• IP addresses are NOT logged in this forum so there's no point asking. Please note that this forum is full of homophobes, racists, lunatics, schizophrenics & absolute nut jobs with a smattering of geniuses, Chinese chauvinists, Moderate Muslims and last but not least a couple of "know-it-alls" constantly sprouting their dubious wisdom. If you believe that content generated by unsavory characters might cause you offense PLEASE LEAVE NOW! Sammyboy Admin and Staff are not responsible for your hurt feelings should you choose to read any of the content here.

    The OTHER forum is HERE so please stop asking.

Chitchat Expert panel to review rules on cycling on the road

bobby

Alfrescian
Loyal
Expert panel to review rules on cycling on the road

Actor Tay Ping Hui took to social media to vent his frustration at a group of cyclists who rode recklessly into a main road without looking and cut in front of his car, even though he had the right of way and had warned them by flashing his lights.


An advisory panel will conduct a review of existing regulations governing bicycles on the roads to improve the safety of both cyclists and motorists.

The review, which will take in feedback from the public, will include considerations of whether cyclists should be licensed and take theory tests.

Senior Minister of State for Transport Chee Hong Tat said this yesterday after meeting with members of the Active Mobility Advisory Panel.

The panel was set up in 2015 to study and discuss regulations in Singapore related to walking, cycling and the use of active mobility devices. Mr Chee said the Government is aware of concerns from both motorists and cyclists about cycling on the roads, hence the review, which is expected to take several months.

The announcement follows a spate of calls recently, including from actor Tay Ping Hui, for measures to put the brakes on errant cyclists.

He posted a video on Facebook taken from the dashboard of his car on April 1 showing a group of cyclists turning into a main road.

Even though his car had the right of way, the cyclists appear not to slow down and cut in front of him.

Irate, he took to social media to vent his frustration. His post, which included a call for all bicycles to be registered, garnered over 1,500 comments.

In a Facebook post a day later, Temasek Holdings chief executive Ho Ching also called for all bicycles and personal mobility devices to be registered.

Mr Chee said that cycling remains an important part of Singapore's green plan for transportation.

But, while it is a good thing that more people are taking up cycling, this should be done in a safe manner, he added.

Mr Chee noted that countries that have many cyclists, such as the Netherlands, do not require bicycles to be registered or cyclists to be licensed.

"It is a proposal that the panel can look at... while we do (the review), it's important that we do so in a balanced and fair manner, because we don't want to inadvertently end up discouraging cycling," he added.

The Land Transport Authority had previously studied licensing bicycles, concluding in 2016 that it would not be practical to implement such a scheme.

Chairman of the Government Parliamentary Committee for Transport Saktiandi Supaat told The New Paper last week that requiring cyclists to be licensed may not be the best approach to deal with errant cyclists.

He said: "We need to tread carefully on the issue of licensing bicycles... It might also dissuade people from cycling as getting such a licence may be an onerous process.

"Education and awareness of safety, along with rules, are better ways to promote a uniquely Singaporean safety culture."

Mr Saktiandi suggested that extra surveillance at typically congested areas where cyclists utilise stretches of roads could be useful.

Transport economist Walter Theseira said that any review of cycling regulations must be done holistically.

He told TNP: "Licensing and testing but not making insurance compulsory, for example, will do little to solve the practical problem of bicycles injuring pedestrians and pedestrians having no compensation.

"If you don't have sufficient enforcement or provide more alternatives for cyclists to major roads, you will also have the same problems as you do now."

Prof Theseira added that licensing cyclists as part of a comprehensive review can help to enforce a regulatory framework to penalise offences. This would help improve errant behaviour over time but should be introduced in a calibrated way.

He said: "Instead of getting every cyclist to get a licence, we can consider requiring only those who wish to go on the roads to get one."

Ms Joyce Leong, 65, founder of Joyriders, the largest amateur cycling club here, said making the basic theory test compulsory for cyclists could be one positive outcome of the review.

She added that any review of rules involving cycling on the roads should target both cyclists and motorists equally.

"Safety is everyone's responsibility," said Ms Leong.

"Motorists do not have the sole right of use of our roads, and they should be reminded of the rules that they need to follow when driving near cyclists. We should all learn to share the roads and learn to be kind and respect one another."
 

kaninabuchaojibye

Alfrescian
Loyal
this is the result when u have more and more people on this tiny little island and everyone fighting for their space rights

it's a symptom of overpopulation
 

kaninabuchaojibye

Alfrescian
Loyal
end up govt make rules, regulate and make more money
you peasants pay for the rights to use
cost of living increases
everyone must be very happy

the root cause is packing this island with so many foreigners....foreigners creates demand but increases costs for the average sinkies, from housing to food
 

mojito

Alfrescian
Loyal
Cheapskate tour de France wannabes trying to free ride on our magnificent boulevards! Why don't they try cycle down Matland north south high way? :mad: :FU:
 

bobby

Alfrescian
Loyal
"Motorists do not have the sole right of use of our roads, and they should be reminded of the rules that they need to follow when driving near cyclists. We should all learn to share the roads and learn to be kind and respect one another."

The right to use roads is also subjected to enforcement & pricing....do cyclists get that ?
 

Byebye Penis

Alfrescian
Loyal
my take:

1. tour-de-france forums blaming food-delivery cyclists for giving cyclists a bad name; not following traffic rules, not good at traffic hand signals.
2. food-delivery cyclists blame tour-de-france cyclists for giving cyclists a bad name; for being arrogant and good at hand signals (middle-fingering).
2. Going forward, more biz for LTA, if LTA IPO, i buy
 

LordElrond

Alfrescian (InfP)
Generous Asset
Cheapskate tour de France wannabes trying to free ride on our magnificent boulevards! Why don't they try cycle down Matland north south high way? :mad: :FU:
They do, but it’s the coastal road. Mudlanders are much more welcoming. If they’re not happy they just mow you down. Sinkies will just fight online war.
 

LordElrond

Alfrescian (InfP)
Generous Asset
Finally someone come out to make a balanced statement. This is by far the most balanced view I’ve heard. Let’s settle it once and for all. I will accept the verdict.
 

LordElrond

Alfrescian (InfP)
Generous Asset
my take:

1. tour-de-france forums blaming food-delivery cyclists for giving cyclists a bad name; not following traffic rules, not good at traffic hand signals.
2. food-delivery cyclists blame tour-de-france cyclists for giving cyclists a bad name; for being arrogant and good at hand signals (middle-fingering).
2. Going forward, more biz for LTA, if LTA IPO, i buy
It’s very simple, forget about who gives who a bad name. It’s about enforcement. We have a huge civil service. Just deploy a few hundred TPs do islandwide operations and catch the errant cyclists / motorists/ grab delivery/ Tour de France wannabe. There are existing rules, just bloody enforce it. Do that a few times and see if there are still dumbfarks behaviour.
 

Byebye Penis

Alfrescian
Loyal
It’s very simple, forget about who gives who a bad name. It’s about enforcement. We have a huge civil service. Just deploy a few hundred TPs do islandwide operations and catch the errant cyclists / motorists/ grab delivery/ Tour de France wannabe. There are existing rules, just bloody enforce it. Do that a few times and see if there are still dumbfarks behaviour.

TP in Singapore don't touch the ultra rich. There are trusted TP officers appointed to filter tickets of these ultra-rich. The former police head of tanglin during little india riot was one of them.
 

LordElrond

Alfrescian (InfP)
Generous Asset
TP in Singapore don't touch the ultra rich. There are trusted TP officers appointed to filter tickets of these ultra-rich. The former police head of tanglin during little india riot was one of them.
What ultra rich?
 

Byebye Penis

Alfrescian
Loyal
What ultra rich?

You never wonder by some people drives supercars, noisy harvey division (not to UN rule specs), mx, ferrari, porsche, bmw, mercs, maserati speeding throughout their life, never get points deducted while you consistently get tickets every few year? There are trusted scholar TP officers assigned to filter them out. They get fast-tracked promotion throughout their careers.

Even police in police force also looks down on them.
 

LordElrond

Alfrescian (InfP)
Generous Asset
Yes but we’re talking about TDF wannabes cyclists. Many hold decent jobs but not ultra rich.
 

Byebye Penis

Alfrescian
Loyal
Yes but we’re talking about TDF wannabes cyclists. Many hold decent jobs but not ultra rich.

If you can hold the bicycle frame within a finger, the TDF bikes cost as much as triumph bike or BMW bike. When TP confronts them, they threaten to sue, this is why TP leaves them alone. In the police force, TP is well-known for 欺善怕恶, that's why other divisions don't respect them.
 

bobby

Alfrescian
Loyal
In a country where motorists are heavily paying for their cars, road usage, petrol tax etc...there will be impasse when you say things like "We should all learn to share the roads and learn to be kind and respect one another."
 

LordElrond

Alfrescian (InfP)
Generous Asset
Well these road bikes have 3 range. Entry level ranges from aluminium 1k+ Decathlon road bike to 3k thereabout. The majority on the road are in the range of 6k - 8k which is good enough for most riders. The top end is in the range of 15k - 20k but these are mostly ridden by race teams or retired uncles with cash to spare. The thing is many of them are white collar who are well versed with their rights. If they do something stupid I don’t see why TP cannot stop them.
 

LordElrond

Alfrescian (InfP)
Generous Asset
In a country where motorists are heavily paying for their cars, road usage, petrol tax etc...there will be impasse when you say things like "We should all learn to share the roads and learn to be kind and respect one another."
It has been argued to death and you won’t get anywhere with this. I pay 3k road tax a year, my car has more rights than those who pay 1k? By the way, no one forces you to buy a car and pay all the charges. It is your choice to pay, just us it is the cyclist choice to go green. You are paying tax not just for the use of the road, but also for the damage you do to the environment. Thus the punitive diesel tax.
 

Byebye Penis

Alfrescian
Loyal
i feel strongly for non-TDF cyclists. A friend's father got killed while cycling on his way to work recently. These are the lessor-educated, poorer folks without any safety gear.
 
Top