- Joined
- Nov 9, 2010
- Messages
- 80,748
- Points
- 113
Auto translate
泼水节aka Songkran also celebrated by Dai in China Yunnan besides Laos Thailand Cambodia Myanmar etc
View attachment 205182泼水节aka Songkran also celebrated by Dai in China Yunnan besides Laos Thailand Cambodia Myanmar etc
Some more celebrate at same time and in exactly the same way not called same people then called what right?泼水节aka Songkran also celebrated by Dai in China Yunnan besides Laos Thailand Cambodia Myanmar etc
Yes and no because not all have 70% MtDna mother ancestry so much Dai or other tribal genes like Cantonese. Hakka 56%. And they have much more because Guangdong is nearer to these tribal tribes and Cantonese have been there for over 2000 years with 南越 tribal people that evolved to these tribes while my previous thread already said study found hokkiens have much less or hardly any 闽越 genes due to mass migration of original 闽越people at north of Fujian to Jianghuai area aka juangsu Shanghai etc area and that’s why one quarter of shanghainese are found to have tribal genes too and so it’s not true that northerners are pure Chinese stock.Southern Chinese do carry some tribal blood in them which explain why southerners look a bit different from the northerners who are of pure Han Chinese stock. In Taiwan, you can spot the difference between a native (hokkien/hakka) and a mainlander just from the physical apprearence.
View attachment 205187View attachment 205188Yes and no because not all have 70% so much Dai or other tribal genes like Cantonese. Hakka 55%. And they have much more because Guangdong is nearer to these tribal tribes and Cantonese have been there for over 2000 years with 南越 tribal people that evolved to these tribes while my previous thread already said study found hokkiens have much less or hardly any 闽越 genes due to mass migration of original 闽越people at north of Fujian to Jianghuai area aka juangsu Shanghai etc area and that’s why one quarter of shanghainese are found to have tribal genes too and so it’s not true that northerners are pure Chinese stock.
Today I learned a new word sinicized. Someone said Cantonese are sinicized Tai kadai people. So no, tribal people don’t die off but sinicized to Cantonese and Hakka, the latter from She people to become Hakka people.what about die people? they die off?
Btw not I anyhow say but Taiwan study said one hor Hakka are She people and She people are hakka. They lived together in the same Guangdong area and have same culture of singing mountain songs, don’t bind feet etc and their Hakka and SHE languages are the same.Today I learned a new word sinicized. Someone said Cantonese are sinicized Tai kadai people. So no, tribal people don’t die off but sinicized to Cantonese and Hakka, the latter from She people to become Hakka people.
View attachment 205189
View attachment 205190View attachment 205191Btw not I anyhow say but Taiwan study said one hor Hakka are She people and She people are hakka. They lived together in the same Guangdong area and have same culture of singing mountain songs, don’t bind feet etc and their Hakka and SHE languages are the same.