In his typically free-associating riff, Pope Francis acknowledged “there have been priests and bishops” who have committed sexual abuse against nuns, and that “it’s continuing because it’s not like once you realise it that it stops”. He said the church needed to do more.
But while attempting to show that his predecessor, Pope Benedict XVI, took tough action on the issue of sexual abuse against nuns, he recalled a separate case of a religious order marred with sexual and economic corruption, but apparently was not one involving nuns.
Pope Francis recounted that Pope Benedict, then known as Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, the church’s doctrinal watchdog, marshalled all his evidence against the complicit order in a meeting with Pope John Paul II. Pope Francis said Pope Benedict returned defeated and told his secretary, “The other side won.” Pope Francis added in an aside, “We should not be scandalised by this — it’s part of a process.”
His point seemed to be that pursuing justice in the church takes time, and he said that when Pope Benedict became pope he immediately told his secretary to get him the files “and let’s start again”.
But his example confounded advocates of nuns abused by priests, who noted that the pope is the single person within the church with absolute authority to take action at any time.
“I was wondering when he said they were dealing with the problem for a long time, because we just don’t know what those actions are,” said Zuzanna Flisowska, general manager of Voices of Faith, a group advocating for more participation by women in lay leadership positions inside the church.
“We feel a little disappointed that it has to be the media who has to press the church and the pope to comment,” she added.
Experts say there is no shortage of factors contributing to the abuse, its cover-up and the lack of action inside the Vatican.