China Daily accused of faking an editorial it said was written by a US journalist
Peter Hessler says his quotes were taken out of context and used as an opinion piece
PUBLISHED : Wednesday, 21 January, 2015, 2:34pm
UPDATED : Wednesday, 21 January, 2015, 2:36pm
Associated Press
Peter Hessler. Photo: SCMP Pictures
A New Yorker journalist famed for his reporting from China wrote that the state-run newspaper China Daily faked an editorial under his byline after interviewing him.
Peter Hessler said on Facebook on Tuesday that he did not write the piece posted on China Daily’s website a day earlier entitled “US observer: Comparing Egypt with China” and that his words were taken out of context.
Hessler wrote that the China Daily reporter asked him to compare China with Egypt. Hessler formerly was based in China, but now reports from Egypt.
The resulting editorial repeats Communist Party talking points, lauding China’s stability and education system while suggesting that any changes in China are “likely to be subtle, incremental, and coming from the top”.
After living in Egypt, the editorial reads, “I think I have a better understanding of how essentially stable the Chinese system is.”
The article continues: “It reminds me that in China, even in a tiny village, there was a great deal of government activity. The villagers were very clearly connected to the larger political systems and issues of the country.”
Hessler, however, wrote on Facebook that he was asked mainly about his reflections on the past year and that the piece misrepresented his larger points.
“It omitted crucial parts, including the most important point: that I believe it’s harder to make a political change in China, where the system is deeper rooted than in Egypt, and thus the flaws are also more deeply rooted,” Hessler wrote. “I said that this is the reason why the current anti-corruption campaign will be a failure, because China is not addressing its systemic flaws.”
A China Daily editor said Wednesday she did not have details about the dispute, but would make inquiries.
The newspaper removed the online piece in English, but it remains available in state media in Chinese.
Hessler wrote on Facebook that he asked the China Daily for a retraction, but the paper refused.
Hessler worked in China for about a decade until 2007 and wrote extensively about the country, producing popular books about his experiences there.
