Anything from the PAP is a lose for sinkees. That's a given. You pay, you never get back what you pay.
PAP says they are for low taxes but they levy all kinds of fees and insurance on you ...you end up paying more than taxpayers elsewhere and get back little.
The biggest rip off is the CPF.
PAP pays you 2.5 percent while they earn 8 percent. The 5.5 percent returns taken by the PAP crushed any sinkee's plan for a secure retirement.
How much is lost? If you contribute $10k a year to CPF for 30 years, you see a paltry $460k at the end of period. If that money is invest in SPY (US etf), you get $1 million.
SPY returns $750k vs CPF returns of $150k ...you lost out $600k in returns.