• IP addresses are NOT logged in this forum so there's no point asking. Please note that this forum is full of homophobes, racists, lunatics, schizophrenics & absolute nut jobs with a smattering of geniuses, Chinese chauvinists, Moderate Muslims and last but not least a couple of "know-it-alls" constantly sprouting their dubious wisdom. If you believe that content generated by unsavory characters might cause you offense PLEASE LEAVE NOW! Sammyboy Admin and Staff are not responsible for your hurt feelings should you choose to read any of the content here.

    The OTHER forum is HERE so please stop asking.

PRC only got fined for causing death to cyclist

K

Kotaro Fuma

Guest

Jun 13, 2011

Pedestrian fined for causing hurt to cyclist

By Elena Chong

ST_20445182.jpg


Xu Yuanyuan, 19, was fined $1,500 for failing to keep a proper lookout at a pedestrian and causing hurt by colliding with a cyclist who, as a result, died from injuries sustained. -- ST PHOTO: KEVIN LIM


A PEDESTRIAN stepped onto the road without looking to the right and collided with a cyclist who died five hours later.

On Monday, Xu Yuanyuan, 19, a Chinese national, was fined $1,500 after she admitted to causing hurt to cleaner Lock Wai Chee, 42, by doing a negligent act as to endanger his life.

The court heard that Xu, a student, was waiting at the pavement of the Jalan Bukit Merah by Henderson Road junction on Dec 21 last year when she took a step forward when the traffic signal was against her.

As a result, she collided into the cyclist who was cycling towards her from her right side along Henderson Road.

Mr Lock was thrown off the bicycle and suffered serious head injuries. He died at 10.19pm.

Xu could have been jailed for up to six months and/or fined up to $2,500.


 

bic_cherry

Alfrescian
Loyal
Jun 13, 2011
Pedestrian fined for causing hurt to cyclist
Elena Chong...

But according to
HOME > BREAKING NEWS > SINGAPORE > STORY
Jun 13, 2011
Pedestrian fined for causing hurt to cyclist- By Elena Chong
And as the photo says:
"Xu Yuanyuan, 19, was fined $1,500 for failing to keep a proper lookout at a pedestrian and causing hurt by colliding with a cyclist who, as a result, died from injuries sustained. -- ST PHOTO: KEVIN LIM"

I think the court was perhaps fair to say that the girl only caused 'hurt' but was not solely responsible for the cyclist death.

Contributing factors for the cyclist death were:
  1. Failure to keep look out for pedestrians or other road obstructions ahead with resultant failure to warn/ take necessary evasive action.
  2. Failure to keep bike in serviceable condition (front brakes were faulty.)
  3. Failure to wear adequate protective gear (helmet not worn).
  4. Failure to slow down and take extra precautions on approaching a road traffic intersection (get ready for changes in traffic signal/ other road hazards).
  5. Riding at an excessive speed/ carelessly/ recklessly as inferred from [2], [3] and [4] and the fact that he most probably totally didn't see Ms Xu "taking a step forward".
  6. (** It is unknown which direction Mr Lock was cycling from, however, Henderson Road in the direction towards Alexandra road is a downward sloping road of fairly steep downward sloping gradient and Mr Lock, if he was traveling in this direction, could have been cycling too fast, focusing on beating the traffic light rather then on riding defensively.)
Actually the criminal fine is PEANUTS compared to what would become of the case if the family of Mr Lock (deceased) sues the girl for being a NEGLIGENT PEDESTRIAN and causing a bread winner's death... the damages could come to tens if not hundreds of thousands... anyhow, my guess it that in such a case, the damages should be split with the main considerations in liability being: in whose favor was the green light in- just because it was red man for Ms Xu doesn't necessarily mean that it was green light for Mr Lock.
Mr Lock was also irresponsible for not keeping adequate lookout and cycling too fast considering the fact that he was riding without helmet and that his bicycle's brakes were worn and ineffective.

Jx-+Jalan+Bukit+Merah+and+Henderson+Road.JPG

Henderson+Rd+Jx.+w+JnBtMerah+dirn+towards+TBlangah+Rd.JPG


jaywalker_fined_1500_for_causing_cyclists_death-thumbnail.jpg

Jaywalker fined $1,500 for causing cyclist's death
14 Jun 2011
SOURCE: The Straits Times
A teenager, who stepped onto the road without looking and caused a cyclist to crash into her and die, was fined $1,500 yesterday.
The cyclist, Mr Lock Wai Chee, 42, suffered head injuries after he was thrown off his bicycle and died five hours later in hospital.
Xu Yuanyuan, 19, a Chinese national, admitted to causing hurt to the cleaner by doing a negligent act to endanger life in the incident at the junction of Jalan Bukit Merah and Henderson Road.
The student at East Asia Institute of Management was with a schoolmate at the road junction at about 5.15pm on Dec 21 last year when she failed to keep a proper lookout.
The court heard she “took a step forward” onto the road when the “red man” was showing, resulting in the collision with Mr Lock, who was then cycling towards her from her right along Henderson Road.
She admitted to the police that the traffic signal was against her.
She also said she did not see the cyclist although she was wearing her spectacles and her view was not obstructed.
An autopsy on Mr Lock concluded that the injuries he sustained were consistent with him colliding with a pedestrian, being thrown off a bicycle and hitting his head on the road.
The court was not told if Xu was injured.
The bicycle was later inspected and its front brake pads were found to be worn and ineffective.
Xu, who was not represented by a lawyer, said she hoped the court would not jail her, to avoid having a problem with her stay here.
Assistant Public Prosecutor Gayathri Krishnan said the prosecution was not asking for a jail term but for a heavy fine to be imposed.
District Judge Kessler Soh told Xu: “I hope you will be more careful in future when you cross the road. It is very unfortunate that death was caused in this case.”
She could have been jailed for up to six months or fined up to $2,500 or jailed and fined.
Last year , 16 cyclists died on the roads in Singapore, one fewer than in 2009.
Even so, cycling groups The Straits Times spoke to called for riders to maintain their bikes regularly, cycle defensively and wear helmets, a practice that has not caught on here.
Both the Singapore Amateur Cycling Association (Saca) and the Safe Cycling Task Force said Mr Lock’s life could have been saved if he had been wearing a helmet.
The law currently makes it mandatory only for users of motorised bicycles to wear helmets.
“A helmet would greatly reduce the chances of head injury because it will absorb some of the impact,” said Mr Steven Lim, the task force’s president.
Mr Tham Chen Munn, Saca’s vice-president for safety and leisure, said some cyclists do not wear helmets because of the heat, lack of awareness and cost.
Helmets can cost from about $20 to a few hundred dollars.
Mr Tham and Mr Lim pointed out that it was dangerous to ride with faulty front brakes.
“Many of us take it for granted, but maintaining your bike and making sure it is in proper condition is very important,” Mr Lim said.
 
Last edited:

CheesePie

Alfrescian (Inf)
Asset
But according to

Save it. 154th are still reporters with borders and biased. OA clones has been posting news here since 2008. Maybe you should dig up the archives as well, those with catchy titles that requires attention. :biggrin:

It's hardly news when infos like gender, names, nationalities are left out.
 
Top