Dentist accused of mutilating patients gets 8 years in prison
Philippe Sotto and Catherine Gaschka, The Associated Press
First posted: Tuesday, April 26, 2016 08:52 AM EDT | Updated: Tuesday, April 26, 2016 01:12 PM EDT
Dutch dentist, Jacobus Van Nierop, is pictured in his dental office in Chateau-Chinon, France, in this photo dated May 16, 2009. Van Nierop dubbed the “horror dentist” by French media went on trial March 8, 2016, facing charges of intentional violence and fraud. (AP Photo/Christophe Masson)
NEVERS, France -- A French court has found a man dubbed the "horror dentist" guilty of assault and fraud and sentenced him to eight years in prison.
Dutch dentist Jacobus Van Nierop had fled to Canada in late 2013. He was arrested in New Brunswick in 2014 and then ordered extradited.
Van Nierop, 51, showed no signs of emotion when the court in the central town of Nevers returned its verdict.
The court barred him from practicing dentistry for life.
About 100 plaintiffs had filed complaints against Van Nierop, ranging from having multiple healthy teeth removed, drill bits left in their gums and teeth, abscesses, recurrent infections and misshapen mouths after he did work on patients.
Van Nierop, who French media dubbed the "horror dentist", was accused of causing "mutilations" or "permanent disabilities" to scores of patients from 2009 to 2012, of overcharging patients and billing them for imaginary procedures and of illegally practicing dentistry in France.
In their 130-page ruling, the judges convicted the Dutchman of 85 counts of assault, including 45 counts of mutilation, and of 61 counts of fraud against patients, their health insurance companies and the local social security agency. They fined him 10,500 euros ($12,000) and said they will decide the amount of damages due to 62 plaintiffs in June.
The court acquitted the defendant of six counts of assault and some counts of fraud. Van Nierop has 10 days to file an appeal. He has been detained in a French prison since January 2015.
Van Nierop came to Canada in December 2013 and remained beyond the time he was permitted. He entered the country despite being under conditions not to leave France.
A statement of facts in his Canadian extradition case said the RCMP went looking for Van Nierop after receiving a complaint and determining he was the subject of an Interpol notice.
He was located on Labour Day 2014 in an apartment in Nackawic, west of Fredericton.
He was later ordered extradited to the Netherlands and then deported to France.
Marie-Jo Lemoine, a victim of Van Nierop, celebrated the verdict of the French court.
"It's silly to say that but I say it: It feels good. He will have time to think about us. But, as for the rest, nothing has changed regarding what we'll be given in terms of compensation. It won't be enough to repair the harm he caused. "
In her closing speech last month, prosecutor Lucile Jaillon-Bru said that in Van Nierop "there was only greed, indifference to another, even some enjoyment in making others suffer" and that for the victims "the price of pain is enormous." The dentist's goal "was to always make more money," she said.
Delphine Morin-Meneghel, the lawyer for Van Nierop, acknowledged her client was responsible for some bad procedures but she insisted he committed no intentional or premeditated violence toward any of his patients.
One patient, Sylviane Boulesteix, 65, testified she was unexpectedly summoned to the Dutchman's dental office in May 2012. Without warning, the dentist pulled eight of her teeth out and immediately fixed dentures on her raw gums. For hours, the woman said she sat "gushing blood."
In the following days, she said Van Nierop refused to relieve her pain. A judicial expert described the dentist as a "cruel and perverse" man whose incompetence made Boulesteix lose several healthy teeth, go through a trauma and suffer irreversible damage to her mouth.
When the dentist opened his office in late 2008, he was first welcomed by residents in Chateau-Chinon, a small town located in a rural and remote part of France's Burgundy region known as a "medical desert" because of a lack of medical professionals.
Van Nierop provided false documents to practise dentistry in France and concealed that he was the subject of disciplinary proceedings in his own country.
While living in an imposing home with a swimming pool, driving expensive cars and visiting luxurious hotels, the Dutchman had debts of nearly one million euros, according to court documents. He may be insolvent, which worries the plaintiffs who had claimed more than three million euros overall in damages.
Psychiatric experts said Van Nierop shows a narcissistic pervert personality with an absence of all moral sense and that he doesn't feel any compassion.
During the trial, the lawyer for one patient told the dentist his client was just waiting for apologies.
Van Nierop replied: "I have no feelings anymore. So, if I was offering my apologies today, I would be lying."
-- With files from The Canadian Press
