Chitchat Can we pin point who is right or wrong?

[Dark Knight]

Company A is an engineering firm.
Assuming that all the staffs working there are technically inclined.

Professional engineer B came out with his product design and proposal for a particular project which involves 2 vendor.
He has done all the calculation and compile all the required data.
But in the proposal, he mixed up the 2 vendor's name which ended up documenting those info which is not related to them.

The Product Manager (approving change management) has read through the proposal and approved the design.
He then passed it down to the product engineer to execute the project.

The product engineer ended up feeding the wrong info to the 2 vendor.

In this scenario, can we really pin point exactly the following:
1) Who is wrong?
2) Who is right?

 

[laksaboy]

Everyone got exactly what he deserved according to his karma.

There will be no end to the matter if you keep splitting hairs about who is right or wrong.

 

[rushifa666]

All are wrong all should be sacked

 

[tanwahtiu]

They ended up doing evil things to prosper and enrich themselves.

BE is good example... used their engineering gunboats to do evil things.... gun barrels rules the world...so they said...

Company A is an engineering firm.
Assuming that all the staffs working there are technically inclined.

Professional engineer B came out with his product design and proposal for a particular project which involves 2 vendor.
He has done all the calculation and compile all the required data.
But in the proposal, he mixed up the 2 vendor's name which ended up documenting those info which is not related to them.

The Product Manager (approving change management) has read through the proposal and approved the design.
He then passed it down to the product engineer to execute the project.

The product engineer ended up feeding the wrong info to the 2 vendor.

In this scenario, can we really pin point exactly the following:
1) Who is wrong?
2) Who is right?

 

[Dark Knight]

Everyone got exactly what he deserved according to his karma.

There will be no end to the matter if you keep splitting hairs about who is right or wrong.

Professional engineer B will claimed that both Product Manager and Product Engineer is in the wrong as why they didn't verify the info before approving and executing it.
Product Manager will push the blame to the Product Engineer as why he execute it before checking the facts and figures are correct.
Product Engineer got all the blame and claimed why the Product Manager approved it blindly and the Professional Engineer has given the wrong info in the first place.

If you are the General Manager, what will you do?