Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directing ?

[NanoSpeed]

I have been watching Donnie Yen's films lately, compliments of YouTube.

I personally feel that Donnie is a more accomplished artist than Jacky Chan. I'm not sure if Jacky's kungfu is real, but Donnie I definitely think he can kill.

 

[Runifyouhaveto]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

I have been watching Donnie Yen's films lately, compliments of YouTube.

I personally feel that Donnie is a more accomplished artist than Jacky Chan. I'm not sure if Jacky's kungfu is real, but Donnie I definitely think he can kill.

Kungfu - Donnie
Personal Integrity - Donnie
Acting - Jacky is more commercialised, better catered to the masses
Directing -ungraded

 

[zeebjii]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

Kungfu - Donnie
Personal Integrity - Donnie
Acting - Jacky is more commercialised, better catered to the masses
Directing -ungraded

Donnie told the world he would not act past 50 years old. I knew he gonna break his promise, because he got his fame and fortune so late in life.

After 26 years of screen fighting, Donnie Yen, 46, is finally being recognized as the world’s number one Chinese action star, inheriting the mantle previously carried by Jet Li, Jackie Chan and Bruce Lee. Bolstered by award-winning, blockbuster hits IP MAN and PAINTED SKIN in 2008 and with upcoming films 14 BLADES, BODYGUARDS AND ASSASSINS and IP MAN 2 gaining momentum, the Boston native has become the hottest fighting star in Asia with offers pouring in from producers. Despite this enviable position, Yen admits that his time as an action star is running out in a new interview with the New York Times.

With age, it’s taking Yen longer to recuperate from shooting action scenes and although not mentioned in the NYT article, the action star has been troubled of late by injuries.

“I’ve actually given myself a retiring deadline for acting of 50,” said Yen. “I want to push myself to the limit, but I don’t want to be hanging around.”

 

[tanakow]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

In term of acting, Jackie is better but as a clown.

 

[halsey02]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

The late Brice Lee. still the best....

 

[Narong Wongwan]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

In term of acting, Jackie is better but as a clown.

Teeko Jackie can't act to save his life.
Despite his fame all his dramatic movies bombed at the box office.
Contrary to popular belief Jackie also hardly knows martial arts he is trained in Beijing opera and routines machiam like a circus act.
Donnie is an accomplished pugilist trained in various martial arts and taken part and won numerous competitions.
Jackie is also uglier, only jumps around doing slapstick and acting like the clown that he is. Uncouth chinaman compared to ABC Donnie

 

[yinyang]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

The late Brice Lee. still the best....

Kungfu - Donnie Personal Integrity - Donnie Acting - Jacky is more commercialised, better catered to the masses

Undoubtedly, Donnie's kungfu's way better than Jacky's. But can't say much of former's acting, so typecast and stone faced:p
True, Jacky's more into slapstick. What has personal integrity got to do with celluloid?

Bruce was a legend in diff era, with art depicting his wing chun moves. Pity he died on his mistress bed (what a way to go) :p

 

[UltimaOnline]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

Kung Fu Jungle and Special ID are Donnie Yen's two most recent movies. Wang BaoQiang and Andy On are both excellent actors with genuine martial art skills (nowhere as experienced as Donnie Yen, but on the flipside they've the advantage of youth), but due to the difference in emphasis of the choreography styles, ie. traditional Chinese martial arts for Kung Fu Jungle, versus MMA (particularly BJJ) for Special ID, anyone who understands genuine martial arts will appreciate that Donnie Yen's Special ID final fight scene is incomparably superior to Donnie Yen's Kung Fu Jungle final fight scene. Special ID fight scenes are mostly realistic, practical and applicable to real-life, while Kung Fu Jungle's fight scenes are mostly unrealistic, impractical and belongs within a movie.

Kung Fu Jungle final fight :
[video=youtube;Dig6htIJL1Q]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dig6htIJL1Q[/video]

Special ID final fight :
[video=youtube;XclQ1tz3MWM]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XclQ1tz3MWM[/video]

 

[Reddog]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

Jack Neo of CHC fame is better.

 

[enterprise2]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

Like the fight between Donnie and Jet Li in Wong Fei Hong. Too bad one got to lose!

 

[halsey02]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

Undoubtedly, Donnie's kungfu's way better than Jacky's. But can't say much of former's acting, so typecast and stone faced:p
True, Jacky's more into slapstick. What has personal integrity got to do with celluloid?

Bruce was a legend in diff era, with art depicting his wing chun moves. Pity he died on his mistress bed (what a way to go) :p

I have watched Donnie's Wing Chun ( the 1st one) many times on Blu-Ray, the moves were slick & well choreographed, but it is still a galaxy difference with Bruce Lee....never mind the slapstick Kung Fu of Jackie Chan.

You heard of Alexander Fu Sheng? he was to be acting in that movie that Jacky Chan, got a break to be a star, he would have been in Jacky Cahn Shoes had he, not died in a car accident.

Betty Tin Pei - recently gave her account of how Bruce Lee died...that is how many years from July 20, 1073 ( I remember this date by heart)...something like, the "day the music died"...

 

[yinyang]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

You heard of Alexander Fu Sheng? he was to be acting in that movie that Jacky Chan, got a break to be a star, he would have been in Jacky Cahn Shoes had he, not died in a car accident.
Betty Tin Pei - recently gave her account of how Bruce Lee died...that is how many years from July 20, 1073 ( I remember this date by heart)...something like, the "day the music died"...

Alexander Fu Sheng's wife (milf now, still doing her vocals) I more than heard :p

On Bruce, jury's still out on his purported ailment

 

[Ambulance]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

halo lau tiko gung balu zhe hee sio pa si jin eh

[video=youtube;jzkSuly_IcE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jzkSuly_IcE[/video]

 

[KuanTi01]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

Jack Neo of CHC fame is better.

Oh no! Not another lau teeko! This guy was into slapstick. Like Jackie lauteeko, he also cannot act to save his life except wayang in CHC and PAP.

 

[NanoSpeed]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

How did one die while having sex ?

Is it because the girl is too hot ? Or ejaculation time out ?

 

[GOD IS MY DOG]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

I have been watching Donnie Yen's films lately, compliments of YouTube.

I personally feel that Donnie is a more accomplished artist than Jacky Chan. I'm not sure if Jacky's kungfu is real, but Donnie I definitely think he can kill.

comparing Jackie Chan to Donnie Yen is like comparing a Mooncake to the Moon............Jackie is a glorified clown, that's all............

 

[halsey02]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

Alexander Fu Sheng's wife (milf now, still doing her vocals) I more than heard :p

On Bruce, jury's still out on his purported ailment

There is so many conspiracy theory, the triad killed him, he smoked Himalayan Weeds etc....we think, the BUTLER did it!

 

[halsey02]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

How did one die while having sex ?

Is it because the girl is too hot ? Or ejaculation time out ?

Very rare people did having it, is usually after they have finished....it is the sudden spike & the cooling down the culprit....my doctor tells me, many people die between 2am - 4am...for the older you get, when you get roused from you sleep...your heart, has to start pumping after a rest...the older you are , the more, 'clogged pipes' one have...

 

[frenchbriefs]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

If u watch jackie's old movies before he went to the american market its definitely pretty impressive.

 

[NanoSpeed]

Re: Donnie Yen vs Jacky Chan ? Who is better in terms of kungfu, acting and directin

Very rare people did having it, is usually after they have finished....it is the sudden spike & the cooling down the culprit....my doctor tells me, many people die between 2am - 4am...for the older you get, when you get roused from you sleep...your heart, has to start pumping after a rest...the older you are , the more, 'clogged pipes' one have...

You understand what your doctor said ? Because I don't understand what you say. Like speaking in parables.