Transport Minister mislead Singaporeans about rail reliability

rusty · Apr 21, 2016

Calling the 100-day major disruption-free on the North South Line (NSL) a “success”, Transport Minister Khaw Boon Wan mischievously misled Singaporeans about the reliability of Singapore’s public railway system.

Minister Khaw cherry-picked the NSL and left out the recent damning report by the Land Transport Authority, which highlighted an increase in train breakdowns. In 2015, there was a total of 14 major MRT train breakdowns, 40% more than 2014’s 10 incidents. For the LRT trains, the number of breakdowns exceeding thirty minutes increased 4-fold to 15 in 2015. The most problematic train system is the Bukit Panjang LRT line, which saw 10 breakdowns in 2015. In summary, there is a train breakdown nearly every 2 weeks in Singapore.

The Malaysia-born Singapore Minister who has never served National Service gave himself a pat on his own shoulder and wax lyrical about success and it being “a game of snakes and ladders”:

“But today’s success does not mean continued success. Any lapse, and we are back to square one, much like a game of snakes and ladders, and the clock is reset.”

You may view his blog post here.

The S$1.1 million Transport Minister is also trying to push the blame of train breakdown to railway maintenance staffs by refusing to apologise or comment on issues whenever there is a train breakdown. Minister Khaw Boon Wan is also known to be heavily political in Parliament, often throwing accusations at Opposition MPs without evidence.http://statestimesreview.com/2016/0...-mislead-singaporeans-about-rail-reliability/

The average speed of the MRT is 50kmh while the average for plane is 200kmh whether landing or take off.
The frequency between planes landing is one minute while the frequency between trains is 3 minutes during peak hours.
MRTs while in motion without breakdown within 100 days is an achievement.
Planes without breakdown while in motion for the last 100 months is pure magic.

eatshitndie · Apr 21, 2016

considering the very hot and humid conditions in sg, this is indeed justification for glorious celebrations.

virus · Apr 21, 2016

Surprisedno one posted on power failure at tpy bus interchange ytd

frenchbriefs · Apr 21, 2016

let the man claim credit while he can ok?its not like whether the train breaks down or not he has any power over it.only bomohs with magic coconuts can predict the next breakdown.

red amoeba · Apr 21, 2016

Saw a msg that there is no MRT svc fr Marina Bay to Newton - Huat ah

scroobal · Apr 21, 2016

These conflicting reports reflects poorly on him. After the Brompton bike affair his credibility hit rock bottom and this makes it more difficult for him and the government. There were a lot of good thing he claimed while in MOH. I am wondering if these were also spin.

rusty said:
The average speed of the MRT is 50kmh while the average for plane is 200kmh whether landing or take off.
The frequency between planes landing is one minute while the frequency between trains is 3 minutes during peak hours.
MRTs while in motion without breakdown within 100 days is an achievement.
Planes without breakdown while in motion for the last 100 months is pure magic.

Satyr · Apr 21, 2016

Notice how quiet they are these days. Pop up now and then to talk about a little good news. In anybody in charge ?

Patriot · Apr 21, 2016

red amoeba said:
Saw a msg that there is no MRT svc fr Marina Bay to Newton - Huat ah

mojito · Apr 21, 2016

If you follow the directions of a lost person, you are not being misled. Just being silly thats all. Why u go do that?

scroobal · Apr 21, 2016

Thats deep and profound bro. And you are right.

mojito said:
If you follow the directions of a lost person, you are not being misled. Just being silly thats all. Why u go do that?

Hans168 · Apr 21, 2016

rusty said:
The average speed of the MRT is 50kmh while the average for plane is 200kmh whether landing or take off.
The frequency between planes landing is one minute while the frequency between trains is 3 minutes during peak hours.
MRTs while in motion without breakdown within 100 days is an achievement.
Planes without breakdown while in motion for the last 100 months is pure magic.

Good point... it proves that papig earning >$$1,000,000 are consummate bullshitters!!
When they can't convince, they will try to confuse you!!! They are all 10 dan blackbelters with 12 dan LeeConYou went up the mountain oredi

Hans168 · Apr 21, 2016

mojito said:
If you follow the directions of a lost person, you are not being misled. Just being silly thats all. Why u go do that?

he who knows not where he is, cannot be lost...............

Hans168 · Apr 21, 2016

eatshitndie said:
considering the very hot and humid conditions in sg, this is indeed justification for glorious celebrations.

humidity provides additional lubrication to mechanical joints.......... so that helps towards 100 daze?

eatshitndie · Apr 21, 2016

Hans168 said:
humidity provides additional lubrication to mechanical joints.......... so that helps towards 100 daze?

nope, the wet condition degrades lubricants, deposits minerals and calcites on insulators, and causes corrosion to metallic surfaces. it's environmentally challenging to run transit operations in tropical cuntries, let alone equatorial ones.

halsey02 · Apr 21, 2016

rusty said:
The average speed of the MRT is 50kmh while the average for plane is 200kmh whether landing or take off.
The frequency between planes landing is one minute while the frequency between trains is 3 minutes during peak hours.
MRTs while in motion without breakdown within 100 days is an achievement.
Planes without breakdown while in motion for the last 100 months is pure magic.

Those numbers given by them are MAGICAL....they are the highest paid MAGICIANS in the world...you believe in their "magic" numbers..then you are one of the "magical creatures"...consisting of the 70% voters.. :biggrin:

johnny333 · Apr 21, 2016

The PAP are used to telling half truths & blatant lies. In the past it may have worked but too many people are being affected by this problem.

There is just no way to hide the problem. As they expand the MRT network, the problem is just going to get worse . The silver lining in this is that it may encourage people to support the opposition :wink:

halsey02 · Apr 21, 2016

Another Milestone today...NEL towards Harbourfront down since this morning ( 6am?).....bus Captains complaining like shit..going off shifts have to do OT...good for them, have OT....doing National Service for Singapore..our CORE workers... three cheers for them...

another milestone... ha ha ha or is it "millstone" ??

halsey02 · Apr 21, 2016

johnny333 said:
The PAP are used to telling half truths & blatant lies. In the past it may have worked but too many people are being affected by this problem.

There is just no way to hide the problem. As they expand the MRT network, the problem is just going to get worse . The silver lining in this is that it may encourage people to support the opposition

You have to give credit to them, they did project the growth of the mass rapid transport when it was built & started in the 1980's....but they didn't factor in..."mee siam mai hum" , OPEN DOOR policy or three countries, one NATION..or was it 4, when you include the "motherlands" ( India included).....the human traffic, is much higher than the projection of early days, that is for sure...& NS/EW Lines....are just 'coping' with the increased & the newer line like NEL....just ok, plus now the circle lines, DT Line...feeding into the grid...

we thank divine providence for protecting the daily commuters that use the mass rapid train lines....say thank god..( PAP god)...ha ha ha ha

yahoo55 · Apr 21, 2016

http://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/singapore/mrt-system-plagued-by-two/2718194.html

MRT system plagued by two breakdowns in a day

Both the North-South Line and North-East Line were hit by train disruptions on Thursday morning (Apr 21).

Updated 21 Apr 2016 13:12

tyudm · Apr 21, 2016

Fuck the minister with that 100-day achievement.
A plane is landing every minute at 5 times the speed of MRT has no problem for the last 100 months or more.

Transport Minister mislead Singaporeans about rail reliability

Alfrescian (Inf)

Alfrescian (Inf)

Alfrescian

Alfrescian (Inf)

Alfrescian (Inf)

Alfrescian

Alfrescian

Alfrescian

Alfrescian

Alfrescian

Alfrescian

Alfrescian

Alfrescian

Alfrescian (Inf)

Alfrescian (Inf)

Alfrescian (Inf)

Alfrescian (Inf)

Alfrescian (Inf)

Alfrescian

Alfrescian

Similar threads