https://news.sina.com.cn/w/2019-07-17/doc-ihytcerm4319548.shtml
机密泄露 美国在欧洲这些地方藏了150颗核弹
2019年07月17日 18:02 环球时报
0
原标题：机密泄露！美国在欧洲这些地方藏了150颗核弹
“这些炸弹被存放在美国和欧洲的6个基地：比利时的克莱因·布罗格尔、德国的比谢尔、意大利的阿维亚诺和盖迪-托雷、荷兰的沃尔克尔和土耳其的因吉利克”
据华盛顿邮报16日报道，美国核武器在欧洲的秘密地点意外地被囊括在了在北约议会的报告中。
A recently released — and subsequently deleted — document published by a NATO-affiliated body has sparked headlines in Europe with an apparent confirmation of a long-held open secret： U.S。 nuclear weapons are being stored in Belgium， Germany， Italy， the Netherlands and Turkey。
一个隶属于北约的机构最近公布了一份随后被删除了的文件，这份文件显然证实了一个长期以来公开的秘密，并在欧洲引起了轰动。这个秘密就是：美国的核武器就存放在比利时、德国、意大利、荷兰和土耳其。
▲Secret locations of U.S。 nuclear weapons in Europe accidentally included in report from NATO parliament （via the Washington Post）
（图 via sputnik）
据RT报道，这份文件的作者是来自加拿大的Sen。 Joseph Day，他是北约议会国防和安全委员会成员。文件中提到：
According to the draft， NATO stores some 150 nuclear B61 bombs in six bases： Kleine Brogel in Belgium， Büchel in Germany， Aviano and Ghedi-Torre in Italy， Volken in the Netherlands and İncirlik in Turkey。 While the draft does not say how many bombs each of the bases houses， the information is readily available online， albeit with varying degrees of accuracy。
根据草案，北约在六个基地：比利时的克莱因·布罗格尔、德国的比谢尔、意大利的阿维亚诺和盖迪-托雷、荷兰的沃尔克尔和土耳其的因吉利克存放了大约150颗B61核弹。虽然草案没有说明每个基地有多少枚炸弹，但这些信息在网上很容易获得，尽管准确性各不相同。
▲Draft NATO-affiliated report reveals number & location of US nukes in Europe （via RT）
上述文件虽已被删除，但最新版本的报告似乎却从另一个隐晦的角度证明了这个消息：
The document does not attribute this information to any source。 Last week， a final version of the report was published online， and it omits the specific reference to where bombs are stored。 Instead， the report refers vaguely to aircraft that could carry nuclear weapons。
这份文件并没有注明信息源。上周，该报告的最终版本在网上公布，并删去了炸弹储存的具体参考地点。取而代之的是，报告含糊地提到了可以携带核武器的飞机。
“The European Allies often cited as operating such aircraft are Belgium， Germany， Italy， The Netherlands， and Turkey，” the document said， with a footnote citing a 2018 report by the Nuclear Threat Initiative， a U.S。 nongovernmental organization。
文件援引美国非政府组织“核威胁倡议”2018年的报告中的内容作为脚注，称：“经常被举例为操作此类飞机的欧洲盟国是比利时、德国、意大利、荷兰和土耳其。”
▲Secret locations of U.S。 nuclear weapons in Europe accidentally included in report from NATO parliament （via the Washington Post）
大家看懂了吗
美国核武器地点泄露？报告作者表示：
Sen。 Joseph Day， the author of the report， wrote in an email that the first version of the report was only a draft and that changes may be made to the report until it is dealt with by the NATO Parliamentary Assembly in November。 “All information used in this report is open source material，” he wrote。
报告作者约瑟夫·戴参议员在一封电子邮件中写道，报告的第一版只是一份草稿，在11月北约议会会议讨论报告之前，可以对报告作一些修改。“本报告中使用的所有信息都是开源材料，”他写道。
▲Secret locations of U.S。 nuclear weapons in Europe accidentally included in report from NATO parliament （via the Washington Post）
北约某官员也开始甩锅：
As a rule， neither the United States nor its European partners discuss the location of Washington’s nuclear weapons on the continent。 “We do not comment on the details of NATO’s nuclear posture，” said a NATO official， speaking on the condition of anonymity in line with the organization’s rules for talking to the media。
一般来说，美国及其欧洲伙伴都没有讨论美国政府的核武器在欧洲大陆位置。“我们对北约核态势的细节不作评论，”一位不愿透露姓名的北约官员表示。
“This is not an official NATO document，” the official added， noting that it was written by members of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly。
“这不是北约的正式文件，”这位官员补充说道，并指出这是北约议会成员写的。
▲Secret locations of U.S。 nuclear weapons in Europe accidentally included in report from NATO parliament （via the Washington Post）
但“秘密的泄露”似乎并不是这件事的重点。这些核武器存放至今是为何？有专家担心这会引发军备竞赛，有专家认为这很危险。。。。。。
（图 via RT）
The presence of the weapons derived from an agreement reached in the 1960s and is in many ways a relic of the Cold War era — designed not only to act as deterrence to the nuclear armed-Soviet Union， but also to convince countries that they didn’t need their own nuclear weapons program。
这些武器的存在源于20世纪60年代达成的协议，从许多方面看来是冷战时代的遗物——不仅旨在威慑核武装的苏联，而且旨在说服各国，它们不需要自己的核武器项目。
But times have changed。 In 2016， after a coup attempt and the rapid spread of the Islamic State extremist group next door， analysts openly wondered whether Turkey was really such a great place to store nuclear weapons。
但时代已经变了。2016年，土耳其发生政变，邻国伊斯兰国极端组织迅速蔓延，分析人士公开质疑，土耳其是否真的是一个储存核武器的好地方。
▲Secret locations of U.S。 nuclear weapons in Europe accidentally included in report from NATO parliament （via the Washington Post）
许多网友也发出质疑：
很难理解为什么拥有这些武器的欧洲国家自愿成为美国的目标。我想知道美国是否真的关心这个问题。
如果一个疯狂的总统控制了他们，那不是很可怕吗？（疯狂暗示）
（这次泄露）绝非意外
你如何看待这次美国核弹储藏位置泄露？
文：YANMING
责任编辑：张申
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/95254...clear-europe-accidentally-leaked-nato-report/
BOMBSHELL Top secret locations of 150 US nukes hidden in Europe are accidentally leaked in Nato report sparking major security fears
The United States and its allies in the Nato military alliance never disclose the locations of the nuclear arsenal but it appears the six sites have inadvertently disclosed.
3
The nuke sites where the nuclear weapons are being deployed - it has been reported they are of the B61 type pictured being tested
A draft version of the document entitled “A new era for nuclear deterrence? Modernisation, arms control and allied nuclear forces” was published earlier this year.
But Belgian newspaper De Morgen spotted that it contained details about the nuke sites.
A section on the nuclear arsenal read: “These bombs are stored at six US and European bases — Kleine Brogel in Belgium, Büchel in Germany, Aviano and Ghedi-Torre in Italy, Volkel in The Netherlands, and Incirlik in Turkey.”
The study was written by a Canadian senator Joseph Day for the Defense and Security Committee of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly.
The final version of the report has now been published online with specific reference to where bombs are stored deleted.
NUKES REVEALED
Instead it refers vaguely to aircraft that could carry nuclear weapons.Senator Day told the Washington Post the original document was only a draft and “all information used in this report is open source material”.
A Nato spokesman said: “We do not comment on the details of NATO’s nuclear posture. This is not an official NATO document.”
It has been reported that the US has deployed the B61 bomb in Europe.
The presence of US nuclear weapons in Europe is a relic of the Cold War and they were originally stationed to deter Soviet aggression.
At the height of tensions, the US is believed to have deployed 110 nuclear weapons at RAF Lakenheath, which were removed in 2008.
America has indicated it may spend more than £703 billion by the 2040s upgrading its nuclear capabilities.
3
The United States and Russia are due to meet today to discuss the possibility of a three-way nuclear arms treaty, including China for the first time.
The talks are being held two weeks before the formal end to the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty between Russia and the US.
The 1987 agreement was signed in 1987 in Washington D.C. by President Ronald Regan and Soviet Union General Secretary Mikhail Gorbachev and greatly reduced nuclear weapons in Europe.
By May 1991, 2,692 missiles had been eliminated and 10 years of on-site verification inspections followed.
Donald Trump signalled the America would withdraw from the treaty because Russia had been "violating it for many years".
Earlier this year a UN arms chief said the threat of nuclear war is at its highest since World War II.
3
The Aviano Air Base in Italy has been revealed as the site of US nuclear weaponsCredit: Alamy
UN security expert Renata Dwan says risk of nuclear weapons being used is highest since World War Two
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/...rmany-italy-turkey-belgium-nato-a9008111.html
Secret locations of US nuclear weapons in Europe accidentally leaked
‘These bombs are stored at six US and European bases’, says Nato committee report
Click to follow
The Independent
The secret locations of US nuclear weapons stored in Europe have been accidentally revealed in a report published by a Nato committee.
The document referred to the sites of roughly 150 American nuclear weapons.
“These bombs are stored at six US and European bases — Kleine Brogel in Belgium, Büchel in Germany, Aviano and Ghedi-Torre in Italy, Volkel in The Netherlands, and Incirlik in Turkey,” a section of the report seen by Belgian newspaper De Morgen said.
The information was included in an early version of the report published in April by the Defence and Security Committee of the Nato Parliamentary Assembly, titled A New Era for Nuclear Deterrence? Modernisation, Arms Control and Allied Nuclear Forces.
However, the reference has since been removed from the final version released last week.
Which countries have nuclear weapons?
Show all 14
The latest version of the report instead makes reference to aircraft capable of carrying nuclear weapons, adding: “The European Allies often cited as operating such aircraft are Belgium, Germany, Italy, The Netherlands, and Turkey.”
A Nato official told The Washington Post the report was “not an official Nato document” and pointed out that it was written by the alliance’s parliamentary assembly.
“We do not comment on the details of Nato’s nuclear posture,” they added.
Independent Minds Events: get involved in the news agenda
While the storing of American nuclear weapons in Europe has long been regarded as an open secret, media organisations on the continent viewed the document as confirmation.
“Finally in black and white: There are American nuclear weapons in Belgian,” the De Morgen report was headlined.
“Nato reveals the Netherlands’ worst-kept secret,” Dutch broadcaster RTL News said.
https://thehill.com/policy/internat...n-locations-in-europe-accidentally-exposed-in
US nuclear weapon locations in Europe accidentally exposed in NATO committee report
By Owen Daugherty - 07/16/19 08:44 PM EDT 230
347
AddThis Sharing Buttons
Share to Facebook
Share to Twitter
© Getty Images
A report from a NATO committee that has since been deleted reportedly exposed the the secret locations of U.S. nuclear weapons in Europe.
The Washington Post reports that the document by a Canadian senator for the Defense and Security Committee of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly detailed the future of the organization’s nuclear deterrence policy but accidentally exposed the open secret.
The report stated that U.S. nuclear weapons are being stored in Belgium, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands and Turkey.
While the document titled “A new era for nuclear deterrence? Modernisation, arms control and allied nuclear forces” was originally published in April without making waves, a Belgian newspaper Tuesday published a copy of the document featuring the locations of about 150 U.S. nuclear weapons.
“These bombs are stored at six US and European bases — Kleine Brogel in Belgium, Büchel in Germany, Aviano and Ghedi-Torre in Italy, Volkel in The Netherlands, and Incirlik in Turkey,” a section of the newspaper’s report read, according to the Post.
The Post made note that the original document did not attribute this information to any source.
A final version of the report was reportedly published last week that did not have any specific references to where the weapons are stored.
“This is not an official NATO document,” a NATO official told the Post, making clear that it was written by members of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly.
“We do not comment on the details of NATO’s nuclear posture,” the official said, remaining anonymous due to the organization’s policy for discussing matters regarding nuclear weapons with the media.
Kingston Reif, director for disarmament and threat-reduction policy at the Arms Control Association, told the Post in an email that it was no surprise to potentially discover the location of U.S. nuclear weapons in Europe.
“This has long been fairly open knowledge,” he said.
机密泄露 美国在欧洲这些地方藏了150颗核弹
2019年07月17日 18:02 环球时报
0
原标题：机密泄露！美国在欧洲这些地方藏了150颗核弹
“这些炸弹被存放在美国和欧洲的6个基地：比利时的克莱因·布罗格尔、德国的比谢尔、意大利的阿维亚诺和盖迪-托雷、荷兰的沃尔克尔和土耳其的因吉利克”
据华盛顿邮报16日报道，美国核武器在欧洲的秘密地点意外地被囊括在了在北约议会的报告中。
A recently released — and subsequently deleted — document published by a NATO-affiliated body has sparked headlines in Europe with an apparent confirmation of a long-held open secret： U.S。 nuclear weapons are being stored in Belgium， Germany， Italy， the Netherlands and Turkey。
一个隶属于北约的机构最近公布了一份随后被删除了的文件，这份文件显然证实了一个长期以来公开的秘密，并在欧洲引起了轰动。这个秘密就是：美国的核武器就存放在比利时、德国、意大利、荷兰和土耳其。
▲Secret locations of U.S。 nuclear weapons in Europe accidentally included in report from NATO parliament （via the Washington Post）
据RT报道，这份文件的作者是来自加拿大的Sen。 Joseph Day，他是北约议会国防和安全委员会成员。文件中提到：
According to the draft， NATO stores some 150 nuclear B61 bombs in six bases： Kleine Brogel in Belgium， Büchel in Germany， Aviano and Ghedi-Torre in Italy， Volken in the Netherlands and İncirlik in Turkey。 While the draft does not say how many bombs each of the bases houses， the information is readily available online， albeit with varying degrees of accuracy。
根据草案，北约在六个基地：比利时的克莱因·布罗格尔、德国的比谢尔、意大利的阿维亚诺和盖迪-托雷、荷兰的沃尔克尔和土耳其的因吉利克存放了大约150颗B61核弹。虽然草案没有说明每个基地有多少枚炸弹，但这些信息在网上很容易获得，尽管准确性各不相同。
▲Draft NATO-affiliated report reveals number & location of US nukes in Europe （via RT）
上述文件虽已被删除，但最新版本的报告似乎却从另一个隐晦的角度证明了这个消息：
The document does not attribute this information to any source。 Last week， a final version of the report was published online， and it omits the specific reference to where bombs are stored。 Instead， the report refers vaguely to aircraft that could carry nuclear weapons。
这份文件并没有注明信息源。上周，该报告的最终版本在网上公布，并删去了炸弹储存的具体参考地点。取而代之的是，报告含糊地提到了可以携带核武器的飞机。
“The European Allies often cited as operating such aircraft are Belgium， Germany， Italy， The Netherlands， and Turkey，” the document said， with a footnote citing a 2018 report by the Nuclear Threat Initiative， a U.S。 nongovernmental organization。
文件援引美国非政府组织“核威胁倡议”2018年的报告中的内容作为脚注，称：“经常被举例为操作此类飞机的欧洲盟国是比利时、德国、意大利、荷兰和土耳其。”
▲Secret locations of U.S。 nuclear weapons in Europe accidentally included in report from NATO parliament （via the Washington Post）
大家看懂了吗
美国核武器地点泄露？报告作者表示：
Sen。 Joseph Day， the author of the report， wrote in an email that the first version of the report was only a draft and that changes may be made to the report until it is dealt with by the NATO Parliamentary Assembly in November。 “All information used in this report is open source material，” he wrote。
报告作者约瑟夫·戴参议员在一封电子邮件中写道，报告的第一版只是一份草稿，在11月北约议会会议讨论报告之前，可以对报告作一些修改。“本报告中使用的所有信息都是开源材料，”他写道。
▲Secret locations of U.S。 nuclear weapons in Europe accidentally included in report from NATO parliament （via the Washington Post）
北约某官员也开始甩锅：
As a rule， neither the United States nor its European partners discuss the location of Washington’s nuclear weapons on the continent。 “We do not comment on the details of NATO’s nuclear posture，” said a NATO official， speaking on the condition of anonymity in line with the organization’s rules for talking to the media。
一般来说，美国及其欧洲伙伴都没有讨论美国政府的核武器在欧洲大陆位置。“我们对北约核态势的细节不作评论，”一位不愿透露姓名的北约官员表示。
“This is not an official NATO document，” the official added， noting that it was written by members of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly。
“这不是北约的正式文件，”这位官员补充说道，并指出这是北约议会成员写的。
▲Secret locations of U.S。 nuclear weapons in Europe accidentally included in report from NATO parliament （via the Washington Post）
但“秘密的泄露”似乎并不是这件事的重点。这些核武器存放至今是为何？有专家担心这会引发军备竞赛，有专家认为这很危险。。。。。。
The presence of the weapons derived from an agreement reached in the 1960s and is in many ways a relic of the Cold War era — designed not only to act as deterrence to the nuclear armed-Soviet Union， but also to convince countries that they didn’t need their own nuclear weapons program。
这些武器的存在源于20世纪60年代达成的协议，从许多方面看来是冷战时代的遗物——不仅旨在威慑核武装的苏联，而且旨在说服各国，它们不需要自己的核武器项目。
But times have changed。 In 2016， after a coup attempt and the rapid spread of the Islamic State extremist group next door， analysts openly wondered whether Turkey was really such a great place to store nuclear weapons。
但时代已经变了。2016年，土耳其发生政变，邻国伊斯兰国极端组织迅速蔓延，分析人士公开质疑，土耳其是否真的是一个储存核武器的好地方。
▲Secret locations of U.S。 nuclear weapons in Europe accidentally included in report from NATO parliament （via the Washington Post）
许多网友也发出质疑：
很难理解为什么拥有这些武器的欧洲国家自愿成为美国的目标。我想知道美国是否真的关心这个问题。
如果一个疯狂的总统控制了他们，那不是很可怕吗？（疯狂暗示）
（这次泄露）绝非意外
你如何看待这次美国核弹储藏位置泄露？
文：YANMING
责任编辑：张申
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/95254...clear-europe-accidentally-leaked-nato-report/
BOMBSHELL Top secret locations of 150 US nukes hidden in Europe are accidentally leaked in Nato report sparking major security fears
- Tariq Tahir
- 17 Jul 2019, 14:39
- Updated: 17 Jul 2019, 14:45
The United States and its allies in the Nato military alliance never disclose the locations of the nuclear arsenal but it appears the six sites have inadvertently disclosed.
3
The nuke sites where the nuclear weapons are being deployed - it has been reported they are of the B61 type pictured being tested
A draft version of the document entitled “A new era for nuclear deterrence? Modernisation, arms control and allied nuclear forces” was published earlier this year.
But Belgian newspaper De Morgen spotted that it contained details about the nuke sites.
A section on the nuclear arsenal read: “These bombs are stored at six US and European bases — Kleine Brogel in Belgium, Büchel in Germany, Aviano and Ghedi-Torre in Italy, Volkel in The Netherlands, and Incirlik in Turkey.”
The study was written by a Canadian senator Joseph Day for the Defense and Security Committee of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly.
The final version of the report has now been published online with specific reference to where bombs are stored deleted.
NUKES REVEALED
Instead it refers vaguely to aircraft that could carry nuclear weapons.Senator Day told the Washington Post the original document was only a draft and “all information used in this report is open source material”.
A Nato spokesman said: “We do not comment on the details of NATO’s nuclear posture. This is not an official NATO document.”
It has been reported that the US has deployed the B61 bomb in Europe.
The presence of US nuclear weapons in Europe is a relic of the Cold War and they were originally stationed to deter Soviet aggression.
At the height of tensions, the US is believed to have deployed 110 nuclear weapons at RAF Lakenheath, which were removed in 2008.
America has indicated it may spend more than £703 billion by the 2040s upgrading its nuclear capabilities.
3
The United States and Russia are due to meet today to discuss the possibility of a three-way nuclear arms treaty, including China for the first time.
The talks are being held two weeks before the formal end to the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty between Russia and the US.
The 1987 agreement was signed in 1987 in Washington D.C. by President Ronald Regan and Soviet Union General Secretary Mikhail Gorbachev and greatly reduced nuclear weapons in Europe.
By May 1991, 2,692 missiles had been eliminated and 10 years of on-site verification inspections followed.
Donald Trump signalled the America would withdraw from the treaty because Russia had been "violating it for many years".
Earlier this year a UN arms chief said the threat of nuclear war is at its highest since World War II.
3
The Aviano Air Base in Italy has been revealed as the site of US nuclear weaponsCredit: Alamy
UN security expert Renata Dwan says risk of nuclear weapons being used is highest since World War Two
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/...rmany-italy-turkey-belgium-nato-a9008111.html
Secret locations of US nuclear weapons in Europe accidentally leaked
‘These bombs are stored at six US and European bases’, says Nato committee report
- Samuel Osborne @SamuelOsborne93
- Wednesday 17 July 2019 10:45
Click to follow
The Independent
The secret locations of US nuclear weapons stored in Europe have been accidentally revealed in a report published by a Nato committee.
The document referred to the sites of roughly 150 American nuclear weapons.
“These bombs are stored at six US and European bases — Kleine Brogel in Belgium, Büchel in Germany, Aviano and Ghedi-Torre in Italy, Volkel in The Netherlands, and Incirlik in Turkey,” a section of the report seen by Belgian newspaper De Morgen said.
The information was included in an early version of the report published in April by the Defence and Security Committee of the Nato Parliamentary Assembly, titled A New Era for Nuclear Deterrence? Modernisation, Arms Control and Allied Nuclear Forces.
However, the reference has since been removed from the final version released last week.
Which countries have nuclear weapons?
Show all 14
The latest version of the report instead makes reference to aircraft capable of carrying nuclear weapons, adding: “The European Allies often cited as operating such aircraft are Belgium, Germany, Italy, The Netherlands, and Turkey.”
A Nato official told The Washington Post the report was “not an official Nato document” and pointed out that it was written by the alliance’s parliamentary assembly.
“We do not comment on the details of Nato’s nuclear posture,” they added.
Independent Minds Events: get involved in the news agenda
While the storing of American nuclear weapons in Europe has long been regarded as an open secret, media organisations on the continent viewed the document as confirmation.
“Finally in black and white: There are American nuclear weapons in Belgian,” the De Morgen report was headlined.
“Nato reveals the Netherlands’ worst-kept secret,” Dutch broadcaster RTL News said.
https://thehill.com/policy/internat...n-locations-in-europe-accidentally-exposed-in
US nuclear weapon locations in Europe accidentally exposed in NATO committee report
By Owen Daugherty - 07/16/19 08:44 PM EDT 230
347
AddThis Sharing Buttons
Share to Facebook
Share to Twitter
© Getty Images
A report from a NATO committee that has since been deleted reportedly exposed the the secret locations of U.S. nuclear weapons in Europe.
The Washington Post reports that the document by a Canadian senator for the Defense and Security Committee of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly detailed the future of the organization’s nuclear deterrence policy but accidentally exposed the open secret.
The report stated that U.S. nuclear weapons are being stored in Belgium, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands and Turkey.
While the document titled “A new era for nuclear deterrence? Modernisation, arms control and allied nuclear forces” was originally published in April without making waves, a Belgian newspaper Tuesday published a copy of the document featuring the locations of about 150 U.S. nuclear weapons.
“These bombs are stored at six US and European bases — Kleine Brogel in Belgium, Büchel in Germany, Aviano and Ghedi-Torre in Italy, Volkel in The Netherlands, and Incirlik in Turkey,” a section of the newspaper’s report read, according to the Post.
The Post made note that the original document did not attribute this information to any source.
A final version of the report was reportedly published last week that did not have any specific references to where the weapons are stored.
“This is not an official NATO document,” a NATO official told the Post, making clear that it was written by members of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly.
“We do not comment on the details of NATO’s nuclear posture,” the official said, remaining anonymous due to the organization’s policy for discussing matters regarding nuclear weapons with the media.
Kingston Reif, director for disarmament and threat-reduction policy at the Arms Control Association, told the Post in an email that it was no surprise to potentially discover the location of U.S. nuclear weapons in Europe.
“This has long been fairly open knowledge,” he said.
