• IP addresses are NOT logged in this forum so there's no point asking. Please note that this forum is full of homophobes, racists, lunatics, schizophrenics & absolute nut jobs with a smattering of geniuses, Chinese chauvinists, Moderate Muslims and last but not least a couple of "know-it-alls" constantly sprouting their dubious wisdom. If you believe that content generated by unsavory characters might cause you offense PLEASE LEAVE NOW! Sammyboy Admin and Staff are not responsible for your hurt feelings should you choose to read any of the content here.

    The OTHER forum is HERE so please stop asking.

Committee Of Inquiry to Look into MRT Disruptions - 17 Dec 2011

M

Mdm Tang

Guest
.

PM Lee: Full public inquiry into MRT breakdowns

By Elena Torrijos | Yahoo! Newsroom – 5 hours ago.



UPDATED

Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong says a full public inquiry will be held to help determine the root cause of the recent MRT train breakdowns, reported The Straits Times.

Its immediate task: to look into reasons for the breakdown and to see if the system can be improved or if the problem is more systemic.The committee will be chosen in the next few weeks.

Speaking after a briefing by the Land Transport Authority officials after another breakdown -- this time on Saturday morning -- PM Lee said SMRT had to begin restoring public confidence in its system.

"What is important is for us now to get to the bottom of the matter and get the system up and running safely again," he was quoted as saying by the paper.

On Saturday morning, Transport Minister Lui Tuck Yew also visited Newton MRT station to check on the breakdown and SMRT's bus bridging services. A day earlier, referring to the massive commuter chaos on Thursday, he made clear that SMRT had to "make this right".

A separate panel of experts is also being convened to do a "thorough check" of the rail network.

Meanwhile, train service on the North South East West Line (NSEWL) will start at 10am on Sunday, 18 December, instead of 5:30am to allow for a full inspection of tracks and trains on Saturday evening, the Land Transport Authority announced.

The move follows three train disruptions this week which have sparked public outrage. The latest two disruptions were on the North-South line while the earlier one was on the Circle Line.

In a press statement, LTA said that it has directed transport operator SMRT to conduct a full inspection of the tracks and trains after end of revenue service on Saturday night "to determine if any obvious impairment are visible arising from the two incidents resulting in train service disruptions on Thursday and Saturday."

LTA said initial investigations point to misalignment between the train track and "collector shoes" causing a fault in the power rail.

The government agency said it will mobilise its team of engineers to assist SMRT to conduct visual checks of collector shoes assembly for all trains to ensure they are intact.

Concurrently, another contingent of inspection teams will examine the third rail assembly on the NSEWL, it added.

"The teams will comb through the entire third rail assembly. This work will be conducted up to 10am the next morning. The delayed opening hour of 10am is necessary as it is estimated that the team will need at least eight hours to conduct this review," it explained.

Meanwhile, LTA said that to facilitate travel on Sunday morning before 10 am, free bus bridging services will be provided.

SMRT said passengers can take the MRT shuttle buses that will run from 5:30am to 10am on Sunday.



.


Committee of Inquiry to look into MRT disruptions: PM Lee

He said that evidence will be presented to see how the train system can be made more robust and safer. -AsiaOne

Sat, Dec 17, 2011
AsiaOne

Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong said Saturday that there will be a public inquiry to look into the recent disruptions of MRT services.

An online news source reported PM Lee as saying that evidence will be presented to see how the train system can be made more robust and safer.

RELATED STORIES
SMRT's North-South line partially resumed
Second train disruption in two days draws ire
Transport Minister disappointed with SMRT
A Committee of Inquiry similar to the one which looked into the Nicoll Highway collapse will be formed, he said.

PM Lee said the train service disruptions required an inquiry as they were not single or isolated incidents.

He pointed out that Saturday morning's breakdown meant that the problem had not been resolved and that authorities will have to sort it out.

Hopefully, there will be a clearer position to ensure that future services will run without problems, he said.

Getting down to the specifics, PM Lee said SMRT needed to understand why the third rail and collector shoes were bumping against one another to cause malfunctions.

He also expressed hopes that the public and commuters would understand the difficulties involved in resolving the problem.



.
 

GoldenDragon

Alfrescian (Inf)
Asset
COI will be a waste of time just like the one convened for the escape of MSK. Objectivity is not the cardinal priority. Cover-up is. Should appoint an opposition MP to ensure no cover-up.
 

Confuseous

Alfrescian (Inf)
Asset
Which means that the Salary Review outcome will be delayed again. How to justify a pay cut, no matter how small, when things keep getting fcuked up?
 

zeddy

Alfrescian (Inf)
Asset
First it was the Ministerial Salary Review Committee... Now its the Committee Of Inquiry to look into these all these MRT cocked ups... So many committees ...:confused: Next they would set up a Committee of Inquiry on how to deal with those stray dogs that had bitten the poor girl in Punggol few days ago..:rolleyes:
 

KNNBCCB

Alfrescian (Inf)
Asset
393425_262531867133469_181333458586644_701209_1334842386_n.jpg


No Porn Lui : Tolay morling no MRT service hor ... blek lown hor...

Pinky : Kin lah... Si Gin Na... Wa ai lim ko pi liao lah...
 

Leongsam

High Order Twit / Low SES subject
Admin
Asset
First it was the Ministerial Salary Review Committee... Now its the Committee Of Inquiry to look into these all these MRT cocked ups... So many committees ...:confused: Next they would set up a Committee of Inquiry on how to deal with those stray dogs that had bitten the poor girl in Punggol few days ago..:rolleyes:

What about a committee to oversee the scope, terms of reference, performance and findings of all various committees tasked with finding out what went wrong as a result of not formulating good practices at committee level.
 

Leongsam

High Order Twit / Low SES subject
Admin
Asset
No Porn Lui : Tolay morling no MRT service hor ... blek lown hor...

Pinky : Kin lah... Si Gin Na... Wa ai lim ko pi liao lah...

Why is high resolution DSLR needed to take pictures of that fart face? Surely a 2 megapixel phone cam would suffice.
 

Loofydralb

Alfrescian
Loyal
Ah Loong's best strategy to solve smrt problem:

Convene a committee.......

Sounds like a Dilbert cartoon strip. Really competence is seriously lacking at the top.

The best organizations would fire the people at the top and the new guy would motivate the ground soldiers (in smrt it would be the legions of nightly maintenance workers as they would be the first to spot any problems).
 

RonRon

Alfrescian
Loyal
Its a joke!! Metro or tube breakdown is daily occurrence in PAris and london and nobody give a shit. KNN MRT breaks down once in a blue moon sinkie want a committee of inquiry?? WTF?
 

Fook Seng

Alfrescian (Inf)
Asset
The more I look at it, the more it doesn't look like a random occurrence but a human error. The required tolerance must have changed or wasn't there in the first place, the first due to human error during maintenance and the second in design. Not so difficult to solve the problem actually.
 

kingrant

Alfrescian
Loyal
A COI is only as good as how it is scoped. I have personally participated in COIs and I know a few have been cleverly crafted so that the scope is on "safe" areas that will not result in e.g. blame, personal attacks, bad judgment, poor strategy, lost of focus by the board etc. Esp. when you ask one scholar mandarin to chair a COI against another colleague who may have been his classmate during Harvard, stanford days etc. you think he's going to sabo him? Usually, the axe fell on the disposables - the part timer staffs, junior ranks, who cannot reply.

Like the MSK case, the outcome is that the lower ranks got bombed for complacency, not omission of top mgmt oversight.



COI will be a waste of time just like the one convened for the escape of MSK. Objectivity is not the cardinal priority. Cover-up is. Should appoint an opposition MP to ensure no cover-up.
 
Last edited:

weetabix

Alfrescian
Loyal
It's called "root cause analysis". No blame with be attributed to anyone except "the process" needs to be tweaked. so , all those baying for blood , waiting to see heads roll -> Dan Gu Gu
 

sammyboi

Alfrescian
Loyal
they must also ensure fully operational airconditioning is functioning, so sexy office ladies can arrive at their ivory towers in a nonsweaty manner.
 
Top