Saudi prince reject hadiths. All muslims should rejoice.

[syed putra]

One less headache for muslims, less contradiction. Less infighting to see who is more religious, who is right or wrong.

 

[glockman]

Very good indeed. I've mentioned previously that Islam needs to update itself in order to stay relevant and bring its followers to the 21st century.

 

[laksaboy]

The hardcore ones will just call the prince a blasphemer, a heretic, an acolyte of dajjal etc.

Muslim on Muslim violence hasn't changed for centuries. And that includes verbal violence.

 

[Loofydralb]

One less headache for muslims, less contradiction. Less infighting to see who is more religious, who is right or wrong.

That is why in Islam we have the tradition of verifying everything before you pass it along or propagate any news, or it becomes fitnah.
Always take these sorts of commentaries with a large dose of salt because there are many false news propagated by Zionists and Shias in the middle east to make the Saudis look bad.
If you look closely, there is no utterance in continuity by MBS. Did he say those things as alleged?
The smart will question. The dumb will be led by lies.
And the kafirs like syed here will receive his just rewards in this life or the next; we don't know.
We leave it to Allah.

 

[glockman]

That is why in Islam we have the tradition of verifying everything before you pass it along or propagate any news, or it becomes fitnah.
Always take these sorts of commentaries with a large dose of salt because there are many false news propagated by Zionists and Shias in the middle east to make the Saudis look bad.
If you look closely, there is no utterance in continuity by MBS. Did he say those things as alleged?
The smart will question. The dumb will be led by lies.
And the kafirs like syed here will receive his just rewards in this life or the next; we don't know.
We leave it to Allah.

Saudi Arabia: MBS's comments on extremism and Islamic laws cause stir​

https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/...extremism-religion-hadith-interview-criticism

Can Mohammed bin Salman break the Saudi-Wahhabi pact?​

https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2018/1/7/can-mohammed-bin-salman-break-the-saudi-wahhabi-pact

 

[Loofydralb]

Saudi Arabia: MBS's comments on extremism and Islamic laws cause stir​

https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/...extremism-religion-hadith-interview-criticism

Can Mohammed bin Salman break the Saudi-Wahhabi pact?​

https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2018/1/7/can-mohammed-bin-salman-break-the-saudi-wahhabi-pact

Again. I repeat in case you missed my point.
Commentaries, editorials, journals can be biased and spin news into whatever it is not. Otherwise no one will want to read their analysis if it is not spiced up.
You have to actually listen to what MBS actually is saying. Did you see MBS saying anything?

 

[whoami]

Haha....fm DCCI aka Defend Christ Critique Islam. Syed....u betul kotek.

So many google scholars here.

 

[Leckmichamarsch]

PROOF THAT MOOSELIMS ARE ALL FOOLS N IDIOTS

 

[whoami]

PROOF THAT MOOSELIMS ARE ALL FOOLS N IDIOTS

When u die, the angel of Death will not come knocking your door. He will snatch ur soul from your body. Ouch! Then he will bring your soul along to be questioned in the grave before the final Judgement Day come. By then seeing is believing. U no need to ask any proof leow.

 

[glockman]

Again. I repeat in case you missed my point.
Commentaries, editorials, journals can be biased and spin news into whatever it is not. Otherwise no one will want to read their analysis if it is not spiced up.
You have to actually listen to what MBS actually is saying. Did you see MBS saying anything?

What?? OK, whatever you say. Already gave you the link to the news report on the interview and excerpts of the interview. Next thing you will say is the English translation in the video is wrong, inaccurate, biased?

A good and intelligent rebuttal would be to admit he gave the interview but he is wrong because <quote your source, quote Quran verse, etc etc>

 

[whoami]

What?? OK, whatever you say. Already gave you the link to the news report on the interview and excerpts of the interview. Next thing you will say is the English translation in the video is wrong, inaccurate, biased?

A good and intelligent rebuttal would be to admit he gave the interview but he is wrong because <quote your source, quote Quran verse, etc etc>

Ehh...on the contrary MBS endorsed wat our Prophet, pbuh, had said i.e. extremist need to be killed. MBS followed the hadith. Where did MBS said doing away with the hadiths?

 

[Loofydralb]

What?? OK, whatever you say. Already gave you the link to the news report on the interview and excerpts of the interview. Next thing you will say is the English translation in the video is wrong, inaccurate, biased?

A good and intelligent rebuttal would be to admit he gave the interview but he is wrong because <quote your source, quote Quran verse, etc etc>

That is why without the clip showing what MBS actually said, we are just running round in circles and being preyed by people with agenda
That is no way to discuss correctly. Produce that clip first.

 

[duluxe]

If what you said is real, muslims should be angry instead of happy. Reason you shld know better.

 

[Loofydralb]

I

If what you said is real, muslims should be angry instead of happy. Reason you shld know better.

I don't get you. What are you talking about?

 

[Devil Within]

It's so much easier to just brand Islam as a cult and ban it like Nazi.

 

[syed putra]

If what you said is real, muslims should be angry instead of happy. Reason you shld know better.

Any removal of irrelevant laws should be a occasion to be celebrated.

 

[syed putra]

It's so much easier to just brand Islam as a cult and ban it like Nazi.

Too late. It wasn't suppose to be a religion in the first place.

 

[glockman]

@whoami @Loofydralb. Found the interview, have not watched them yet though. Thought you'd be keen since it concerns your beloved religion. Personally, I'd rather watch porn

 

[Loofydralb]

If you listen carefully what he is saying, he is correct that his source for his administration is still the quran and hadiths. Nothing really has changed. What I think he wants to do is to get the scholars to look at those hadiths which he feels are not categorised correctly.
Like everything else, the devil's in the details. The scholars eventually are the ones to review it. And note these scholars have a tradition where they only fear giving the wrong advise and be on the wrong side on judgement day.
DCCI does itself a disservice when it generalises and does not potray properly but attempts to score brownie points. DCCI also lied about the changing of direction of prayer from Jerusalem to Mecca as if it was instructed in a hadith. That verse is actually Allah's commandment in the Quran.

So clearly DCCI is a lying organisation.

On the whole I agree with MBS position as I do not see any change in the Islamic rulings, just more investments and business.
In 20 years things will not change much. You have to give it to MBS as he is savvy enough to get the investment community excited. Saudis are top notch dealers. And you guys took the bait.