'We're at economic war ': China is playing with fire in Trump battle
Skip to sections navigationSkip to contentSkip to footer
SubscribeLog In
OPENMENU
The Sydney Morning Herald
SUBSCRIBE0 items in Shortlist
SMH RECOMMENDS
'Australia needs a raise': wage-earners have rarely collected a smaller share of the economy
'Australia needs a raise': wage-earners have rarely collected a smaller share of the economy
Add to shortlist
'The worst is yet to come': House prices fall by fastest rate in six years
'The worst is yet to come': House prices fall by fastest rate in six years
Add to shortlist
Death threats and ongoing criticism force Cecchin to quit the NRL
Death threats and ongoing criticism force Cecchin to quit the NRL
Add to shortlist
Labor wins and Coalition reels in Super Saturday byelections
Labor wins and Coalition reels in Super Saturday byelections
Add to shortlist
'Sir Lunchalot' Ian Macdonald's jailhouse blues
'Sir Lunchalot' Ian Macdonald's jailhouse blues
Add to shortlist
A mystery note ended my marriage
A mystery note ended my marriage
Add to shortlist
The economy
Markets
Companies
Banking & finance
Small business
Consumer affairs
Workplace
Advertisement
OPINIONBUSINESSTHE ECONOMYCURRENCIES
'We're at economic war ': China is playing with fire in Trump battle
By Ambrose Evans-Pritchard
3 August 2018 — 1:41pm
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Whatsapp
Send via Email
Normal text sizeLarger text sizeVery large text size
29
View all comments
China's currency slide is moving from benign neglect to something more deliberate. Whether or not you deem it currency warfare, it is playing with political and financial fire.
The yuan has weakened by 9 per cent against the US dollar since mid-April. This is the steepest fall for the micro-managed exchange rate for a quarter century.
This week's blow-off to Y6.84 has been a move too far for Washington. The retort is a cannon shot across the bows. The Trump administration is now threatening to more than double punitive tariffs on a further $US200 billion ($270 billion) of Chinese goods, lifting the rate from 10 per cent to 25 per cent. It smacks of an embargo.
The economic war between the US and China is intensifying.
The economic war between the US and China is intensifying.
Photo: AP
The weak yuan is no longer just a strong US dollar story. The currency has been tumbling against the other big world currencies, the euro and the yen.
China's leaders have breached their pledge to hold the country's currency basket "generally stable". The People's Bank (PBOC) commands $US3.1 trillion of foreign exchange reserves. And it has chosen not to use this firepower to stabilise the yuan.
Advertisement
Trouble ahead
RELATED ARTICLE
Commodity markets shiver as trade tensions rise again
TRADE
Commodity markets shiver as trade tensions rise again
Add to shortlist
What we do not yet know is why Beijing has taken this fateful step. Is it in order to undercut Donald Trump's earlier round of trade tariffs, triggered in early July on the first $US34 billion of Chinese goods? Or because the authorities are losing control, caught between a rock and a hard place as defaults rise and the economy flirts with a hard landing?
Perhaps it is both. Either spells trouble.
"It is a strange mix of a trade war and currency war, and is on the verge of becoming a very unstable situation. It is the biggest topic for global markets right now," said Jens Nordvig, from Exante, in New York.
Advertisement
"China has been hit by several shocks. They still have a few bullets left to fire but they face a tricky balance. They can't stomach a strong currency. It needs to be even weaker," he said.
Nordvig said the pressures pushing down the yuan are obvious: the economy has wilted; interest rates are tumbling. The yield spread between US and Chinese five-year bonds - a key driver of currency moves - has shrivelled to almost nothing.
Policy pirouette
The reserve requirement ratio has been cut three times this year. On Tuesday, the politburo flagged a policy pirouette, effectively suspending its campaign to deflate the credit bubble. It is a return to fiscal stimulus as usual.
Beijing may have let its ferocious crackdown on shadow banking go too far. "The financial deleveraging campaign since early 2017 has resulted in a severe negative shock to aggregate credit supply. The real economy has begun to feel the pain," said Wei Yao from Societe Generale.
Advertisement
"We think that the Chinese government has a good chance of avoiding a financial meltdown in the short term. The more likely risk scenario, to which we assign a 20 per cent probability, is an economic downturn that is deeper and more extended than expected," she said.
The People’s Bank of China has chosen not to use this firepower to stabilise the yuan.
The People’s Bank of China has chosen not to use this firepower to stabilise the yuan.
Photo: Bloomberg
Capital Economics said the pattern from China's stop-go cycles is that it takes 12 months for fresh stimulus to feed through, and it will be a less powerful dosage this time. The economic mood music will get worse before it gets better this year.
China faces a variant of the "impossible trinity". If it loosens monetary policy in these circumstances to shore up the economy, it risks capital flight and a further slide in the currency. Foreign investors have extracted $US100 billion already through the Hong Kong/Shanghai Connect pipeline.
Capital controls are tighter than they were during the Chinese currency crisis of 2015-2016, when the country was losing $US25 billion a week, but they are still leaky. The danger for Beijing is that by letting the yuan fall so far, so fast, it will set off a fresh rush for the exits.
Advertisement
Parallel universe
As this drama unfolds, Washington is in a parallel universe. The Trump administration has seized on the currency warfare hypothesis for the weak yuan. Donald Trump accuses the country of stealing a competitive edge, grouching that the yuan is "dropping like a rock".
Make America great again? The suspicion is that Trump is using the trade war as a smokescreen for the bigger battle - stopping China from becoming a rival superpower.
Make America great again? The suspicion is that Trump is using the trade war as a smokescreen for the bigger battle - stopping China from becoming a rival superpower.
Photo: Bloomberg
The White House counterattack has sharpened this week. Officials are briefing that the threatened rise in tariffs on the next tranche of Chinese exports - televisions, washing machines, clothes, etc - is pitched high enough at 25 per cent to disarm Beijing's currency weapon.
Chinese leaders are struggling to come up with a response to the Trump phenomenon. They have got nowhere trying to fob off Washington with purchases of grains, oil, or liquefied natural gas - fungible commodities that shift the patterns of global trade without changing anything.
Advertisement
The bigger picture
The suspicion is growing that Trump does not really want a trade deal, but rather wants to provoke China into tit-for-tat retaliation in order to carry out a pre-emptive assault on the country's technology-industrial complex before China is fully established as a rival superpower.
Trade policy cannot be separated from the geostrategic clash. The US national security strategy report this year names China for the first time as an adversary that seeks to "challenge American power, influence and interests, attempting to erode American security and prosperity".
Tariffs may just be a smokescreen. The fight is over control of artificial intelligence and the technologies of the 21st century.
Trump has largely purged the China "doves" in his inner circle, lending his ear instead to the quartet of hardliners.
Advertisement
'Unprecedented larcency'
RELATED ARTICLE
Australia on the front line of clash with China, says Steve Bannon
DONALD TRUMP
Australia on the front line of clash with China, says Steve Bannon
Add to shortlist
Their view is that the Communist Party has been engaged in systematic cyber theft of Western know-how - "unprecedented larceny" in the words of secretary of state Mike Pompeo - and that its "Made in China 2025" blueprint is a hostile attempt to dominate 10 strategic sectors.
It relies on a nexus of subsidies and cheap state credit, with party officials lodged on the boards of private companies. It is national mobilisation with a wartime structure.
This was bound to provoke trouble, and it has. "We're at economic war with China. One of us is going to be a hegemon in 25 or 30 years," says Trumpian ideologue Steve Bannon.
Advertisement
All evidence suggests that this is in fact the Trump doctrine.
China is in a bind. Its 35-year phase of catch-up growth is exhausted. It is no longer a particularly dynamic economy. The "middle income trap" looms and it is grappling with a post-bubble hangover. Now it faces Trump.
Du Wanhua, a grand justice at the People's Supreme Court, wrote an extraordinary piece for China's judicial newspaper last week saying the country must prepare for mass insolvency.
"It's hard to predict how this trade war will develop and to what extent. But one thing is sure: if the US imposes tariffs on Chinese imports following an order of $US60 billion, $US200 billion, or even $US500 billion, many Chinese companies will go bankrupt," he said.
The Telegraph, London
Advertisement
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Whatsapp
Send via Email
CURRENCIES
OPINION
TRADE
DONALD TRUMP
CHINA
MOST VIEWED IN BUSINESS
'They're scamming people': Fake 'monks' in Sydney are cashing in
'They're scamming people': Fake 'monks' in Sydney are cashing in
Add to shortlist
'Australia needs a raise': wage-earners have rarely collected a smaller share of the economy
'Australia needs a raise': wage-earners have rarely collected a smaller share of the economy
Add to shortlist
Plastic toys vs plastic bags: Coles' Little Shop drove bag backflip
Plastic toys vs plastic bags: Coles' Little Shop drove bag backflip
Add to shortlist
Here's how little Amazon Australia sold in its first month of trading
Here's how little Amazon Australia sold in its first month of trading
Add to shortlist
Sacked for getting drunk on peach martinis while off duty
Sacked for getting drunk on peach martinis while off duty
Add to shortlist
'We're at economic war ': China is playing with fire in Trump battle
OPINION
'We're at economic war ': China is playing with fire in Trump battle
Add to shortlist
Loading
A relationship banned under traditional law.Our new podcast series from the team behind Phoebe's FallVIEW EPISODES
RECOMMENDED
NATIONAL
No bail for 'angry' youth who bashed US surgeon during Australian Open
NATIONAL
Ex-priest who drugged and raped 12-year-old boy gets reduced jail time
DOMAIN.COM.AU
UDIA awards point to 'quality and innovation' for Sydney developments
BUSINESS
Here's how little Amazon Australia sold in its first month of trading
FROM THE WEB
CARNIVAL CRUISES
Carnival Sale - Honeyboomers save up to $800^ per cabin! ^Ts&Cs Apply
HOME LOAN REPORT
Find out your Borrowing Capacity to Purchase
HOME LOAN REPORT
Find out your Borrowing Capacity to Purchase
AMERICAN EXPRESS
Get 50K Bonus Points with the Amex Explorer Credit Card. T&Cs apply.
MORNINGSTAR NEXT
Why do I need to invest? Isn’t that the whole point of super?
MITSUBISHI
Take a closer look at the all-new crossover SUV
Recommendations powered by plista
The Sydney Morning Herald
Twitter
Facebook
Instagram
RSS
OUR SITES
CLASSIFIEDS
THE SYDNEY MORNING HERALD
PRODUCTS & SERVICES
FAIRFAX MEDIA
Copyright © 2018
Fairfax Media
Feedback
SUBSCRIBE