• IP addresses are NOT logged in this forum so there's no point asking. Please note that this forum is full of homophobes, racists, lunatics, schizophrenics & absolute nut jobs with a smattering of geniuses, Chinese chauvinists, Moderate Muslims and last but not least a couple of "know-it-alls" constantly sprouting their dubious wisdom. If you believe that content generated by unsavory characters might cause you offense PLEASE LEAVE NOW! Sammyboy Admin and Staff are not responsible for your hurt feelings should you choose to read any of the content here.

    The OTHER forum is HERE so please stop asking.

The Singapore Dream Was a One-Time Offer

k1976

k1976

Alfrescian
Loyal
Joined
May 16, 2023
Messages
43,497
Points
113
Your parents didn’t work harder. They arrived earlier.

If you grew up in Singapore, you know the story by heart.

Your parents tell it at dinner. Teachers reinforce it at school. The government builds policy around it. Work hard, study hard, make good choices, and you’ll get ahead. Your parents did it—started with nothing, bought an HDB through discipline and sacrifice, watched it appreciate, maybe upgraded to private property. The system is fair. The ladder is real. If you’re not climbing, look at yourself before you blame the structure.

For a long time, this was true.

The generation that bought HDB flats in the 1980s and 1990s really did see their wealth compound. A flat that cost $30,000 became worth $500,000 or more. CPF contributions grew when interest rates were higher. Careers advanced as the economy expanded at double digits. The people who followed the script actually got what they were promised.

So when they tell their children the same story, they’re not lying. They’re describing their own experience. The problem is that the experience doesn’t transfer.
 

Something stopped adding up​

Young Singaporeans are working. They’re educated—often more credentialed than their parents were at the same age. They’re making what look like reasonable salaries. And yet the things their parents achieved by thirty feel increasingly out of reach.

The BTO queue stretches years. The resale market feels impossible. Private property might as well be another country. Couples delay marriage because they can’t secure housing.

For a while, this got explained away. You’re not saving enough. Your expectations are too high. The system works—you just need to work it better.

But the gap kept widening. And at some point, the explanations stopped making sense.
 

The math that breaks the promise​

Between 2019 and 2024, private home prices rose 37.5%. Over the same period, real median income grew by 0.7% per year.

Not per month. Per year.

The price-to-income ratio—what a home costs relative to annual earnings—has climbed from 13.6x to 14.6x. That single point represents years of additional work to reach what your parents reached with less.

When two-thirds of Singaporeans say housing is unaffordable for young people, they’re not complaining. They’re reading the market correctly.

But here’s what the data doesn’t explain: if wages can’t support these prices, how is the market still functioning? How are units still selling?
 

The hidden entry ticket​

Three words: intergenerational wealth transfer.

Around 959,000 Singaporeans—roughly 27% of the population—are between 55 and 74 years old. This generation bought property when prices were a fraction of what they are now. They rode decades of appreciation. They also had fewer children, which means the wealth they accumulated gets concentrated rather than diluted.

Now they’re doing what any parent would do: helping their kids buy homes.

The market has come to depend on this. Not as a bonus for lucky families, but as a structural requirement. Without parental cash for the down payment, without family support to bridge the gap between what salaries can service and what properties cost, the upgrader pathway from HDB to private is effectively closed.

This happens quietly, inside families, which is why it doesn’t show up in official narratives. But anyone who’s tried to buy property in Singapore in the last five years knows the reality.

The question isn’t whether you work hard. It’s whether your parents got in early enough to help you now.
 

Who it still works for—and who it doesn’t​

For the poorest families, the system actually works. Research from NUS found that children whose parents benefited from affordable public housing are significantly more likely to surpass their parents’ housing status. HDB still creates mobility for the bottom half.

But the squeeze isn’t at the bottom. It’s in the middle.

Middle-class families trying to move from public to private housing—the trajectory that defined success for the previous generation—now face a different market entirely. The pathway exists on paper. In practice, it requires inheritance.
 

The wealth gap behind the GDP​

Singapore’s economy keeps growing. GDP per capita ranks among the highest in the world.


But wealth inequality worsened by 22.9% between 2008 and 2023—the sharpest increase among all economies tracked by UBS. Real income growth slowed to 1.4% in 2024, despite the glowing macro numbers.

The disconnect is simple: GDP includes corporate profits and investment returns that flow to shareholders, not workers. National wealth rises. Individual purchasing power flatlines.

The people who got in early captured positions that now compound automatically. Their children inherit not just property but access—to down payments, to networks, to the soft advantages that become hard ones. Everyone else competes with wages alone
 

What the story obscures​

The meritocracy narrative isn’t a lie. It’s a description of how things used to work, applied to conditions that no longer exist.

Work hard, get ahead—that equation balanced when asset prices and wages moved together. When an HDB cost three years’ salary instead of fifteen. When the gap between public and private housing was a stretch, not a chasm.

Those conditions created the generation now sitting on seven-figure flats, telling their kids the same story that worked for them. They’re not wrong about their experience. They’re wrong about its transferability.

Young Singaporeans aren’t failing to work hard. They’re playing a different game with the same rulebook—and the rules no longer match the board.
 

The offer that expired​

The Singapore Dream was real. For those who arrived at the right time, it delivered exactly what it promised. Hard work translated into ownership, ownership into appreciation, appreciation into security and options.

But the dream was also a product of specific conditions: rapid growth, low asset bases, policy designed for a building nation rather than a built one. Those conditions created a one-time transfer of wealth to whichever generation happened to be buying during the boom decades.

That generation is now ageing. Their children are competing—against each other, with inherited advantages, for assets their parents locked up long ago.

The system still preaches effort as the deciding variable. The math says otherwise.

This isn’t about resentment or giving up. It’s about honesty. The advice doesn’t match the market anymore. And until that’s acknowledged, every conversation about effort and outcomes in Singapore will miss the structural reality underneath.
 
k1976 said:

What the story obscures​

The meritocracy narrative isn’t a lie. It’s a description of how things used to work, applied to conditions that no longer exist.

Work hard, get ahead—that equation balanced when asset prices and wages moved together. When an HDB cost three years’ salary instead of fifteen. When the gap between public and private housing was a stretch, not a chasm.

Those conditions created the generation now sitting on seven-figure flats, telling their kids the same story that worked for them. They’re not wrong about their experience. They’re wrong about its transferability.

Young Singaporeans aren’t failing to work hard. They’re playing a different game with the same rulebook—and the rules no longer match the board.
Click to expand...
Machiam meaning new gen are playing Dungeon and Dragons game with Hero Unlimited Rule Book…no wonder so many new Foreign Talents class NPC Cosplayers join the game :)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

W
All 12k household stupid sinkies no ask their MPs and HDBs where are the infra and transportation network now and end 2025? HDB provide free trans?
Replies
2
Views
416
Boonsiong
B
Yuletide
'Men have it tougher in life': Woman's TikTok clip sparks lively online debate
Replies
3
Views
375
sbfuncle
sbfuncle
W
Marry 1 of the 4 daughters better than strike Jackpot TOTO First Prize. Potong and marry all 4, U confirm more shiok than become Sultan
Replies
11
Views
1K
A Singaporean
A Singaporean
glockman
If you grew up in the 1960s or 70s, you probably learned these 10 life lessons
2 3
Replies
48
Views
6K
birdie69
B
W
Time for all the Daft Papaya Voters to standby cash to flip flip invest in properties to huat big big together with the new papayas ... huat ah!
Replies
0
Views
904
WangChuk
W
Back
Top