https://mil.news.sina.com.cn/jssd/2019-12-31/doc-iihnzahk1065501.shtml
台军新导弹能打到浙江？张召忠：台湾解放前都难服役
台军新导弹能打到浙江？张召忠：台湾解放前都难服役
806
来源：局座召忠
近日，根据部分台湾媒体报道，台军计划于2021年左右量产所谓的“雄风”二型和“雄风”三型超音速反舰导弹的增程版。在报道中，有些媒体直接将这些新型导弹的射程划到了大陆，宣称能够“打到浙江至广东外海”。
一直以来，“雄风”三型反舰导弹都是台军和部分台湾媒体宣称的“航母杀手”，在他们口中，不要说对付解放军的航母和战舰，就是美国海军航母战斗群，遇上“雄三”也是有来无回。就连美国和日本都极度“眼馋”“雄三”，一直想从台湾购买这种导弹……
不过对于台方部分人引以为傲的“飞弹”，恐怕绝大多数大陆网友的印象还停留在“误击渔船”这一乌龙事件上。
遭到误击的“翔利昇”号
2016年7月1日，台军锦江级巡逻舰“金江”号在进行“雄风”三型导弹的测试时，失误射出一枚“雄风”三型导弹。导弹飞行了约40海里后，在澎湖列岛的东南方海域命中高雄籍渔船“翔利昇”号。“翔利昇”号船长当场死亡，三名船员受伤。导弹贯穿船体后继续飞行一段时间，随后坠入大海。
右为锦江级巡逻舰“金江”号
这号称能“摧毁美国海军航母战斗群”的“雄三飞弹”，怎么打一艘小渔船还这么困难呢？其实，这还真不是导弹的错。作为一种超音速反舰导弹，“雄风”三型导弹能够有效的贯穿现代军舰的多层舱壁，在舰体内部爆炸。而渔船的船体在超音速导弹面前薄的像纸一样，导弹打在上面当然是一穿而过。并不是“雄三”威力不够，只是渔船太小了而已。
尽管如此，“雄三”的性能仍然难说是尽如人意。首先我们忽略部分媒体的搞笑信息，从技术上对“雄风”三型导弹进行分析。作为一种超音速反舰导弹，“雄风”三显然是比较先进的：毕竟全世界也没有多少国家和地区具备研制超音速反舰导弹的能力。
雄风”三型导弹
但如果和同一级别的超音速反舰导弹相比，“雄风”三可就有点露怯了。“雄风”三型导弹采用的是液态燃料冲压发动机，并在弹体外加装火箭助推器的设计。虽然台媒总是号称“雄三飞弹”是自主研发，但其实“雄风”三的设计仍然起源自美国。
超音速战术导弹（STM）
20世纪60年代，美国沃特公司开始了ALVRJ计划，准备研制一种“先进小体积冲压发动机”。ALVRJ后来转变为“超音速战术导弹”（STM）计划，不过最终被美国海军取消。经过了十多年的研发和竞标，沃特公司投入了大量的资金和时间，但却被美国海军放弃。1984年，这个“倒霉孩子”也被转手出售，接盘的正是台“中科院”。
鹰击一号（C-101）导弹
在STM的基础上，台“中科院”结合此前开发“熊二”的经验，很快照葫芦画瓢的搞出了样弹。1997年，“雄三”的原型弹首飞，可以说这个时候，“雄风”三型导弹的性能在世界上还是比较先进的，稍稍强于中国大陆同一时期研制的“鹰击一号”导弹，但仍然逊于俄罗斯的Kh-31P反舰导弹。
鹰击-18超音速反舰导弹
不过如今距离“雄三”首飞，已经过去了整整22年，“鹰击一号”也进化成了“鹰击-18”。作为一种上世纪60年代技术改进而来的超音速反舰导弹，“雄三”相比鹰击-18、“布拉莫斯”和ASM-3等新时代反舰导弹，无疑已经大幅落后了。
Kh-31导弹
作为一种反舰导弹，“雄三”的体积相对较大，这是因为外挂的火箭助推器占用了大量空间。由于这种落后设计，“雄三”不能空射，舰艇和地面发射平台的载弹量也会受限。相比之下，俄罗斯80年代开发的Kh-31P虽然也是外挂火箭助推器，但尺寸却远小于“雄三”，因此能够在战斗机上发射。
“布拉莫斯”超音速反舰导弹
如果和三哥的“布拉莫斯”相比，那么“雄三飞弹”的性能简直不堪一提。作为一种重型反舰导弹，“布拉莫斯”重达3吨，是“雄三”的一倍还要多，射程远远超过“雄三”，甚至能搭载核弹头。而且虽然尺寸更大，但“布拉莫斯”却能从战斗机上发射，这也是“雄三”做不到的。
ASM-3超音速反舰导弹
和日本的ASM-3反舰导弹相比，“雄三”更是显得“傻大黑粗”。ASM-3不仅采用了先进的整体火箭冲压发动机技术，还采取了隐身设计，是完完全全的新一代超音速反舰导弹。虽然ASM-3的前景尚不明朗，性能也不能让自卫队满意，但仍然不是古董一样的“雄三”能比较的。日本想从台湾采购“雄三”无疑是天方夜谭。
当然，我们这里就不拿威力巨大的“雄三飞弹”和俄罗斯最新的“锆石”高超音速反舰导弹对比了，毕竟这两种导弹根本不是一个量级的。
舰载型的“雄风”三型导弹
而台湾部分媒体将“雄三飞弹”吹成是“航母杀手”更是一厢情愿了。要知道面对防御完备的航母战斗群，少数几枚反舰导弹根本无法造成什么有效损害。如果面对装备和战术水平接近甚至超过解放军的对手，台军绝大多数水面舰艇都会在第一时间被摧毁，很难构成有效打击。
相比舰载的“雄三”，陆基的导弹发射车的隐蔽性更强，威胁还要稍大一些。但当对手掌握制空权后，这些陆基发射车的生存性也实在是堪忧，基本上沦为“一次性”用品。或许能够损伤几艘中小型舰船，但很难威胁到航母等大型战舰。
这次报道中的“雄三”增程型，尚没有确切的资料，但如果真的和部分台湾媒体宣称的一样“能打到浙江”，那这个增程“雄三”的体积肯定更加巨大，能不能塞进普通“雄三”的发射筒里发射都成问题。恐怕直到台湾解放之前，这个增程“雄三”都很难形成战斗力了。
Can Taiwan ’s new missile hit Zhejiang? Zhang Zhaozhong: It is difficult to serve in Taiwan before liberation
Can Taiwan ’s new missile hit Zhejiang? Zhang Zhaozhong: It is difficult to serve in Taiwan before liberation
806
Source: Zhuo Zhongzhong
Recently, according to some Taiwan media reports, the Taiwan Army plans to mass-produce extended range versions of the so-called "Xiongfeng" Type 2 and "Xiongfeng" Type III supersonic anti-ship missiles around 2021. In the report, some media have directly extended the range of these new missiles to the mainland, claiming to be able to "strike the sea off Zhejiang to Guangdong".
For a long time, the "Xiongfeng" type III anti-ship missiles have been declared as "carrier killers" by the Taiwan military and some Taiwan media. In their mouth, do not say that the aircraft carriers and warships that deal with the PLA are the US Navy aircraft carrier battle group. "There is no return. Even the United States and Japan are extremely "eye-catching" and "Yongsan" and have always wanted to buy such missiles from Taiwan ...
However, with regard to the "missile" that some people in Taiwan are proud of, I am afraid that the impression of the vast majority of mainland netizens is still in the blunder incident of "missing a fishing boat".
"Xiang Li Sheng" was hit by mistake
On July 1, 2016, the Taiwan Army Jinjiang-class patrol ship "Jinjiang" erroneously fired a "Xiongfeng" type III missile during the test of the "Xiongfeng" type III missile. After the missile flew about 40 nautical miles, it hit the Kaohsiung fishing vessel "Xiang Li Sheng" in the southeast waters of the Penghu Islands. The captain of "Xianglisheng" died on the spot and three crew members were injured. The missile continued to fly for some time after penetrating the hull, and then crashed into the sea.
On the right is the Jinjiang-class patrol ship Jinjiang
How can it be so difficult to hit a small fishing boat with this "male three missile" that can "destroy the US Navy aircraft carrier battle group"? In fact, this is really not the fault of the missile. As a supersonic anti-ship missile, the "Xiongfeng" type 3 missile can effectively penetrate the multilayer bulkheads of modern warships and explode inside the hull. The hull of the fishing boat is thin and paper-like in front of the supersonic missile, and of course the missile hits it. It's not that the "Three Men" is not powerful enough, it's just that the fishing boat is too small.
Nevertheless, the performance of "Yongsan" is still difficult to say. First of all, we ignore the funny information of some media and analyze the "Xiongfeng" three missiles technically. As a supersonic anti-ship missile, "Xiongfeng III" is obviously more advanced: after all, not many countries and regions in the world have the ability to develop supersonic anti-ship missiles.
"Xiongfeng" type III missile
But if compared with the supersonic anti-ship missiles of the same level, the "Xiongfeng" Sanke can be a bit timid. The "Xiongfeng" type III missile uses a liquid fuel ram engine and is equipped with a rocket booster outside the missile body. Although Taiwan Media always claims that the "Xiongsan Missile" is independently developed, in fact, the design of the "Xiongfeng III" still originates from the United States.
Supersonic Tactical Missile (STM)
In the 1960s, the American Water Company started the ALVRJ program, preparing to develop an "advanced small-volume stamping engine". ALVRJ later transformed into the Supersonic Tactical Missile (STM) program, but was eventually cancelled by the US Navy. After more than ten years of research and development and bidding, Water Company invested a lot of money and time, but was abandoned by the US Navy. In 1984, this "unlucky child" was also sold for sale, and it was the Taiwan "Chinese Academy of Sciences" that took over.
Eagle Strike One (C-101) Missile
Based on the STM, the "Chinese Academy of Sciences" of Taiwan combined with the previous experience of developing "Bear II", and took a snapshot of the gourd painting. In 1997, the prototype of the "Xiong III" flew for the first time. At this time, it can be said that the performance of the "Xiongfeng" type III missile is still relatively advanced in the world, slightly stronger than the "Eagle Strike 1" missile developed in the same period in mainland China. But still inferior to Russia's Kh-31P anti-ship missile.
Eagle Strike-18 Supersonic Anti-ship Missile
However, it has now been 22 years since the first flight from the "Three Heroes", and the "Eagle Strike One" has also evolved into the "Eagle Strike-18". As a supersonic anti-ship missile improved from the technology of the 1960s, the "Male III" has undoubtedly fallen behind compared to the new era anti-ship missiles such as the Hawk-18, BrahMos and ASM-3. .
Kh-31 missile
As an anti-ship missile, the volume of "Xiong III" is relatively large, because the external rocket booster takes up a lot of space. Due to this backward design, the "Xiong III" cannot be air-launched, and the bomb load of ships and ground launching platforms will also be limited. In contrast, although the Kh-31P developed by Russia in the 1980s is also an external rocket booster, it is much smaller than the "Three Kings" and can therefore be launched on a fighter jet.
"Brahmos" supersonic anti-ship missile
If compared with the third brother's "Brahmos", then the performance of "Three Missiles" is simply incomparable. As a heavy anti-ship missile, "Brahmos" weighs 3 tons, which is more than double that of "Xiao III". Its range is far more than that of "XIII", and it can even carry a nuclear warhead. And even though the size is larger, the Brahmos can be launched from a fighter plane, which is also impossible for the "Three Heroes".
ASM-3 supersonic anti-ship missile
Compared with Japan's ASM-3 anti-ship missiles, the "Three Miscellaneous" is even more "stupid and rough." ASM-3 not only uses advanced integrated rocket ram engine technology, but also adopts a stealth design. It is a completely new generation of supersonic anti-ship missiles. Although the future of ASM-3 is unclear and the performance is not satisfactory to the Self-Defense Force, it is still not comparable to the antique "Three Men". It is no wonder Japan wants Japan to purchase "Three Men" from Taiwan.
Of course, we will not compare the powerful "Three Missiles" with Russia's latest "Zircon" hypersonic anti-ship missiles. After all, these two missiles are not an order of magnitude at all.
Carrier-based "Xiongfeng" three missiles
And some Taiwan media have made the "Three Missiles" a "carrier killer" even more wishful thinking. We must know that in the face of a well-defended carrier battle group, a few anti-ship missiles cannot cause any effective damage at all. If confronted with opponents whose equipment and tactical levels are close to or even higher than those of the PLA, most surface ships of the Taiwan Army will be destroyed in the first place, making it difficult to constitute an effective strike.
Compared with the shipborne "Xiong III", the land-based missile launch vehicle is more concealed and the threat is slightly greater. However, when the opponent has control of the air, the survivability of these land-based launch vehicles is really worrying, basically reduced to "disposable" supplies. It may be able to damage several small and medium ships, but it is difficult to threaten large warships such as aircraft carriers.
There is no exact data for the "Xiongsan" range extension in this report, but if it is really "capable of reaching Zhejiang" as claimed by some Taiwan media, then the volume of the "Xiongsan" range will certainly be even greater Can not be shoved into the launch box of ordinary "Three Thirds" is a problem. I am afraid that until the liberation of Taiwan, it is difficult for this extended range "Yongsan" to form combat effectiveness.
台军新导弹能打到浙江？张召忠：台湾解放前都难服役
台军新导弹能打到浙江？张召忠：台湾解放前都难服役
806
来源：局座召忠
近日，根据部分台湾媒体报道，台军计划于2021年左右量产所谓的“雄风”二型和“雄风”三型超音速反舰导弹的增程版。在报道中，有些媒体直接将这些新型导弹的射程划到了大陆，宣称能够“打到浙江至广东外海”。
一直以来，“雄风”三型反舰导弹都是台军和部分台湾媒体宣称的“航母杀手”，在他们口中，不要说对付解放军的航母和战舰，就是美国海军航母战斗群，遇上“雄三”也是有来无回。就连美国和日本都极度“眼馋”“雄三”，一直想从台湾购买这种导弹……
不过对于台方部分人引以为傲的“飞弹”，恐怕绝大多数大陆网友的印象还停留在“误击渔船”这一乌龙事件上。
遭到误击的“翔利昇”号
2016年7月1日，台军锦江级巡逻舰“金江”号在进行“雄风”三型导弹的测试时，失误射出一枚“雄风”三型导弹。导弹飞行了约40海里后，在澎湖列岛的东南方海域命中高雄籍渔船“翔利昇”号。“翔利昇”号船长当场死亡，三名船员受伤。导弹贯穿船体后继续飞行一段时间，随后坠入大海。
右为锦江级巡逻舰“金江”号
这号称能“摧毁美国海军航母战斗群”的“雄三飞弹”，怎么打一艘小渔船还这么困难呢？其实，这还真不是导弹的错。作为一种超音速反舰导弹，“雄风”三型导弹能够有效的贯穿现代军舰的多层舱壁，在舰体内部爆炸。而渔船的船体在超音速导弹面前薄的像纸一样，导弹打在上面当然是一穿而过。并不是“雄三”威力不够，只是渔船太小了而已。
尽管如此，“雄三”的性能仍然难说是尽如人意。首先我们忽略部分媒体的搞笑信息，从技术上对“雄风”三型导弹进行分析。作为一种超音速反舰导弹，“雄风”三显然是比较先进的：毕竟全世界也没有多少国家和地区具备研制超音速反舰导弹的能力。
雄风”三型导弹
但如果和同一级别的超音速反舰导弹相比，“雄风”三可就有点露怯了。“雄风”三型导弹采用的是液态燃料冲压发动机，并在弹体外加装火箭助推器的设计。虽然台媒总是号称“雄三飞弹”是自主研发，但其实“雄风”三的设计仍然起源自美国。
超音速战术导弹（STM）
20世纪60年代，美国沃特公司开始了ALVRJ计划，准备研制一种“先进小体积冲压发动机”。ALVRJ后来转变为“超音速战术导弹”（STM）计划，不过最终被美国海军取消。经过了十多年的研发和竞标，沃特公司投入了大量的资金和时间，但却被美国海军放弃。1984年，这个“倒霉孩子”也被转手出售，接盘的正是台“中科院”。
鹰击一号（C-101）导弹
在STM的基础上，台“中科院”结合此前开发“熊二”的经验，很快照葫芦画瓢的搞出了样弹。1997年，“雄三”的原型弹首飞，可以说这个时候，“雄风”三型导弹的性能在世界上还是比较先进的，稍稍强于中国大陆同一时期研制的“鹰击一号”导弹，但仍然逊于俄罗斯的Kh-31P反舰导弹。
鹰击-18超音速反舰导弹
不过如今距离“雄三”首飞，已经过去了整整22年，“鹰击一号”也进化成了“鹰击-18”。作为一种上世纪60年代技术改进而来的超音速反舰导弹，“雄三”相比鹰击-18、“布拉莫斯”和ASM-3等新时代反舰导弹，无疑已经大幅落后了。
Kh-31导弹
作为一种反舰导弹，“雄三”的体积相对较大，这是因为外挂的火箭助推器占用了大量空间。由于这种落后设计，“雄三”不能空射，舰艇和地面发射平台的载弹量也会受限。相比之下，俄罗斯80年代开发的Kh-31P虽然也是外挂火箭助推器，但尺寸却远小于“雄三”，因此能够在战斗机上发射。
“布拉莫斯”超音速反舰导弹
如果和三哥的“布拉莫斯”相比，那么“雄三飞弹”的性能简直不堪一提。作为一种重型反舰导弹，“布拉莫斯”重达3吨，是“雄三”的一倍还要多，射程远远超过“雄三”，甚至能搭载核弹头。而且虽然尺寸更大，但“布拉莫斯”却能从战斗机上发射，这也是“雄三”做不到的。
ASM-3超音速反舰导弹
和日本的ASM-3反舰导弹相比，“雄三”更是显得“傻大黑粗”。ASM-3不仅采用了先进的整体火箭冲压发动机技术，还采取了隐身设计，是完完全全的新一代超音速反舰导弹。虽然ASM-3的前景尚不明朗，性能也不能让自卫队满意，但仍然不是古董一样的“雄三”能比较的。日本想从台湾采购“雄三”无疑是天方夜谭。
当然，我们这里就不拿威力巨大的“雄三飞弹”和俄罗斯最新的“锆石”高超音速反舰导弹对比了，毕竟这两种导弹根本不是一个量级的。
舰载型的“雄风”三型导弹
而台湾部分媒体将“雄三飞弹”吹成是“航母杀手”更是一厢情愿了。要知道面对防御完备的航母战斗群，少数几枚反舰导弹根本无法造成什么有效损害。如果面对装备和战术水平接近甚至超过解放军的对手，台军绝大多数水面舰艇都会在第一时间被摧毁，很难构成有效打击。
相比舰载的“雄三”，陆基的导弹发射车的隐蔽性更强，威胁还要稍大一些。但当对手掌握制空权后，这些陆基发射车的生存性也实在是堪忧，基本上沦为“一次性”用品。或许能够损伤几艘中小型舰船，但很难威胁到航母等大型战舰。
这次报道中的“雄三”增程型，尚没有确切的资料，但如果真的和部分台湾媒体宣称的一样“能打到浙江”，那这个增程“雄三”的体积肯定更加巨大，能不能塞进普通“雄三”的发射筒里发射都成问题。恐怕直到台湾解放之前，这个增程“雄三”都很难形成战斗力了。
Can Taiwan ’s new missile hit Zhejiang? Zhang Zhaozhong: It is difficult to serve in Taiwan before liberation
Can Taiwan ’s new missile hit Zhejiang? Zhang Zhaozhong: It is difficult to serve in Taiwan before liberation
806
Source: Zhuo Zhongzhong
Recently, according to some Taiwan media reports, the Taiwan Army plans to mass-produce extended range versions of the so-called "Xiongfeng" Type 2 and "Xiongfeng" Type III supersonic anti-ship missiles around 2021. In the report, some media have directly extended the range of these new missiles to the mainland, claiming to be able to "strike the sea off Zhejiang to Guangdong".
For a long time, the "Xiongfeng" type III anti-ship missiles have been declared as "carrier killers" by the Taiwan military and some Taiwan media. In their mouth, do not say that the aircraft carriers and warships that deal with the PLA are the US Navy aircraft carrier battle group. "There is no return. Even the United States and Japan are extremely "eye-catching" and "Yongsan" and have always wanted to buy such missiles from Taiwan ...
However, with regard to the "missile" that some people in Taiwan are proud of, I am afraid that the impression of the vast majority of mainland netizens is still in the blunder incident of "missing a fishing boat".
"Xiang Li Sheng" was hit by mistake
On July 1, 2016, the Taiwan Army Jinjiang-class patrol ship "Jinjiang" erroneously fired a "Xiongfeng" type III missile during the test of the "Xiongfeng" type III missile. After the missile flew about 40 nautical miles, it hit the Kaohsiung fishing vessel "Xiang Li Sheng" in the southeast waters of the Penghu Islands. The captain of "Xianglisheng" died on the spot and three crew members were injured. The missile continued to fly for some time after penetrating the hull, and then crashed into the sea.
On the right is the Jinjiang-class patrol ship Jinjiang
How can it be so difficult to hit a small fishing boat with this "male three missile" that can "destroy the US Navy aircraft carrier battle group"? In fact, this is really not the fault of the missile. As a supersonic anti-ship missile, the "Xiongfeng" type 3 missile can effectively penetrate the multilayer bulkheads of modern warships and explode inside the hull. The hull of the fishing boat is thin and paper-like in front of the supersonic missile, and of course the missile hits it. It's not that the "Three Men" is not powerful enough, it's just that the fishing boat is too small.
Nevertheless, the performance of "Yongsan" is still difficult to say. First of all, we ignore the funny information of some media and analyze the "Xiongfeng" three missiles technically. As a supersonic anti-ship missile, "Xiongfeng III" is obviously more advanced: after all, not many countries and regions in the world have the ability to develop supersonic anti-ship missiles.
"Xiongfeng" type III missile
But if compared with the supersonic anti-ship missiles of the same level, the "Xiongfeng" Sanke can be a bit timid. The "Xiongfeng" type III missile uses a liquid fuel ram engine and is equipped with a rocket booster outside the missile body. Although Taiwan Media always claims that the "Xiongsan Missile" is independently developed, in fact, the design of the "Xiongfeng III" still originates from the United States.
Supersonic Tactical Missile (STM)
In the 1960s, the American Water Company started the ALVRJ program, preparing to develop an "advanced small-volume stamping engine". ALVRJ later transformed into the Supersonic Tactical Missile (STM) program, but was eventually cancelled by the US Navy. After more than ten years of research and development and bidding, Water Company invested a lot of money and time, but was abandoned by the US Navy. In 1984, this "unlucky child" was also sold for sale, and it was the Taiwan "Chinese Academy of Sciences" that took over.
Eagle Strike One (C-101) Missile
Based on the STM, the "Chinese Academy of Sciences" of Taiwan combined with the previous experience of developing "Bear II", and took a snapshot of the gourd painting. In 1997, the prototype of the "Xiong III" flew for the first time. At this time, it can be said that the performance of the "Xiongfeng" type III missile is still relatively advanced in the world, slightly stronger than the "Eagle Strike 1" missile developed in the same period in mainland China. But still inferior to Russia's Kh-31P anti-ship missile.
Eagle Strike-18 Supersonic Anti-ship Missile
However, it has now been 22 years since the first flight from the "Three Heroes", and the "Eagle Strike One" has also evolved into the "Eagle Strike-18". As a supersonic anti-ship missile improved from the technology of the 1960s, the "Male III" has undoubtedly fallen behind compared to the new era anti-ship missiles such as the Hawk-18, BrahMos and ASM-3. .
Kh-31 missile
As an anti-ship missile, the volume of "Xiong III" is relatively large, because the external rocket booster takes up a lot of space. Due to this backward design, the "Xiong III" cannot be air-launched, and the bomb load of ships and ground launching platforms will also be limited. In contrast, although the Kh-31P developed by Russia in the 1980s is also an external rocket booster, it is much smaller than the "Three Kings" and can therefore be launched on a fighter jet.
"Brahmos" supersonic anti-ship missile
If compared with the third brother's "Brahmos", then the performance of "Three Missiles" is simply incomparable. As a heavy anti-ship missile, "Brahmos" weighs 3 tons, which is more than double that of "Xiao III". Its range is far more than that of "XIII", and it can even carry a nuclear warhead. And even though the size is larger, the Brahmos can be launched from a fighter plane, which is also impossible for the "Three Heroes".
ASM-3 supersonic anti-ship missile
Compared with Japan's ASM-3 anti-ship missiles, the "Three Miscellaneous" is even more "stupid and rough." ASM-3 not only uses advanced integrated rocket ram engine technology, but also adopts a stealth design. It is a completely new generation of supersonic anti-ship missiles. Although the future of ASM-3 is unclear and the performance is not satisfactory to the Self-Defense Force, it is still not comparable to the antique "Three Men". It is no wonder Japan wants Japan to purchase "Three Men" from Taiwan.
Of course, we will not compare the powerful "Three Missiles" with Russia's latest "Zircon" hypersonic anti-ship missiles. After all, these two missiles are not an order of magnitude at all.
Carrier-based "Xiongfeng" three missiles
And some Taiwan media have made the "Three Missiles" a "carrier killer" even more wishful thinking. We must know that in the face of a well-defended carrier battle group, a few anti-ship missiles cannot cause any effective damage at all. If confronted with opponents whose equipment and tactical levels are close to or even higher than those of the PLA, most surface ships of the Taiwan Army will be destroyed in the first place, making it difficult to constitute an effective strike.
Compared with the shipborne "Xiong III", the land-based missile launch vehicle is more concealed and the threat is slightly greater. However, when the opponent has control of the air, the survivability of these land-based launch vehicles is really worrying, basically reduced to "disposable" supplies. It may be able to damage several small and medium ships, but it is difficult to threaten large warships such as aircraft carriers.
There is no exact data for the "Xiongsan" range extension in this report, but if it is really "capable of reaching Zhejiang" as claimed by some Taiwan media, then the volume of the "Xiongsan" range will certainly be even greater Can not be shoved into the launch box of ordinary "Three Thirds" is a problem. I am afraid that until the liberation of Taiwan, it is difficult for this extended range "Yongsan" to form combat effectiveness.
