台湾医生现在很惨. 经常集体辞职罢工. click this for video
https://tw.news.yahoo.com/台大名醫的沉痛自白：「在台灣當醫師豬狗不如」-043109666.html
台大名醫的沉痛自白：「在台灣當醫師豬狗不如」「小孩當醫師我一定打斷腿」
Yahoo奇摩（新聞）
1k 人追蹤
2018年3月21日 下午12:31
「在台灣當醫師豬狗不如，如果我小孩要去當醫師，我一定打斷他的腿！」近日，民間司法改革基金會在臉書上傳一段影片，台大醫院整形外科主治醫師黃慧夫在鏡頭前吐露出內心悲哀，不隨著同業轉戰醫學美容，為了救人留在又累又忙的醫學中心，這樣的熱忱和使命感擺在法律前卻毫無價值，在過去的司法體制下，一場不公平的醫療判決，幾乎澆熄他的熱血。
10年前，一名14歲李姓少年無照駕駛家人的機車外出，返家途中超速失控撞上路邊汽車，右小腿重創緊急送醫。當時任職於亞東醫院的黃慧夫，立即為受傷的少年進行右腿筋膜切開術急救，而在術後5天少年自行轉院，不料，轉院後卻發現小腿持續內出血而導致壞死，最終少年被迫截肢，家屬因而控告黃慧夫業務過失傷害致重傷罪。" data-reactid="12">10年前，一名14歲李姓少年無照駕駛家人的機車外出，返家途中超速失控撞上路邊汽車，右小腿重創緊急送醫。當時任職於亞東醫院的黃慧夫，立即為受傷的少年進行右腿筋膜切開術急救，而在術後5天少年自行轉院，不料，轉院後卻發現小腿持續內出血而導致壞死，最終少年被迫截肢，家屬因而控告黃慧夫業務過失傷害致重傷罪。
原先一審獲判無罪的黃慧夫，在沒有的新事證、新的鑑定報告等情況下，這起醫療糾紛案就這樣在二審時直接翻判，依據刑事訴訟法376條的限制，特定案件在二審確定後，不得再上訴三審，最終，李慧夫在二審得易科罰金12萬元定讞，面對突如其來的翻判，即使有著滿腹的冤屈，卻也無處可訴。" data-reactid="13">原先一審獲判無罪的黃慧夫，在沒有的新事證、新的鑑定報告等情況下，這起醫療糾紛案就這樣在二審時直接翻判，依據刑事訴訟法376條的限制，特定案件在二審確定後，不得再上訴三審，最終，李慧夫在二審得易科罰金12萬元定讞，面對突如其來的翻判，即使有著滿腹的冤屈，卻也無處可訴。
在過去，刑事訴訟法376條的設立確實有實務上的考量，目的在於讓輕判的案件不要拖太久，但這卻也縮限人民的訴訟權，當被告在經一審無罪，二審翻判有罪的情況下，更是顯失公平。另外，即使現在的訴訟採覆審制，其實很多的證據在一審調查過後二審就不再審查，更不用說當案件涉及醫療專業時，也讓不少人質疑，這樣的審查制度真的能做出最公正的判決嗎？" data-reactid="14">在過去，刑事訴訟法376條的設立確實有實務上的考量，目的在於讓輕判的案件不要拖太久，但這卻也縮限人民的訴訟權，當被告在經一審無罪，二審翻判有罪的情況下，更是顯失公平。另外，即使現在的訴訟採覆審制，其實很多的證據在一審調查過後二審就不再審查，更不用說當案件涉及醫療專業時，也讓不少人質疑，這樣的審查制度真的能做出最公正的判決嗎？
立法院在去年底三讀通過「刑事訴訟法」的部分條文修正草案，在未來，特定類型的案件，被告若一審判決無罪，二審改判有罪，修法後都可以上訴，但黃慧夫的醫療糾紛案已經終結，即使修法後依舊沒有上訴的機會，再多的冤屈也只能繼續在法庭之外徘徊。" data-reactid="15">立法院在去年底三讀通過「刑事訴訟法」的部分條文修正草案，在未來，特定類型的案件，被告若一審判決無罪，二審改判有罪，修法後都可以上訴，但黃慧夫的醫療糾紛案已經終結，即使修法後依舊沒有上訴的機會，再多的冤屈也只能繼續在法庭之外徘徊。
面對無法三審，失去辯駁機會，黃慧夫在鏡頭前顯得十分落寞，他非常失望地說：「在台灣千萬、千萬、千萬不要當醫生，醫生是一個豬狗不如的行業。如果有能力的話做好進修，去別的國家當醫生，都比在台灣好。」" data-reactid="16">面對無法三審，失去辯駁機會，黃慧夫在鏡頭前顯得十分落寞，他非常失望地說：「在台灣千萬、千萬、千萬不要當醫生，醫生是一個豬狗不如的行業。如果有能力的話做好進修，去別的國家當醫生，都比在台灣好。」
The doctors in Taiwan are very miserable now. They often resign and go on strike. The doctors at the National Taiwan University have confessed: "When doctors in Taiwan are not as good as pigs and dogs," "When a child is a doctor, I must break my legs." [Yahoo Kimo (News)] Yahoo Kimo (News) 1k People follow March 21, 2018, at 12:31 pm "When doctors in Taiwan are better than pigs and dogs, if my child is going to become a doctor, I must interrupt his legs!" Recently, the Civil Justice Reform Foundation uploaded a copy on Facebook. In the film, Huang Huifu, the attending physician at the Department of Orthopedics at National Taiwan University Hospital, uttered a sad heart in front of the camera. He did not go to the medical cosmetology with her peers. In order to save people and stay in a tired and busy medical center, such enthusiasm and sense of mission were placed before the law. Worthless, under the past judicial system, an unfair medical verdict almost extinguished his blood. Ten years ago, a 14-year-old Li surnamed his teenage boy without a car on his family’s locomotive. When he returned home, he speeded out of control and hit a roadside car. The right calf hit an emergency. Huang Huifu, who worked at Yadong Hospital at the time, immediately performed first-aid right leg fasciotomy for the injured teenager. He transferred himself to the hospital 5 days after the operation. Unexpectedly, after the transfer, he found that the calf sustained internal hemorrhage and resulted in necrosis. After the amputation, the family members accused Huang Huifu of negligent injury and caused serious injury. Huang Huifu, who was acquitted at the first trial, did not have a new case, new appraisal report, and so on. The medical dispute case was directly reversed at the second instance. According to the 376 rule of the Criminal Procedure Law, the specific case was in the second instance. After being confirmed, the third trial must not be appealed. In the end, Li Huifu had a fine of 120,000 yuan in the second instance, which was subject to sudden penalties. Even if he had a grievance, there was no place for complaint. In the past, the establishment of Section 376 of the Criminal Procedure Act did have practical considerations. The purpose was to allow cases of light sentences not to drag on for too long. However, it also narrowed the people’s right to litigation. When the defendant was acquitted at the first instance, the second instance turned aside. In the case of guilt, it is even more obvious that it is fair. In addition, even if the current lawsuit is tried, a lot of evidence will not be reviewed at the second instance after the first-instance investigation. Not to mention that when the case involves the medical profession, many people also question that such a review system can really do Is the most just judgment? The Legislature passed the third revised draft of the "Criminal Procedure Law" at the end of last year. In the future, if the defendant in a certain type of case is not guilty at the first instance, the second instance is found guilty and can be appealed after the amendment, but Huang Huifu's medical dispute case has ended. Even if there is no chance of appeal after the amendment, more grievances can only continue to linger outside the courtroom. Faced with the inability to make a third instance and lose the opportunity to refute, Huang Huifu looked very lonely in front of the camera. He was very disappointed to say, "Ten million, ten million, and ten million must not be doctors in Taiwan. Doctors are an industry inferior to pigs and dogs. If there are If you are able to do advanced studies and go to other countries as doctors, you are better than in Taiwan.” He recalled being a doctor for 13 years. At the time, he had also encountered the Eight Immortals explosion. The hospital has collected 20 patients with burns and burns. Everyone was at risk. As a surgeon, he tried his best. Even if the rest was just lying on the table, the last 20 patients were all saved. Behind the figure of blood sacrifice, in fact, it was very frustrating for Taiwanese medicine. Because of Li’s juvenile lawsuit, Huang Huifu lost all opportunities for promotion and further education, and his future was almost completely destroyed. He also "learns" defensive medical treatment because he does not know how the current patients will deal with you in the future. Many unnecessary examinations and treatments will be necessary. Even medical care that causes extra harm to the patient must be done. Otherwise, it cannot be protected. The physician himself. He feels very sad. "When a doctor first thinks of not how to do his best to cure his patients, but how to protect himself first." Huang Huifu also stressed that he is not allowed to be a doctor. "If he is a doctor, I It was a wrong choice and a wrong career to interrupt his legs." When talking about these words, Huang Huifu kept shaking his head. However, Huang Huifu still chooses to stay in the medical sector even though he has undergone sudden changes in his life. Although the white robe mission continues, the pain caused by the ruthless and evil method cannot be erased. In fact, under the judicial giant tower, there are more people like Huang Huifu. In the past, because of the 376 limitation of the Criminal Procedure Law, they lost the power to appeal their own defenses. Now, what they are waiting for is just another chance for judicial fair trial. attachFull40062 https://tw.news.yahoo.com/%E5%8F%B0%E5%A4%A7%E5%90%8D%E9%86%">Organizing the report: Lin Weixin editor of the nuclear manuscript: Chen Yiru, Shen Mengyan]]>attachFull40062 https://tw.news.yahoo.com/%E5%8F%B0%E5%A4%A7%E5%90%8D%E9%86% AB%E7%9A%84%E6%B2%89%E7%97%9B%E8%87%AA%E7%99%BD%EF%BC%9A%E3%80%8C%E5%9C%A8% E5%8F%B0%E7%81%A3%E7%95%B6%E9%86%AB%E5%B8%AB%E8%B1%AC%E7%8B%97%E4%B8%8D%E5% A6%82%E3%80%8D-043109666.html
