Charlie, you are right. That was the event that changed SPF. Prior to that no scholars as old man wanted to tried and tested folks to rise thru the ranks. In the old days, 60s, 70s, 80s, the PC will go all the way to AC and entry level Inspector may not even advance.
After the 3 clowns were posted, it was heralded as proven talent introduced from SAF Scholar cadres. A few years later old man himself revealed that those who failed the SAF Wrangler scheme was sent to the Police and there was only 3 and all 3 were posted out together. MHA by then had come to come of this and refused further transfer and create their old Scholarship scheme. It however was hit and miss. 3 turned out to be outstanding, one from each of the first 3 batch . First one became am MP and runs his family business (loaded to the hilt, nice guy), Second guy will be your new PM and 3rd guy is watching over the country's entire security apparatus. There is 4th one and is groomed to be the next CP and he certainly will be streets ahead of previous scholar CPs.
Ask the SPF to reveal the resignation rate of entry level male non-scholar graduate Inspectors / ASP - it is close to 95% over 20 years.
The Little Indian Riot is the outcome of the rot.
As for the SAF, there is no opportunity to date to test them in a real life scenario unlike Little India. After the riots, one truly wonders if it is hollow shell with expensive toys. Its like the PRC Army that went into North Vietnam to teach them a lesson. In the end they were taught a lesson and quickly retreated. The Same with the Indian Army who were decimated by Tamil Tigers ( a rag tag bunch ) In Sri Lanka and retreated with their tails behind their back. And for that incursion, the PM was assassinated as payback.
In all the 3 countries, the state media and propaganda are notorious for their nationalistic fervour.
With respect, I speculate that it went down the drain, with that former SAFOS, whose men went AWOL (at 1 SIR), and he (as well as CCK) were sent to the SPF.
He became the Commissioner, and stayed there for an extended period of time.
There are a few who are able and competent.
But the Little India riots demonstrated that at least one of their senior officers could not handle a live and happening evolving situation, even with all the weapons and assets at their disposal.