https://mil.news.sina.com.cn/jssd/2019-03-30/doc-ihsxncvh6775162.shtml
印度用以色列导弹瞄准枭龙战机 却击落己方直升机
印度用以色列导弹瞄准枭龙战机 却击落己方直升机
610
2月27日早上的印巴空中冲突已经过去了一个多月了。在这场空中对抗中，印度空军不但被击落了一架米格-21比斯战斗机，还有一架米-17V5直升机在混乱中坠毁，造成7人死亡。印度方面一开始称是被巴基斯坦战机导弹击落，后来又称是机械故障坠毁。
最近据消息人士透露，这架直升机很可能是在混乱中被印度自己的陆基防空导弹击落，而一些证据指向了印度向以色列购买的MR-SAM型中近程防空导弹系统。
图片：印度米-17V5直升机坠毁。
印度《经济时报》（ET）报道称，极有可能这架米-17V5直升机是被印度自己的防空导弹击落的。该报在印度空军高层的“消息源”称，他们在调查以色列导弹可能出现的技术故障，并调查是否有人员应该对此负责，并可能会就这一致命事故诉诸军事法庭。
我们来再梳理一下一个月之前的场景，会发现这架直升机进入战场并坠毁的时机太“偶然”了。根据目前公开的报道，印度米格-21比斯战斗机是在27日上午10时5分在巴控克什米尔一带被击落的。而这架米格-21比斯战斗机是为了追击巴基斯坦空军“枭龙”战斗机而进入巴控区的。为了报复前一天印度空军侵犯巴控克什米尔，巴基斯坦空军战机在当天早上也飞入印控区进行打击，而米格-21比斯战斗机随即升空作战，最终被击落。
图片：从执行搜救任务来看，坠毁的应该是一架印度空军的直升机。
我们再看这架直升机坠毁的时间，直升机是10时10分坠毁的，离印度战斗机被击落的时间仅差5分钟，而且也在上述交战区域的印控区内。根据印度《经济时报》的报道，印度防空导弹部队这个时候是发射了从以色列购买的防空导弹。
战争时期是非常混乱的，有可能印度战斗机被击落后，印度防空部队第一时间就从预警雷达上知晓了，神经更加紧张，怕巴基斯坦战机再次入境袭击。防空导弹此时也肯定已经通电状态随时可以发射。
图片：阅兵中出现的以色列产MR-SAM中程防空导弹系统，采用垂直发射。
就在这个时候，那架倒霉的米-17V5直升机飞入了战区。印度称这架直升机是执行搜救任务的，显然直升机也知道自己的战斗机被击落了。但是他并不知道下面的防空导弹部队已经将导弹对准了空中，只是让人不解的是，既然已经知道两国开打了，为什么直升机上面的敌我识别装置没有开呢？或者真的像媒体说的是导弹故障没有理睬敌我识别信号？
显然，防空导弹部队对于雷达上突然出现的这架低空目标，第一反应可能认为这是巴基斯坦的无人机来进行袭击后损害评估的。加上直升机的敌我识别器可能并没有开，亦或者是航空兵和防空导弹部队之间的信息不对称，让防空导弹部队认为这是巴基斯坦目标，随后发射了导弹。这枚本来要打击再次入侵的巴基斯坦“枭龙”战斗机的以色列导弹拔地而起，射向毫不知晓的米-17V5直升机，瞬间就将其击落了！
图片：印度媒体认为，击落直升机的正是这种垂直发射的防空导弹。
不过，根据印度《经济时报》“消息人士”的说法，这枚导弹是严重偏离了目标。则可能当时空中确实还有巴基斯坦的战机或者是无人机，在混乱的战区中，这枚导弹盯上了自己的直升机。不过可以确定的是，这架价值1700万美元的直升机没有出现任何技术故障，是印度新近引进的飞机，设备也比较新。
印度《经济时报》所称的以色列防空导弹是印度新买的MR-SAM导弹。印度最近从以色列航空航天工业公司进口了价值20亿美元MR-SAM（中程防空导弹）系统和LR-SAM（远程防空导弹）系统。其中，印度陆军获得的是陆基MR-SAM导弹，印度海军获得的是海基MR-SAM和LR-SAM导弹。
图片：印度还有一种射程30公里的QR-SAM导弹，由于还处于研制阶段，应该不会部署到克什米尔。
该导弹是著名的以色列“巴拉克”-8导弹的陆基版本，使用同型导弹，最大速度2马赫，最大射程70千米，采用垂直发射。MR-SAM系统使用有源相控阵雷达，具备360度全向覆盖的探测能力，导弹使用主动雷达制导和双向数据链，加上垂直发射系统的使用，具有很强的多目标交战能力。这种防空导弹对付一架毫不知晓的直升机可以说是非常轻松的事情。
当然，目前印度空军并不承认误击事件，不过我们也可以看出，印度媒体从最开始的一片褒奖声开始转向质疑印度空军防空作战能力了！或许这一事件最终会被掩盖在厚厚的政治利益交换帷幕之后，但是让我们对一个月前爆发的空战又有了新的认识！（作者：虹摄库尔斯克）
图片：被俘虏的印度飞行员成为了民族英雄，而这架直升机上的7名印度机组人员却没有人知道他们叫什么。
India uses Israeli missiles to target the dragon fighters but shoots down its own helicopters.
India uses Israeli missiles to target the dragon fighters but shoots down its own helicopters.
610
It has been more than a month since the air conflict in India and Pakistan on the morning of February 27. In this air confrontation, the Indian Air Force was not only shot down by a MiG-21 Biss fighter, but also a Mi-17V5 helicopter crashed in chaos, killing seven people. The Indian side initially claimed to have been shot down by Pakistani fighter missiles and later called a mechanical failure.
According to recent sources, the helicopter is likely to be shot down by India’s own land-based air defense missiles in chaos, and some evidence points to the MR-SAM medium-range short-range air defense missile system that India purchased from Israel.
Photo: The Indian Mi-17V5 helicopter crashed.
India’s Economic Times (ET) reported that it is highly probable that the Mi-17V5 helicopter was shot down by India’s own air defense missile. The newspaper’s “source” at the top of the Indian Air Force stated that they were investigating possible technical failures of Israeli missiles and investigating whether any personnel should be held accountable and might resort to military courts for this fatal accident.
Let's take a look at the scene a month ago and find that the timing of the helicopter entering the battlefield and crashing is too "accidental." According to the current public report, the Indian MiG-21 Biss fighter was shot down in the Pakistani-controlled Kashmir area at 10:5 am on the 27th. The MiG-21 Biss fighter entered the Pakistani control zone in pursuit of the Pakistani Air Force "Dragon" fighter. In retaliation for the day before the Indian Air Force invaded Pakistani-controlled Kashmir, the Pakistani Air Force fighters also flew into the Indian-controlled area in the morning to attack, and the MiG-21 Biss fighter immediately took off and was eventually shot down.
Photo: From the execution of the search and rescue mission, the crash should be an Indian Air Force helicopter.
Let us look at the time when the helicopter crashed. The helicopter crashed at 10:10, and the Indian fighter was only 5 minutes behind it, and it was also in the control zone of the above-mentioned war zone. According to the Indian Economic Times, the Indian air defense missile unit launched an anti-aircraft missile purchased from Israel.
The war period was very chaotic. It is possible that the Indian fighter planes were left behind. The Indian air defense units were known from the early warning radars at the first time. The nerves were even more tense and they were afraid of Pakistani warplanes entering the attack again. The air defense missile must also be ready to launch at any time.
Photo: The Israeli-made MR-SAM medium-range air defense missile system that appeared in the military parade used vertical launch.
It was at this time that the unlucky Mi-17V5 helicopter flew into the theater. India called the helicopter a search and rescue mission. Obviously the helicopter also knew that its fighter was shot down. However, he did not know that the following air defense missile units had already pointed the missiles into the air. What is puzzling is that since the two countries have already started to fight, why is the enemy-identification device on the helicopter not open? Or is it really like the media said that the missile failure has ignored the identification signal of the enemy?
Obviously, the first reaction of the air defense missile unit to the sudden appearance of the low-altitude target on the radar may be that this is a Pakistani drone to carry out the damage assessment after the attack. In addition, the helicopter's enemy and the enemy identifier may not be opened, or the information asymmetry between the aviation and air defense missile units, so that the air defense missile unit considered this to be a Pakistani target, and then launched a missile. The Israeli missile, which had been hitting the re-invading Pakistani "Dragon" fighter, rose to the ground and shot at the unknown Mi-17V5 helicopter, and immediately shot it down!
Photo: The Indian media believes that it is this vertically launched anti-aircraft missile that shoots down the helicopter.
However, according to the "news" of the Indian Economic Times, the missile is seriously deviating from the target. It may be that there were indeed Pakistani fighters or drones in the air. In the chaotic theater, the missile was eyeing its own helicopter. However, it is certain that this $17 million helicopter has no technical problems. It is a newly introduced aircraft in India and its equipment is relatively new.
The Israeli Air Defense Missile, known as the Economic Times, is a newly purchased MR-SAM missile from India. India recently imported a $2 billion MR-SAM (medium-range air defense missile) system and an LR-SAM (long-range air defense missile) system from Israel Aerospace Industries. Among them, the Indian Army obtained the land-based MR-SAM missile, and the Indian Navy obtained the sea-based MR-SAM and LR-SAM missiles.
Photo: India also has a QR-SAM missile with a range of 30 kilometers. It should not be deployed to Kashmir because it is still in the development stage.
The missile is a land-based version of the famous Israeli "Balak"-8 missile, using the same type of missile, with a maximum speed of Mach 2 and a maximum range of 70 kilometers, with vertical launch. The MR-SAM system uses active phased array radar with 360-degree omnidirectional coverage. The missile uses active radar guidance and a two-way data link, plus the use of a vertical launch system, which has a strong multi-target engagement capability. This kind of air defense missile can be said to be very easy to deal with a helicopter that is unknown.
Of course, the Indian Air Force does not recognize the accidental attack, but we can also see that the Indian media has turned from the initial slogan to question the Indian Air Force's air defense capabilities! Perhaps this event will eventually be concealed behind the thick exchange of political interests, but let us have a new understanding of the air battle that broke out a month ago! (Author: Rainbow photo Kursk)
Photo: The captured Indian pilot became a national hero, and none of the seven Indian crew members on the helicopter knew what they were calling.
印度用以色列导弹瞄准枭龙战机 却击落己方直升机
印度用以色列导弹瞄准枭龙战机 却击落己方直升机
610
2月27日早上的印巴空中冲突已经过去了一个多月了。在这场空中对抗中，印度空军不但被击落了一架米格-21比斯战斗机，还有一架米-17V5直升机在混乱中坠毁，造成7人死亡。印度方面一开始称是被巴基斯坦战机导弹击落，后来又称是机械故障坠毁。
最近据消息人士透露，这架直升机很可能是在混乱中被印度自己的陆基防空导弹击落，而一些证据指向了印度向以色列购买的MR-SAM型中近程防空导弹系统。
图片：印度米-17V5直升机坠毁。
印度《经济时报》（ET）报道称，极有可能这架米-17V5直升机是被印度自己的防空导弹击落的。该报在印度空军高层的“消息源”称，他们在调查以色列导弹可能出现的技术故障，并调查是否有人员应该对此负责，并可能会就这一致命事故诉诸军事法庭。
我们来再梳理一下一个月之前的场景，会发现这架直升机进入战场并坠毁的时机太“偶然”了。根据目前公开的报道，印度米格-21比斯战斗机是在27日上午10时5分在巴控克什米尔一带被击落的。而这架米格-21比斯战斗机是为了追击巴基斯坦空军“枭龙”战斗机而进入巴控区的。为了报复前一天印度空军侵犯巴控克什米尔，巴基斯坦空军战机在当天早上也飞入印控区进行打击，而米格-21比斯战斗机随即升空作战，最终被击落。
图片：从执行搜救任务来看，坠毁的应该是一架印度空军的直升机。
我们再看这架直升机坠毁的时间，直升机是10时10分坠毁的，离印度战斗机被击落的时间仅差5分钟，而且也在上述交战区域的印控区内。根据印度《经济时报》的报道，印度防空导弹部队这个时候是发射了从以色列购买的防空导弹。
战争时期是非常混乱的，有可能印度战斗机被击落后，印度防空部队第一时间就从预警雷达上知晓了，神经更加紧张，怕巴基斯坦战机再次入境袭击。防空导弹此时也肯定已经通电状态随时可以发射。
图片：阅兵中出现的以色列产MR-SAM中程防空导弹系统，采用垂直发射。
就在这个时候，那架倒霉的米-17V5直升机飞入了战区。印度称这架直升机是执行搜救任务的，显然直升机也知道自己的战斗机被击落了。但是他并不知道下面的防空导弹部队已经将导弹对准了空中，只是让人不解的是，既然已经知道两国开打了，为什么直升机上面的敌我识别装置没有开呢？或者真的像媒体说的是导弹故障没有理睬敌我识别信号？
显然，防空导弹部队对于雷达上突然出现的这架低空目标，第一反应可能认为这是巴基斯坦的无人机来进行袭击后损害评估的。加上直升机的敌我识别器可能并没有开，亦或者是航空兵和防空导弹部队之间的信息不对称，让防空导弹部队认为这是巴基斯坦目标，随后发射了导弹。这枚本来要打击再次入侵的巴基斯坦“枭龙”战斗机的以色列导弹拔地而起，射向毫不知晓的米-17V5直升机，瞬间就将其击落了！
图片：印度媒体认为，击落直升机的正是这种垂直发射的防空导弹。
不过，根据印度《经济时报》“消息人士”的说法，这枚导弹是严重偏离了目标。则可能当时空中确实还有巴基斯坦的战机或者是无人机，在混乱的战区中，这枚导弹盯上了自己的直升机。不过可以确定的是，这架价值1700万美元的直升机没有出现任何技术故障，是印度新近引进的飞机，设备也比较新。
印度《经济时报》所称的以色列防空导弹是印度新买的MR-SAM导弹。印度最近从以色列航空航天工业公司进口了价值20亿美元MR-SAM（中程防空导弹）系统和LR-SAM（远程防空导弹）系统。其中，印度陆军获得的是陆基MR-SAM导弹，印度海军获得的是海基MR-SAM和LR-SAM导弹。
图片：印度还有一种射程30公里的QR-SAM导弹，由于还处于研制阶段，应该不会部署到克什米尔。
该导弹是著名的以色列“巴拉克”-8导弹的陆基版本，使用同型导弹，最大速度2马赫，最大射程70千米，采用垂直发射。MR-SAM系统使用有源相控阵雷达，具备360度全向覆盖的探测能力，导弹使用主动雷达制导和双向数据链，加上垂直发射系统的使用，具有很强的多目标交战能力。这种防空导弹对付一架毫不知晓的直升机可以说是非常轻松的事情。
当然，目前印度空军并不承认误击事件，不过我们也可以看出，印度媒体从最开始的一片褒奖声开始转向质疑印度空军防空作战能力了！或许这一事件最终会被掩盖在厚厚的政治利益交换帷幕之后，但是让我们对一个月前爆发的空战又有了新的认识！（作者：虹摄库尔斯克）
图片：被俘虏的印度飞行员成为了民族英雄，而这架直升机上的7名印度机组人员却没有人知道他们叫什么。
India uses Israeli missiles to target the dragon fighters but shoots down its own helicopters.
India uses Israeli missiles to target the dragon fighters but shoots down its own helicopters.
610
It has been more than a month since the air conflict in India and Pakistan on the morning of February 27. In this air confrontation, the Indian Air Force was not only shot down by a MiG-21 Biss fighter, but also a Mi-17V5 helicopter crashed in chaos, killing seven people. The Indian side initially claimed to have been shot down by Pakistani fighter missiles and later called a mechanical failure.
According to recent sources, the helicopter is likely to be shot down by India’s own land-based air defense missiles in chaos, and some evidence points to the MR-SAM medium-range short-range air defense missile system that India purchased from Israel.
Photo: The Indian Mi-17V5 helicopter crashed.
India’s Economic Times (ET) reported that it is highly probable that the Mi-17V5 helicopter was shot down by India’s own air defense missile. The newspaper’s “source” at the top of the Indian Air Force stated that they were investigating possible technical failures of Israeli missiles and investigating whether any personnel should be held accountable and might resort to military courts for this fatal accident.
Let's take a look at the scene a month ago and find that the timing of the helicopter entering the battlefield and crashing is too "accidental." According to the current public report, the Indian MiG-21 Biss fighter was shot down in the Pakistani-controlled Kashmir area at 10:5 am on the 27th. The MiG-21 Biss fighter entered the Pakistani control zone in pursuit of the Pakistani Air Force "Dragon" fighter. In retaliation for the day before the Indian Air Force invaded Pakistani-controlled Kashmir, the Pakistani Air Force fighters also flew into the Indian-controlled area in the morning to attack, and the MiG-21 Biss fighter immediately took off and was eventually shot down.
Photo: From the execution of the search and rescue mission, the crash should be an Indian Air Force helicopter.
Let us look at the time when the helicopter crashed. The helicopter crashed at 10:10, and the Indian fighter was only 5 minutes behind it, and it was also in the control zone of the above-mentioned war zone. According to the Indian Economic Times, the Indian air defense missile unit launched an anti-aircraft missile purchased from Israel.
The war period was very chaotic. It is possible that the Indian fighter planes were left behind. The Indian air defense units were known from the early warning radars at the first time. The nerves were even more tense and they were afraid of Pakistani warplanes entering the attack again. The air defense missile must also be ready to launch at any time.
Photo: The Israeli-made MR-SAM medium-range air defense missile system that appeared in the military parade used vertical launch.
It was at this time that the unlucky Mi-17V5 helicopter flew into the theater. India called the helicopter a search and rescue mission. Obviously the helicopter also knew that its fighter was shot down. However, he did not know that the following air defense missile units had already pointed the missiles into the air. What is puzzling is that since the two countries have already started to fight, why is the enemy-identification device on the helicopter not open? Or is it really like the media said that the missile failure has ignored the identification signal of the enemy?
Obviously, the first reaction of the air defense missile unit to the sudden appearance of the low-altitude target on the radar may be that this is a Pakistani drone to carry out the damage assessment after the attack. In addition, the helicopter's enemy and the enemy identifier may not be opened, or the information asymmetry between the aviation and air defense missile units, so that the air defense missile unit considered this to be a Pakistani target, and then launched a missile. The Israeli missile, which had been hitting the re-invading Pakistani "Dragon" fighter, rose to the ground and shot at the unknown Mi-17V5 helicopter, and immediately shot it down!
Photo: The Indian media believes that it is this vertically launched anti-aircraft missile that shoots down the helicopter.
However, according to the "news" of the Indian Economic Times, the missile is seriously deviating from the target. It may be that there were indeed Pakistani fighters or drones in the air. In the chaotic theater, the missile was eyeing its own helicopter. However, it is certain that this $17 million helicopter has no technical problems. It is a newly introduced aircraft in India and its equipment is relatively new.
The Israeli Air Defense Missile, known as the Economic Times, is a newly purchased MR-SAM missile from India. India recently imported a $2 billion MR-SAM (medium-range air defense missile) system and an LR-SAM (long-range air defense missile) system from Israel Aerospace Industries. Among them, the Indian Army obtained the land-based MR-SAM missile, and the Indian Navy obtained the sea-based MR-SAM and LR-SAM missiles.
Photo: India also has a QR-SAM missile with a range of 30 kilometers. It should not be deployed to Kashmir because it is still in the development stage.
The missile is a land-based version of the famous Israeli "Balak"-8 missile, using the same type of missile, with a maximum speed of Mach 2 and a maximum range of 70 kilometers, with vertical launch. The MR-SAM system uses active phased array radar with 360-degree omnidirectional coverage. The missile uses active radar guidance and a two-way data link, plus the use of a vertical launch system, which has a strong multi-target engagement capability. This kind of air defense missile can be said to be very easy to deal with a helicopter that is unknown.
Of course, the Indian Air Force does not recognize the accidental attack, but we can also see that the Indian media has turned from the initial slogan to question the Indian Air Force's air defense capabilities! Perhaps this event will eventually be concealed behind the thick exchange of political interests, but let us have a new understanding of the air battle that broke out a month ago! (Author: Rainbow photo Kursk)
Photo: The captured Indian pilot became a national hero, and none of the seven Indian crew members on the helicopter knew what they were calling.
