afford it. Will be reused after disinfection.
Most patients do not know the use of second-hand goods
Most of the disposable surgical materials are reused.
Chen surnamed nurse, who has worked in the operating room of a regional hospital in the north for many years, revealed that except for boneless vegetables, bone plates, bone cement and other medical materials that cannot be recycled, as well as medical materials such as blood coagulation agents and hemostasis supplies, they will not be reused. Originally used only for one-time use of surgical materials, mostly used after disinfection.
Most patients don't know that they use "second-hand medical materials." Chen surnamed nurse said that the patient received anesthesia before surgery, put on the surgical quilt, pushed it to the operating table, and how to know what equipment he had used after waking up. This is also the main reason for the repeated use of disposable surgical supplies in some hospitals.
For some hospitals to perform surgical re-use of disposable devices, Taiwan's endoscope surgery director, Gao Xiongrong general general surgery director Chen Yishu said that standing in the academic position, I hope the hospital to comply with the norms, the single use of disposable supplies.
Chen Yishu said frankly that several years ago, there were similar drawbacks. Some hospitals set a ridiculous charging standard. The first patient who used the equipment charged 50%, the second received 30%, and so on. The last user has the highest risk of infection, and of course the cheapest is the cheapest.
In the face of the bad habits of the medical profession, Chen Yishu said helplessly that if he is easy to change, he is a patient. Of course, he hopes that the doctor can tell the details calmly, instead of being forced to use second-hand medical materials without knowing it. Fair.".
Wei Fu Department: can only be used alone
Can be fined 500,000. Seriously closed
The Health Insurance Department reviewed the "Medical Materials Comparison Network" information at the beginning of the year and found that some hospitals were outrageously low. They were sent to call these hospitals to understand the reasons for the low price. The reason was repeated use. However, this is not the health care business. It has not further supervised the responsibility. It is just a call to "know it."
For this secret that the medical profession can't say, Shi Chongliang, director of the Department of Medical Affairs of the Department of Health and Welfare, said that if the medical consumables are written with "single use", they can only be used for a single use, and should not be reused. According to the imitation single operation, it is equivalent to a penalty of more than 100,000 yuan and less than 500,000 yuan in violation of the doctor's law. In severe cases, it may be required to suspend business.
Extended reading
The secret that the medical profession can't say? Reuse of surgical consumables
Medical equipment storms come out Beirong, Chinese medicine "sensory model students"
Trapped in the medical equipment storm Taida, Xiu Chuan: saving money for patients "forced to use" repeated equipment?
More udn reports
https://tw.news.yahoo.com/調查報導-醫界再爆黑幕-次性手術器械遭重複使用-091524494.html
調查報導/醫界再爆黑幕 一次性手術器械遭重複使用

聯合新聞網
12.1k 人追蹤
記者李樹人、陳雨鑫、鄧桂芬、簡浩正、魏忻忻/調查報導
2019年5月9日 下午5:15
檢視相片
可重覆使用的手術器械。
為了切除外痔的50幾歲李姓婦人,術前趴在手術檯上,醫護人員當場拆掉「雙極電外科器械」塑膠封套,意味著這是全新的,為此,她自費兩、三萬元支付此醫材費用,但果真如此嗎?
檢視相片
一次性手術器械包裝上有註明只能供一位病人使用。
手術室裡不能說的祕密
檢視相片
原應該一次性使用的手術器械,部分醫院重複使用。
「你開刀耗材是幾手貨?」
手術室裡不能說的祕密--「你開刀耗材是幾手貨?」,繼揭發達文西手術A健保數億元黑幕之後,聯合報系再次挖掘到國內自費醫療的大黑洞,眾多醫院竟不顧法令,私下重複使用一次性手術耗材,擬定消毒SOP。
儘管醫師、醫院均認為,「這為了病人著想」,但眾多手術患者卻在不知情狀況下,用了第二手、第三手,甚至第四手的醫材,除了承受感染風險,長久以來,病人信任醫師的醫病關係也遭受重大挑戰。
俗稱「雙極電外科器械」屬於一次性使用手術耗材,在食藥署藥證中,清楚寫著「單次使用器械」,但許多醫療院所卻在消毒殺菌後重複使用,記者深入追查,在健保署「醫材比價網」中可看出端倪。
一套「雙極電外科器械」費用近3萬元,但在77家提供該項自費醫材的醫療院所中,卻有32家售價低於2.5萬元,其中八家醫院低於8,000元,台大醫院僅需6875元,位居低價排行榜的第九名。
最便宜的是委託彰化秀傳醫療體系所經營的台南市立醫院,患者僅需自費3,000元,而價格最高的是桃園敏盛綜合醫院,自費價格高達4.75萬元,價格幾乎為台南市立醫院的16倍。
同樣醫材自費價差距大
醫院重複用可能高達10次
先不探究同樣醫材在不同醫院自費售價差距如此懸殊,低於出廠售價的醫院幾可認定重複使用此一次性手術耗材,只是各醫院重複使用的次數不一,有些五次,有些則可能高達十次。
大醫院:幫病患省錢
重複使用竟有消毒SOP
記者親訪台大醫院大腸直腸科主任梁金銅,他不諱言地表示,台大確實重複使用「雙極電外科器械」,出發點是為了幫患者省錢,此醫材單價約3萬,依照院內手術管理委員會所討論出來消毒SOP規範,徹底消毒後,使用次數最高五次。
梁金銅說,就他所了解,在相關能量器械的重複使用上,台大醫院在使用一次性手術耗材時,重複使用機率僅約一成,但有些醫院甚至超過三成以上。
由秀傳醫療體系委託經營的台南市立醫院創下全台「雙極電外科器械」最低價紀錄,病人僅需自費3000元,秀傳醫療體系副總裁牟聯瑞說,基於病人省錢的出發點,平均使用八至十次,價格才能壓到如此之低,讓每個病友都用得起。
牟聯瑞說,「重複使用一次性耗材,這是無可奈何的事」,站在醫院及醫師的立場,當然希望讓病人使用全新的手術耗材,但並非每個病家都能夠負擔得起,因此,才會消毒後重複使用。
大部分病患不知用二手貨
一次性手術醫材大多再使用
在北部某區域醫院手術室任職多年的陳姓護理師透露,除了骨丁、骨板、骨水泥等無法回收的醫材,以及凝血劑、止血用品等醫材,不會重複使用之外,其餘原本僅限一次使用的手術醫材,大都在消毒後多次使用。
大部分患者不知道自己使用「二手醫材」,陳姓護理師說,患者術前接受麻醉,披上手術被單,推至手術台,術後醒來怎會知道自己用過了哪些器械,而這也是部分醫院重複使用一次性手術耗材的主因。
對於部分醫院執行外科手術重複使用一次性器械,台灣內視鏡外科理事長、高雄榮總一般外科主任陳以書表示,站在學會立場,希望醫院遵守規範,單一使用一次性耗材。
陳以書坦言,好幾年前,就爆發過類似弊端,就有醫院訂出令人啼笑皆非的收費標準,第一個使用器材的患者收取50%的費用,第二名則收30%,以此類推,最後一名使用者因為感染風險最高,當然收費就最便宜。
面對醫界這項陋習,陳以書無奈地說,如果易地而處,換他是病人,當然希望醫師坦然告知細節,而不是在不知情的情況下,被迫使用二手醫材,「這樣才公平吧。」。
衛福部:只能單一使用
可開罰50萬 嚴重者停業
健保署年初審閱「醫材比價網」資料,就發現部分醫院價格低得離譜,曾派人致電這些醫院,瞭解低價原因,原因就是重複使用。不過,這並非健保署業務,並未進一步督導究責,而只是打電話「瞭解瞭解」。
對於這項醫界不能說的秘密,衛福部醫事司司長石崇良說,如果醫材耗材仿單上寫著「single use」,就只能做單一使用,不得重消再用,若醫師未依照仿單操作,等同違反醫師法可開罰10萬元以上、50萬元以下罰鍰,嚴重者可要求停業。
延伸閱讀》
醫界不能說的祕密?重複使用手術耗材 衛部把關嚴重失職
醫界器械風暴脫身 北榮、中醫「感控模範生」
陷醫界器械風暴 台大、秀傳:為病患省錢「逼不得已」使用重複器械?
更多udn報導
Investigation report/medical circles re-sharpening Disposable surgical instruments are being reused
[Joint News Network]
United News Network
12.1k person tracking
Reporter Li Shuren, Chen Yuxin, Deng Guifen, Jian Haozheng, Wei Wei/Investigation Report
May 9, 2019 5:15 PM
Reusable surgical instruments.
View photos
Reusable surgical instruments.
In order to remove the 50-year-old woman named Li, she was on the operating table before surgery. The medical staff removed the plastic cover of the "bipolar electrosurgical instrument" on the spot, which means that this is brand new. For this reason, she paid two or three thousand at her own expense. Yuan pays for this medical material, but is this really true?
Disposable surgical instruments are marked on the package for use by only one patient.
View photos
Disposable surgical instruments are marked on the package for use by only one patient.
Secrets that cannot be said in the operating room
Surgical instruments that should have been used once and used in some hospitals.
View photos
Surgical instruments that should have been used once and used in some hospitals.
"How much is your supply of supplies?"
The secret that can't be said in the operating room--"What is your hand-selling consumables?" After the cover of the developed Wenxi surgery A health insurance billions of dollars, the joint newspapers once again tapped into the big black hole of domestic self-funded medical care, many hospitals ignored Decree, private use of disposable surgical supplies, draft disinfection SOP.
Although doctors and hospitals all believe that "this is for the sake of patients", many surgical patients have used second-hand, third-hand, and even fourth-hand medical materials without knowing the situation. In addition to the risk of infection, they have long been The patient's trust in the doctor's medical relationship has also been a major challenge.
Commonly known as "bipolar electrosurgical instrument" is a disposable surgical consumable. In the drug administration certificate, the "single use device" is clearly written. However, many medical institutions have repeatedly used it after disinfection and sterilization. In the "Medical Materials Comparison Network" of the Health Insurance Department, we can see the clues.
A set of "bipolar electrosurgical instruments" costs nearly 30,000 yuan, but among the 77 medical institutions that provide the self-funded medical materials, 32 have sold for less than 25,000 yuan, of which eight hospitals are under 8,000. Yuan, the National Taiwan University Hospital only needs 6875 yuan, ranking ninth in the low-cost list.
The cheapest is Tainan City Hospital, which is commissioned by Changhua Xiuchuan Medical System. The patient only needs to pay 3,000 yuan at his own expense, and the highest price is Taoyuan Minsheng General Hospital. The self-funded price is as high as 47,500 yuan, and the price is almost 16 for Tainan Municipal Hospital. Times.
The same medical materials have a large gap in self-cost
Repeated use of hospitals up to 10 times
We will not explore the disparity in the price of the same medical materials in different hospitals. The hospitals below the factory price can be considered to reuse the disposable surgical consumables. However, the number of repeated use in hospitals varies, some five times, and some It can be up to ten times.
Big hospital: help patients save money
Repeated use has a disinfection SOP
The reporter visited Liang Jintong, director of the large intestine and rectal department of the National Taiwan University Hospital. He said without hesitation that the National Taiwan University has repeatedly used the "bipolar electrosurgical instrument". The starting point is to help the patient save money. The unit price of this medical material is about 30,000, according to the operation management in the hospital. The committee discussed the disinfection of the SOP specification and disinfected it up to five times.
Liang Jintong said that as far as he knows, in the repeated use of related energy devices, the use of disposable surgical consumables in National Taiwan University Hospital is only about 10%, but some hospitals even exceed 30%.
Tainan City Hospital, commissioned by Xiuchuan Medical System, set a record for the lowest price of "bipolar electrosurgical instruments" in Taiwan. Patients only need to pay 3,000 yuan at their own expense. Yan Lianrui, vice president of Xiuchuan Medical System, said that based on the patient's money-saving starting point, the average use Eight to ten times, the price can be so low that every patient can afford it.
Yan Lianrui said, "Reuse of disposable consumables is a helpless thing." From the standpoint of hospitals and physicians, of course, I hope that patients can use new surgical supplies, but not every patient can afford it. Will be reused after disinfection.
Most patients do not know the use of second-hand goods
Most of the disposable surgical materials are reused.
Chen surnamed nurse, who has worked in the operating room of a regional hospital in the north for many years, revealed that except for boneless vegetables, bone plates, bone cement and other medical materials that cannot be recycled, as well as medical materials such as blood coagulation agents and hemostasis supplies, they will not be reused. Originally used only for one-time use of surgical materials, mostly used after disinfection.
Most patients don't know that they use "second-hand medical materials." Chen surnamed nurse said that the patient received anesthesia before surgery, put on the surgical quilt, pushed it to the operating table, and how to know what equipment he had used after waking up. This is also the main reason for the repeated use of disposable surgical supplies in some hospitals.
For some hospitals to perform surgical re-use of disposable devices, Taiwan's endoscope surgery director, Gao Xiongrong general general surgery director Chen Yishu said that standing in the academic position, I hope the hospital to comply with the norms, the single use of disposable supplies.
Chen Yishu said frankly that several years ago, there were similar drawbacks. Some hospitals set a ridiculous charging standard. The first patient who used the equipment charged 50%, the second received 30%, and so on. The last user has the highest risk of infection, and of course the cheapest is the cheapest.
In the face of the bad habits of the medical profession, Chen Yishu said helplessly that if he is easy to change, he is a patient. Of course, he hopes that the doctor can tell the details calmly, instead of being forced to use second-hand medical materials without knowing it. Fair.".
Wei Fu Department: can only be used alone
Can be fined 500,000. Seriously closed
The Health Insurance Department reviewed the "Medical Materials Comparison Network" information at the beginning of the year and found that some hospitals were outrageously low. They were sent to call these hospitals to understand the reasons for the low price. The reason was repeated use. However, this is not the health care business. It has not further supervised the responsibility. It is just a call to "know it."
For this secret that the medical profession can't say, Shi Chongliang, director of the Department of Medical Affairs of the Department of Health and Welfare, said that if the medical consumables are written with "single use", they can only be used for a single use, and should not be reused. According to the imitation single operation, it is equivalent to a penalty of more than 100,000 yuan and less than 500,000 yuan in violation of the doctor's law. In severe cases, it may be required to suspend business.
Extended reading
The secret that the medical profession can't say? Reuse of surgical consumables
Medical equipment storms come out Beirong, Chinese medicine "sensory model students"
Trapped in the medical equipment storm Taida, Xiu Chuan: saving money for patients "forced to use" repeated equipment?
More udn reports