Shrimp that will boil in steam boat but STILL ALIVE!

[singveld]

what makes u think 1 atm 100 degree that fellow will die from cooking?

the shrimp will die, because the water inside the shrimp will boil, all living thing have water inside them, if the water would to boil, can the shrimp survive?

the shrimp survive at 450C at high pressure, stress high pressure, the water at that high pressure is not boiling.

 

[Microsoft]

U might b right...or perhaps de fluid in de shrimp are different frm water as we known...nid sum live sample to study b4 any conclusion is drawn...

 

[matamafia]

so, wil dey call it freeze boat? ... u heat water 2 boil in a freeze boat? ...

Icecream shrimp?
<iframe width="640" height="360" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/Y08qKqjC3qw" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

 

[matamafia]

You all greedy Singaporeans all want to eat freak shrimp meh? Want to eat SPACE ALIENS or not?:*::p

 

[Unrepented]

1. Put human in hot water, don't need water to reach "Boiling Point of water" can also die. It is the heat in the water that kills.
2. The water at that depth is claimed to be 450 C, so what if it doesn't reach boiling point.
3. Whether the water is boiling or not is irrelevant, imo.

OMG. Who are the people who visit the forum? Science fail.

water boil at higher temperature in high pressure
water boil at lower temperature in low pressure

therefore if this shrimp is brought to the steamboat in the restaurant, it will boil at 100C, thus the shrimp will die and maybe eaten if not poison.


We got opposition who do not know basic politics, we have people in the middle of both parties who know little science, arts or basic computer skill like paste correctly. See orly heartattck.

 

[singveld]

1. Put human in hot water, don't need water to reach "Boiling Point of water" can also die. It is the heat in the water that kills.
2. The water at that depth is claimed to be 450 C, so what if it doesn't reach boiling point.
3. Whether the water is boiling or not is irrelevant, imo.

boiling matters.
if you were to put a man in an vacuum chamber, lower the pressure until water boil at 40C, which normally is temp human can tolerant, he will die when his blood boil in that situation.

 

[Microsoft]

[video=youtube;rFHtVRKoaUM]http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=rFHtVRKoaUM[/video]

 

[singveld]

U might b right...or perhaps de fluid in de shrimp are different frm water as we known...nid sum live sample to study b4 any conclusion is drawn...

H2O is same on land and under 5000m of ocean, same as the water on mars and same as the water trillions trillions miles away in another galaxy.

 

[drifter]

water parameters in the ocean is not the same as our tap water ...different level of pH , GH , ammonia, nitrite , nitrate , co2 , phosphate ...ect . so the shrimps still cannot survive even though the hot temperture cant kill them .

 

[vamjok]

logical admit defeat.

i was thinking of only the heat

 

[drifter]

logical admit defeat.

i was thinking of only the heat

no worries ...i just understand about fishes and animals more then normal ppl cause its my job

 

[drifter]

thats why its very important for ppl who keep marine fishes to buy test kits for water parameters to monitor the water conditions in order for the coral and fishes to survive .

 

[Microsoft]

H2O is same on land and under 5000m of ocean, same as the water on mars and same as the water trillions trillions miles away in another galaxy.

De black smoke like discharge shown in de video r actually extremely hot water escaping from hydrothermal vent...i couldn't find any details whether it's extremely hot water or boiling water...being able to survive in extremely hot water and boiling water are entirely 2 different thing...bery interesting if it's de latter...

 

[Unrepented]

You are correct in the control environment that you set to prove your point. But in the context of the shrimps under water, temperature is another matter.

boiling matters.
if you were to put a man in an vacuum chamber, lower the pressure until water boil at 40C, which normally is temp human can tolerant, he will die when his blood boil in that situation.

 

[Microsoft]

Freeze can be only below 0c LOL

Freeze as in temp drop below wat de body can take...not changing frm liquid to solid...

so, wil dey call it freeze boat? ... u heat water 2 boil in a freeze boat? ...

Yeah sumting like tat...same theory as upturn de downturn u noe...:p:p

 

[Unrepented]

Boiling water reaches "boiling point", "boiling point" is the point/temperature that causes water to rapidly vapourize.

In sinveld's control vacum example, liquid in human will boil and vapourize if atmospheric pressure is lowered sufficiently for water to boil at 40C which is the normal temp of human. In this sense, liquid in human vapourizes at 40c if that is the boiling point. Human starts to cook if internal temp is about 43C at sea level.

But at atmospheric high pressure, water boil at higher temperatures, even if doesn't boil, the heat is still there, at 450c.

................. whether it's extremely hot water or boiling water...being able to survive in extremely hot water and boiling water are entirely 2 different thing...bery interesting if it's de latter...

 

[Unrepented]

But sometimes got chew chew abit for fun lah:o Baby shrimps are very tiny lah, won't choke but tingling feeling only.:o

u mean u gulped ze water 2gether wif ze baby shrimp swimming in it down ur throat? ...

 

[Pervert]

There is still alot of weird creature yet to be discover.

 

[Unrepented]

In the spirit of a friendly discourse, I don't think your logic is wrong eventhough the element of vapourization was not within your sphere of reasoning, imo.

b4 u shoot you go have your brain check

hello 450 degree high pressure cooker under the sea that bugger already wun die

what makes u think 1 atm 100 degree that fellow will die from cooking?

it might not live long at ground level sea water but that is another story.

 

[Rogue Trader]

You all bio fail lah... Put this kind of prawn in 100 degree water and it will freeze to death!