Vaccine scandal highlights public’s lack of trust in the Chinese government
PUBLISHED : Sunday, 27 March, 2016, 11:37pm
UPDATED : Monday, 28 March, 2016, 12:06am
Wang Xiangwei
[email protected]
It started as a piece of good news on February 23 when Xinhua reported that police in Shandong had arrested
a mother and daughter on suspicion of having illegally sold improperly stored or expired vaccines worth more than 570 million yuan (HK$679 million) across 24 provinces since 2011.
But the news failed to capture the public’s attention until a news website controlled by the Shanghai municipal government published a follow-up report on March 18 with a catchier headline that noted the vaccines could cause death. It was immediately picked up by the social media accounts of mainstream media such as the People’s Daily and China Central Television.
It has since fermented rapidly into the biggest health care scandal of recent years. Premier Li Keqiang ordered a thorough investigation and even the World Health Organisation issued a statement. Local media suggested some mainland mothers planned to bring their children to Hong Kong for vaccinations, raising concerns over whether local facilities could cope with the influx.
As mind-boggling as it is, how the good news could degenerate into a crisis for the government is another sad reminder of its deep-rooted propensity to withhold information vital to the public interest and its lack of credibility in the eyes of ordinary citizens.
Subsequent reports have suggested massive corruption and lack of effective supervision by the government authorities in production, transport, storage, and sale of vaccines.
As the official China Daily commented: “The authorities have nobody but themselves to blame for the disbelief and mistrust they face.”
The Xinhua report said the arrests were made in April 2015 and the case was then transferred to the supervision of the Ministry of Public Security and the China Food and Drug Administration in Beijing. This suggested the central government regulators had known about the seriousness of the case for nearly one year.
But even with the latest reports focusing public attention and anger on the snowballing scandal, regulators have been slow to react.
Even the WHO acted faster. On Tuesday, it acknowledged the reports and said the improperly or expired vaccines seldom caused any toxic reactions and thus posed minimal health risks.
It was only after Wednesday when state media reported that Li had ordered a thorough probe and a timely response to the public concerns that the regulators shifted into high gear, holding their first press conference on Thursday, nearly a week after the reports began to cause panic among the public.
At the press conference, the officials admitted most of the problematic vaccines had been used and flaws in the supervision of vaccine distribution were to blame.
They tried to reassure the public by echoing the WHO’s statement that the health risk was minimal. But it was too little, too late given the public’s anger and distrust. They have had too many experiences of officials attempting cover-ups or downplaying scandals that are a matter of life and death – such as the melamine-spiked milk powder scandal and the Sars epidemic.
Many have questioned how a mother and a daughter could so easily set up a distribution network that remained undetected and unsupervised for so long, especially as it involved dozens of pharmaceutical firms and hundreds of salesmen and an unknown number of clinics.
Moreover, this came to light after Caixin, a leading investigative publication, published a detailed report in 2013 chronicling the malpractices in production and sales of the vaccines which resulted in the deaths of children.
There is no doubt that, as this case has received attention from the highest level of government, the culprits and those officials found in dereliction of duty will be duly punished. But will the regulators learn a lesson? After all, the first chief of the food and drug administration was executed on corruption charges in 2007. These included charges of approving unsafe drugs that had caused dozens of fatalities.
Even more importantly, officials’ bad handling of this scandal has put another serious dent in the credibility of the government.
But the news failed to generate much public attention until an online news website controlled by the Shanghai municipal government published a follow-up report on March 18 with a catchier headline that noted the vaccines could cause death. It was immediately picked up by the social media accounts of other mainstream media such as the People’s Daily and China Central Television.
It has since fermented rapidly into the biggest healthcare scandal of recent years. Premier Li Keqiang ordered a thorough investigation and the World Health Organisation deemed it necessary to issue a statement. Local media reports suggested some mainland mothers planned to bring their children to Hong Kong for vaccinations, raising concerns over whether local facilities could cope with the influx.
As mind-boggling as it is, how the good news could degenerate into a crisis for the Chinese government is another sad reminder of its deep-rooted propensity to withhold information vital to the public interest and its lack of trust and credibility in the eyes of ordinary mainlanders. The subsequent reports have also suggested massive corruption and lack of effective supervision by the government authorities in production, transport, storage, and sale of vaccines.
As the official China Daily commented: “The authorities have nobody but themselves to blame for the disbelief and mistrust they face.”
Indeed, the initial Xinhua report said the arrests were made in April 2015 and the case was then transferred to the direct supervision of the Ministry of Public Security and the China Food and Drug Administration in Beijing. This suggested the central government regulators had known about the seriousness of the case for nearly one year.
But even with the latest media reports focusing public attention and anger on the snowballing scandal, regulators have been slow to react.
Even the WHO acted faster, by releasing a statement on Tuesday acknowledging the reports and saying that the improperly or expired vaccines seldom caused any toxic reaction and thus posed minimal health risk.
It was only after Wednesday when state media reported that Li had ordered a thorough probe and a timely response to the public concerns that the regulators shifted into high gear, holding their first press conference on the issue on Thursday, nearly one week after the reports began to cause panic and concerns among the public.
At the press conference, the officials admitted that most of the problematic vaccines had been used and flaws in the supervision of vaccine distribution were to blame.
They tried to reassure the public by echoing the WHO statement that the health risk was minimal. But it was too little too late given the public’s anger and distrust. They have had too many experiences of officials attempting cover-ups or underplaying scandals that are a matter of life and death – such as the melamine-spiked milk powder scandal and the Sars epidemic.
Many have questioned how a mother and a daughter could so easily set up a distribution network that remained undetected and unsupervised for so long, especially given it involved dozens of pharmaceutical firms and hundreds of salesmen and an unknown number of clinics.
Moreover, this came to light after Caixin, one of the country’s leading investigative publications, published a detailed report in 2013 chronicling the malpractices in production and sales of the vaccines which resulted in the deaths of children.
There is no doubt that as this case has received attention from the highest level of government, the culprits and those officials found in dereliction of duty will be duly punished. But will the regulators learn a lesson? After all, the first chief of the food and drug administration was executed on corruption charges in 2007. These included charges of approving unsafe drugs that had caused dozens of fatalities.
Even more importantly, officials’ bad handling of this scandal has put another serious dent in the credibility of the government.
