GMS clarifies Nicole Seah's Donation Call - Thanks

scroobal

Alfrescian
Loyal
Joined
Jul 16, 2008
Messages
25,134
Points
83
Dear All,

Thank you for all the concerns raised here. I apologize for the great confusion and anxiety caused by this episode.

Under the Political Donation Act, it is LEGAL for candidates to solicit donations under their names. Thus what Nicole has done is legal. The main concern is why personal bank account has been used instead of Party bank account. First of all, Nicole is soliciting funds for her candidacy in Marine Parade. She is also trying to get funding for her whole Marine Parade Team. Thus, it would be technically tedious for us to differentiate between funding meant for Marine Parade Team if donations are made to the Party bank account. Besides, financial reporting for the Party will be very complex if every Teams or individual candidates utilize the Party bank account for their fund raising activities.

I believe that those who have donated to Nicole or any other opposition members would have full confidence and trust in them to utilize the funds solely for the GE only. Having said that, I also understand the demand for transparency from the public on the fund raised. Rest be assured that due diligence will be carried out by the whole Marine Parade Team since the fund raised is intended to defray the cost of its election campaign.

As I have mentioned before to the press, young people are using the New Media more often and it will become a trend for them to utilize New Media for their political work and engagement which will include soliciting political donations. It is unfortunate that this present issue was blown out of proportion due to the utilization of the New Media. On hindsight, it could have been managed better.

Nevertheless, I have full confidence in Nicole and her Marine Parade Team in managing public funding properly. The stakeholders who have contributed money to their funds have the right to know how the funds have been utilized. This is a matter of transparency. This can be done by sending them the details via emails.

However, I think it is totally inappropriate for the members of public to insinuate corrupt practices, intent or misconduct with regards to this issue. It would be unfair to Nicole and her team to suggest that because they have acted within the legal limits. Unless there is any proof of misappropriation of funds, I think such slander is totally unwarranted. I hope the members of public should refrain from making such insinuations.

I think that this issue would be a good public education process for both politicians as well as Singaporeans. Singaporeans may not be used to politicians soliciting funds under their names but this is perfectly legal for candidates to do so, just as any other democratic countries in the world (US, Europe countries etc). On the other hand, politicians have to be mindful about perceptions of the public as well as the transparency of the whole fund raising exercise.

To conclude, I hope that Singaporeans could bear with us while we move on to a more open society. It is perfectly healthy for Singaporeans to raise their concerns on transparency and accountability when such public donations are involved. But I hope that my explanations and clarifications here could address their concerns adequately.

Yours Sincerely ,

Goh Meng Seng
 
One of the things Nicole should do to win the trust of the donors is to:

- Published and constantly update how much money has been received
- What amount of money has been allocated to the Marine Parade campaign
- What amount of money is left over and how is it spent

By doing this, Nicole Seah is being accountable to funds that has been entrusted to her, being accountable is something she preaches a great deal in her talk of the PAP.

If Nicole Seah has nothing to hide, I think she would be most willing to account for the donations received.
 
--------------------------------
 
Last edited:
This official answer is just fine and needed, however it did come a little late.

No matter what is said here, damages have been done to NSP on this issue, and fine too that GMS acknowledges that this could have been handled more professionally - that is, stating the reasons of using personal account BEFORE (and not AFTER) soliciting for funds.
Even the real intention has been what it is claimed, it raises doubt at the least, and protray a rather disorganised leadership.

Nicole has a fair share of blame for this episode, and besides GMS making an official statement, she should acknowledge her oversight as well.
 
Ok... GMS finally exercised his leadership... thanks.

What Nicole needs to do is the same as what any other candidate needs to do. Publish the full details once the target is reached. There is no reason for her to do more. Those of you who cannot get over this, you may keep your 50 cents.
 
This official answer is just fine and needed, however it did come a little late.

No matter what is said here, damages have been done to NSP on this issue, and fine too that GMS acknowledges that this could have been handled more professionally - that is, stating the reasons of using personal account BEFORE (and not AFTER) soliciting for funds.
Even the real intention has been what it is claimed, it raises doubt at the least, and protray a rather disorganised leadership.

Nicole has a fair share of blame for this episode, and besides GMS making an official statement, she should acknowledge her oversight as well.

What is the share of blame you are talking about? It is already clarify the method of collecting donation is common and legal.
 
Bro, what is common and legal may not be politically correct. The fact that GMS comes out with an official statement says it all, doesn't it?
 
Bro, what is common and legal may not be politically correct. The fact that GMS comes out with an official statement says it all, doesn't it?

I am not sure if this is commonly practised by other candidates... if it is then someone with ill intent must have stirred shit to create negative publicity for Nicole Seah... if it is uncommon then NSP should just implement party guideline that all donations come through party account... this would have avoided the mess
 
exactly. If the ground sentiments have not been this strong, I can assure you the local press, tv and what-have-you would have a field day on this issue. Better men who did less have been maimed and kicked out of Singapore, the life of an opposition in Singapore is about steering of self-inflicted trouble first and foremost.
 
One of the things Nicole should do to win the trust of the donors is to:

- Published and constantly update how much money has been received
- What amount of money has been allocated to the Marine Parade campaign
- What amount of money is left over and how is it spent

By doing this, Nicole Seah is being accountable to funds that has been entrusted to her, being accountable is something she preaches a great deal in her talk of the PAP.

If Nicole Seah has nothing to hide, I think she would be most willing to account for the donations received.

Sporeans love making a mountain out of a mole hill. What iverbert syas is right; sporeans love to focus on kanchang puteh issues like student eating on mrt, or why this person dont give up seat, or why students kssing each other on void deck etc...Thats why PAP remain in power for so long.

Is a student walks up to you on saturday asking for flag donations, do you request a breakdown and proper accounting of the monies collected?

There was nothing fradulent. It was well known that the money went into her personal account. If you dont trust, then dont donate. If you want to donate, then you have to trust.
 
Suits me fine, if Nicole Seah and the opposition wants my 3 digit donation, she should start to account for her campaign finances and donations.

Nicole Seah can't be double standards, Nicole can't complain of the PAP not being open, Temasek not being transparent and yet Nicole herself is not or have no intention of being open and transparent.

If Nicole Seah wants the $15,000 prize in the next election, she should start to account for her campaign finances and donations now.
 
Back
Top