• IP addresses are NOT logged in this forum so there's no point asking. Please note that this forum is full of homophobes, racists, lunatics, schizophrenics & absolute nut jobs with a smattering of geniuses, Chinese chauvinists, Moderate Muslims and last but not least a couple of "know-it-alls" constantly sprouting their dubious wisdom. If you believe that content generated by unsavory characters might cause you offense PLEASE LEAVE NOW! Sammyboy Admin and Staff are not responsible for your hurt feelings should you choose to read any of the content here.

    The OTHER forum is HERE so please stop asking.

Chitchat NTUC Trolley Crisis - solution, more cheap labour

scroobal

Alfrescian
Loyal
Joined
Jul 16, 2008
Messages
25,134
Points
83
The guy is a long standing PAP MP, CEO of NTUC, Colombo Plan scholar, went to Harvard for MBA, and he can't solve this long standing issue for years.

Here are the solutions he and his brainy lot came up with.
- employ trolley enforcement officers.
- get Kindness Movement and school kids to spread the message.
- previously they engaged Town Councils to spread the message.

Many countries have the wheelock system which immobilises the trolley wheels once you cross the designated perimeter. It is so well designed that you can't even see or tamper with the damn thing. Try carrying a trolly with locked wheels.

http://www.channelnewsasia.com/news...-solve-missing-trolleys/3094772.htmlFairPrice launches new initiative to solve missing trolleys problem
By Lim Jia Qi Posted 02 Sep 2016 12:31 Updated 02 Sep 2016 13:17
Abandoned FairPrice trolleys at a park in Singapore. (Photo: Yvonne Lim)


SINGAPORE: To grapple with the problem of missing trolleys, supermarket chain NTUC FairPrice, on Friday (Sep 2), launched an initiative which includes enforcement officers reaching out to customers on returning trolleys.

Named the Trolley Enforcement Project, the initiative hopes to deter shoppers from wheeling trolleys away from the premises, said FairPrice.

It will be piloted at Jurong Point Shopping Mall which experiences the highest incidence of trolley abandonment cases. Up to 200 supermarket trolleys are retrieved daily from around the vicinity of the mall.

About two trolley enforcement officers will be on shift at any time and they will be stationed at the store's exit to educate shoppers on returning trolleys.

"We have decided to pilot this new trolley initiative at Jurong Point Shopping Mall to complement ongoing public education efforts to encourage responsible trolley use," said chief executive officer of FairPrice, Mr Seah Kian Peng.

The supermarket chain lost about 1,000 trolleys last year. This is an increase of almost 20 per cent compared to five years ago, said Mr Seah. FairPrice spends over S$150,000 every year on repairing, replacing and retrieving unreturned trolleys.

As part of the project, FairPrice has also partnered the Singapore Kindness Movement and the Frontier Community Club to involve students to spread the message of responsible trolley use. About 15 students from Jurong West Secondary School will distribute fliers to shoppers as well as residents living in the area.

Campaign collaterals are also on the trolleys to inform customers that trolleys are the property of FairPrice and the supermarket has the right to report those who wheel them out from the mall to the police.

Several measures were introduced by the supermarket chain in previous years to address the ongoing problem of abandoned shopping trolleys. These include exchanging identification cards, perimeter fencing and the coin-lock system.

"But these had limited success in addressing the issue ... shoppers will always find a way to defeat any security system," said Mr Seah.

Mr Seah hopes that the new initiative will complement the supermarket's ongoing efforts to address the problem of abandoned shopping trolleys in Singapore.

"We are always trying new solutions, finding new solutions. We think this is a step forward," he said.

"This is quite a drastic change from the earlier initiatives that we have taken. But we believe that having spoken to the community and the grassroots, they are all supportive, let's do something about it," Mr Seah added.
 
[video=youtube_share;VFUMLyAEMHw]https://youtu.be/VFUMLyAEMHw[/video]

[video=youtube_share;LLuzRfAJ9cU]https://youtu.be/LLuzRfAJ9cU[/video]

[video=youtube_share;3ngF_2jB8SQ]https://youtu.be/3ngF_2jB8SQ[/video]
 
Singapore Kindness Movement has lost its relevancy with Singaporeans.

SKM has been relegated to be a pap mouth piece when it failed to be kind and speak up for Singaporeans who suffered pap abuses. Not many Singaporeans look up to it
 
Fairprice CEO is right in employing more cheap labor. Instead of collecting cardboxes for a living which can be quite physically demanding for people beyond a certain age, they can be employed by Fairprice and given such jobs which are quite senang.
 
Fairprice CEO is right in employing more cheap labor. Instead of collecting cardboxes for a living which can be quite physically demanding for people beyond a certain age, they can be employed by Fairprice and given such jobs which are quite senang.

Will NTUC Fairprice employ younger foreign trash to retrieve the trolleys rather than employ older Singaporeans?
 
Guarantee you they will hire Singaporeans who lost their jobs and then claim how they helped them by publishing in their newsletters etc.

Will NTUC Fairprice employ younger foreign trash to retrieve the trolleys rather than employ older Singaporeans?
 
Why wouldn't they employ the coin operated trolley system there?

Need an MP to figure this out?
 
How does one steal a trolley ? You cannot load it into a car. You have to stow in in a van or larger or just wheel it away ? So unless alot of van drivers are kleptomaniacs, these are just people wheeling them away because they have no cars and live within wheeling distance. If I were them I would simply forget it. Ask people to leave shopping cards in car park bays just give someone a five dollar voucher for alerting them to abandoned carts. Nobody wants the darn thing in their homes anyway. As you say, better use technology. Or embed microchips on carts which will cause an alarm when taken through exit doors or trigger a cctv camera. Or the one you mentioned. Flyers and education ..phooey.
 
Last edited:
They do. For 50cents, people treat it as "rental" fee.

When I was in Taipei, I came out of one their MRT Station, forgot the name, it had these orange coloured bicycles outside the station in which you can rent to ride along designated routes, all you need to do is to buy their season tickets for transportations, that encompasses everything like the Octopus Card in HK. To cut a long story short...they will deduct a deposit amount, you return the bike within the time limit....your deposit will be refunded, if not it will be forfeited plus extra fees will be deducted.

The same, they can do with the shopping trolley!...you use your cash card, & MRT Card whatever card...a deposit of $10 will deducted plus the usage fee of 50 cts...within 1 hr or 2 hrs, you do not return the trolley to the designated return point, outside taxi stands, pick up points ,within the time limit the $10 will be deposited back to account less 50 cts already if not, the next time you use one of their trolleys....the deposit is forfeited & the extra cost of the trolleys will be deducted from your cash card etc...if it is linked to a bank account..better still.

They hang huge sign at the pick up points, taxi stands, Trolley points in the supermarket, the $10 deposit & forfeiture, THE COST OF THE TROLLEY....& you take it with you...the AMOUNT TO BE DEDUCTED.

:D
 
How does one steal a trolley ? You cannot load it into a car. You have to stow in in a van or larger or just wheel it away ? So unless alot of van drivers are kleptomaniacs, these are just people wheeling them away because they have no cars and live within wheeling distance. If I were them I would simply forget it. Ask people to leave shopping cards in car park bays just give someone a five dollar voucher for alerting them to abandoned carts. Nobody wants the darn thing in their homes anyway. As you say, better use technology. Or embed microchips on carts which will cause an alarm when taken through exit doors or trigger a cctv camera. Or the one you mentioned. Flyers and education ..phooey.

I see them at the lift lobby near where I live, every now & then & one day I saw the culprit or culprits....the filipinos that is staying around here pushes there groceries home, all the way from fairprice supermarket.
 
When I was in Taipei, I came out of one their MRT Station, forgot the name, it had these orange coloured bicycles outside the station in which you can rent to ride along designated routes, all you need to do is to buy their season tickets for transportations, that encompasses everything like the Octopus Card in HK. To cut a long story short...they will deduct a deposit amount, you return the bike within the time limit....your deposit will be refunded, if not it will be forfeited plus extra fees will be deducted.

The same, they can do with the shopping trolley!...you use your cash card, & MRT Card whatever card...a deposit of $10 will deducted plus the usage fee of 50 cts...within 1 hr or 2 hrs, you do not return the trolley to the designated return point, outside taxi stands, pick up points ,within the time limit the $10 will be deposited back to account less 50 cts already if not, the next time you use one of their trolleys....the deposit is forfeited & the extra cost of the trolleys will be deducted from your cash card etc...if it is linked to a bank account..better still.

They hang huge sign at the pick up points, taxi stands, Trolley points in the supermarket, the $10 deposit & forfeiture, THE COST OF THE TROLLEY....& you take it with you...the AMOUNT TO BE DEDUCTED.

:D


So it's like ERP for supermarket trolleys except that a refund is given if the trolley is returned.
It will never work if the PAP is involved because a refund is a foreign concept :)
 
If they could get pap help, the problem can easily resolved by having mandatory jail sentence of 24 hrs :D
 
Yeah, its just people going all their way to homes or where they want to drop the good with a car or other transport. These trolleys are then abandoned under blocks, grass verges etc.

I still wondering why these so called scholars need to involve children?? I still cannot get the connection.


How does one steal a trolley ? You cannot load it into a car. You have to stow in in a van or larger or just wheel it away ? So unless alot of van drivers are kleptomaniacs, these are just people wheeling them away because they have no cars and live within wheeling distance. If I were them I would simply forget it. Ask people to leave shopping cards in car park bays just give someone a five dollar voucher for alerting them to abandoned carts. Nobody wants the darn thing in their homes anyway. As you say, better use technology. Or embed microchips on carts which will cause an alarm when taken through exit doors or trigger a cctv camera. Or the one you mentioned. Flyers and education ..phooey.
 
My sense is that they so scared of trying things in case they are labeled failures and therefore come out with simple, low cost but short term remedies. I still cannot believe the CEO is a scholar, Harvard MBA and he comes out with this rubbish and actually gave an interview. All he has to do is google. He is a 3 term MP and I wonder how he is even going to help his residents.


When I was in Taipei, I came out of one their MRT Station, forgot the name, it had these orange coloured bicycles outside the station in which you can rent to ride along designated routes, all you need to do is to buy their season tickets for transportations, that encompasses everything like the Octopus Card in HK. To cut a long story short...they will deduct a deposit amount, you return the bike within the time limit....your deposit will be refunded, if not it will be forfeited plus extra fees will be deducted.

The same, they can do with the shopping trolley!...you use your cash card, & MRT Card whatever card...a deposit of $10 will deducted plus the usage fee of 50 cts...within 1 hr or 2 hrs, you do not return the trolley to the designated return point, outside taxi stands, pick up points ,within the time limit the $10 will be deposited back to account less 50 cts already if not, the next time you use one of their trolleys....the deposit is forfeited & the extra cost of the trolleys will be deducted from your cash card etc...if it is linked to a bank account..better still.

They hang huge sign at the pick up points, taxi stands, Trolley points in the supermarket, the $10 deposit & forfeiture, THE COST OF THE TROLLEY....& you take it with you...the AMOUNT TO BE DEDUCTED.

:D
 
After Harvard no need to use Brains anymore, just sit back, act smart and busy. PAP's style of management
 
Seen the auto locking trolleys in Coles in Australia. Coles is like SG NTUC, but bigger and many more outlets over a large district.

Once out of Coles, 50 meters more and the wheel of trolley locked. Just need trolley boys to periodically collect the trolley.

No need high tech stuff. Simple and effective.

No need scholars, Harvard-trained, nor million-dollar CEO to implement it.
 
My sense is that they so scared of trying things in case they are labeled failures and therefore come out with simple, low cost but short term remedies. I still cannot believe the CEO is a scholar, Harvard MBA and he comes out with this rubbish and actually gave an interview. All he has to do is google. He is a 3 term MP and I wonder how he is even going to help his residents.

as usual lo

all these MPs only know how to be busy eating mangoes

and chasing after papayas

if you dun belive u can ask Ah Luck
 
So it's like ERP for supermarket trolleys except that a refund is given if the trolley is returned.
It will never work if the PAP is involved because a refund is a foreign concept :)

It will work, tell the people, you need to place a $3 deposit plus the 50cts rental & the trolley is not returned to the designated return points within a certain period of time, the cost of the trolley will deducted from THAT card, the next time, they tap to use the trolley. Better still scan in the NRIC after tapping the card.

At the trolley point state clearly the deposit amount & rental & in large bold letters, how much the trolley cost. The super market can make some money from this...just add 100% to the cost..

This sure will stop all missing trolleys....with NRIC....they can send "trolley ah long' to the house too... ha ha ha ha :D
 
Back
Top